4 ms·
I don't know what this means, but local franchise fees are in fact taxes.
by tptacek 3y ago
I don't know what this means, but local franchise fees are in fact taxes.
- m463 3y agoThe ISPs allow you to add "free television" with your internet service, then it turns out to be very NOT free. They do get lots of ad revenue even though they "don't charge" for the TV.
- tekknik 3y agoThis comment doesn’t make a lot of sense, and with all the quotes it’s hard to tell if you mean it’s actually free or not. If they are not charging you for the TV service then why are you complaining about ads? Complain about paying for ads, not getting an ad supported service for free.
- m463 3y agoYears ago when signing up with a cable isp, I was offered cable television/cable box for no additional cost. Except no additional cost sidestepped the monthly surcharges and taxes that ended up on the bill anyway.
- eli 3y agoI just pulled up an old comcast bill and it has: "Federal Cost Recovery Fee" and "Universal Service Fund Surcharge (State)" and "Utility User’s Tax /Business" and "Universal Connectivity Charge" and "911 Line Tax (State)"
- tptacek 3y agoThose are all pass-through fees. They are just taxes.
- eli 3y agoThey are not just taxes. Reimbursing the telco for their compliance costs makes about as much sense and reimbursing a restaurant for complying with local health code. If they were actually taxes Comcast wouldn’t be fighting this rule, which does not apply to government mandated taxes.
- tptacek 3y agoI tracked down the FCC filing this article is about and read it. They are just taxes. There may be other things in the FCC rule that aren't about taxes, but the NCTA's objection is exclusively to the taxes.
- deelowe 3y agoLike most things, the government creates a problem then convinces everyone they aren't the reason. I can't get broadband at my home despite being less than a mile from multiple providers in 3 different directions. I literally have an att fiber running down my row to a neighborhood less than a mile a way. After being pissed at att for several years I finally looked into it and realized the county won't approve att putting in the service for anything but developer projects. Basically crony capitalism...
- sangnoir 3y agoDo you think ATT is for or against not having to compete on every block?
- tptacek 3y agoMost of these fees have nothing to do with exclusivity, and for the most part AT&T and Comcast don't get exclusivity in their franchise agreements. Go look yours up (your city or township should make it very simple to find, and if it doesn't, there's a reason for that!) and see if they got exclusivity.
- deelowe 3y agoI don't follow. In my specific case there has been one developer locked up already for collusion with the county so I think I'm fair in assuming the issue is not ATT in this case. Plus what's stopping Comcast from coming down my street other than the countys rules about new developments only?
- ljm 3y agoIn the UK, for most bills, it is line rental + provider fee. Line rental is to pay for the copper wiring that is still used for landline phones and all of the infra for it (via local loop unbundling). It goes to OpenReach and every ISP resells it unless they plant their own infra (Virgin, Hyperoptic)
- Jochim 3y agoMost ISPs sell broadband only plans now, even on copper installations.
- lokar 3y agoWhen you eat at a restaurant do you see property tax on the bill? It is a cost of doing business, everyone has them.
- tptacek 3y agoWhen I eat at a restaurant, that business is not paying a per-seating fee to the city it's sited in. But that's what the ISPs are doing.
- lokar 3y agoWhy does that matter?
- tptacek 3y agoBecause property taxes are a predictable, fixed fee, and ISP fees are usage taxes applied per-customer. Let's make this imaginary restaurant more fun: not only is it required to charge a per-seating fee, but it's not the same fee for each customer. Instead, they have to inquire about the residential address of each guest, and compute a locality-specific seating fee.
- woobar 3y agoIsn't fee based on location of where the service is provided? My ISP at the rental property doesn't care about my residential address. They only care about the address where their service is consumed. You can stop worrying about that restaurant, they will charge same fee all their customers as long as they don't deliver.
- tptacek 3y agoThis is about labeling requirements at the point of sale, not about about the details of your bill, which already list these fees.
- 3y ago
- gamblor956 3y agoAs a tax lawyer, I must rebut your ridiculous claim that "franchise fees are in fact taxes." Franchise fees are fees paid by an ISP for the right to provide their service in a territory; paying the franchise fee entitles the ISP to access the public right of way (such as by installing lines under roads, in sewers, etc.). That they happen to commonly be calculated as a % of gross charges paid by ISP customers is irrelevant; royalties are calculated the same way and nobody calls a royalty a tax.
- AmericanChopper 3y agoSo it’s a compulsory contribution to state revenue levied by the government and added to the cost of the service? Because that’s what a tax is… > a compulsory contribution to state revenue, levied by the government on workers' income and business profits, or added to the cost of some goods, services, and transactions.
- lmm 3y agoSounds like it's not compulsory though? The ISP is perfectly welcome to lay their lines via private lands (having negotiated permission with each landowner, naturally) if they'd prefer.
- AmericanChopper 3y agoWell it’s not compulsory to pay your vehicle registration tax either, if you only want to drive your vehicle on private land.
- lmm 3y agoI wouldn't consider that a "tax" either if that's all it's for. Do you consider national park entrance passes to be a tax?
- AmericanChopper 3y agoContrived arguments about whether something is a tax or a user fee has been a feature of politically motivated spin since basically forever. I would say any essential service (like access to internet, roads, healthcare, etc…) that requires for money to be paid to the government is taxes. There is no way to get access to the internet without paying these taxes to the government, and your suggestion to implement a private-land-only infrastructure is silly. There is no contiguous area of private land between my house and an ISP POP that doesn’t cross over publicly owned land. That’s almost certainly true for you too, and anybody else who’s reading this.