4 ms·
> Most people forget that Russia gave NATO an ultimatum[1] in December 2021 More people forget that Russia gave NATO an ultimatum in 2008 regarding giving MAPs
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Most people forget that Russia gave NATO an ultimatum[1] in December 2021
More people forget that Russia gave NATO an ultimatum in 2008 regarding giving MAPs to Georgia and Ukraine, and when NATO complied by not doing so, just as Russia demanded, Russia immediately invaded Georgia, and once that conflict went from active to mostly frozen, immediately invaded Ukraine as soon as they again didn’t have a Russia-compliant leader.
And the same people seem to forget that the ultimatum in 2021 was during the war of aggression launched in 2014, not before a conflict that started later.
- reducesuffering 3y agoYep. The informed analysis around the NATO ultimatum before the invasion was that it was not in good-faith. It was a non-starter to be used as another pretext, not actually something NATO can fulfill all of, or even if they did, wouldn't deter the problems Russian kleptocracy are facing (a prosperous west-aligned Ukraine, like Poland, that shows their neighbors they are being swindled by corrupt oligarchs.)
- brabel 3y agoI think that any war starts when the demands of one side are considered as "non-starters" to the other side. If that was not the case, there simply would be no war.
- reducesuffering 3y agoWell Ukraine was invaded, but they aren't a part of NATO. You should take into account there are times when war can be avoided by compromise, and there are times when the "demands" are essentially "give us all territory, sovereignty, and resources." If you would like to lump those together as the victim not negotiating enough because the aggressor submitted "non-starters," that's on you. If you actually want to understand the problems with the Russian invasion-pretext demands at the time, there's https://twitter.com/DAlperovitch/status/1473362460673515527 https://twitter.com/DAlperovitch/status/1473362460673515527
- brabel 3y ago> and there are times when the "demands" are essentially "give us all territory, sovereignty, and resources." This was not one of those times. If you look at the demands in the ultimatum, Ukraine actually just had to NOT do anything (e.g. do not continue process to join NATO).
- dragonwriter 3y ago> If you look at the demands in the ultimatum, Ukraine actually just had to NOT do anything (e.g. do not continue process to join NATO). First, this ultimatum was after (by 7 years) the beginning of rhe invasion, not before. Second, the content described is false. In fact, while the threat was implicitly directed at Ukraine, and that’s where the escalation of the ongoing war occurred, the ultimatum’s demands were directed largely at other countries: it demanded that NATO make a binding commitment not to admit any new members (with no time limit) especially Ukraine and Georgia [0], and that NATO make a binding commitment not to deploy additional non-local troops in existing NATO member-states, that NATO withdraw troops and infrastructure from states, including NATO members, that were former members of the Soviet Union, that NATO recognize a special Russian role in ensuring stability and security among the former Soviet states, that Russia receive international guarantees of respect for its sovereignty and territorial security, including over Crimea (which it was illegally occupying and had claimed to annex) and the Donbass (wherr it was sponsoring separatists but had not yet formally claimed to annex), and the establishment of a moratorium on short- and intermediate-range missiles in Europe, and reforms of the OSCE. [0] this part alone was an major expansion of the 2008 ultimatum not to offer MAPs at that tine to Ukraine and Georgia which, when NATO acceded to when it was made, Russia immediately invaded Georgia.
- brabel 3y agoRead what you've just written and tell me how that equates to "when the "demands" are essentially "give us all territory, sovereignty, and resources."!!! The Russian demands amounted basically to getting the guarantees they "believed" they had when the USSR collapsed but that were never fully accepted by NATO [1]. I agree they were unrealistic, as to make such demands Russia would need to actually have the upper hand militarily, which it hasn't had even before it was still the USSR. However, saying that they were unacceptable offhand was a clear sign that NATO didn't respect Russia even enough to sit and have a talk. That's the modern equivalent of defenestrating [2] the Russians. They knew they wouldn't get all their demands, but probably expected to get "something" (perhaps a new Treat with Ukraine that ensured it didn't join NATO - would that be better than a multi-year war?? I say absolutely!!) - but all they got was a big fuck you. Invading Ukraine was irrational, I totally agree with that as clearly it would cause a huge divide in the world that just didn't need to come back, but after being thrown out of the window when approaching for negotiations, I suppose that's not exactly unexpected. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20220222223845/https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics_111767.htm#c203 https://web.archive.org/web/20220222223845/https://www.nato.... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defenestrations_of_Prague https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defenestrations_of_Prague
- brabel 3y ago> immediately invaded Ukraine as soon as they again didn’t have a Russia-compliant leader. The fact that the Russia-compliant leader was democratically elected, and was removed from power not by democratic means, but by a revolution in which one side was directly supported by Russia, and the other by the USA [1] shows that the situation is much more complex than that. > And the same people seem to forget that the ultimatum in 2021 was during the war of aggression launched in 2014, That's true and the fact Russia was prepared to do that after Ukraine started going directly against its interests should have shown that they were absolutely not afraid to start a war over the issue, and Ukraine knew all too well it was playing with fire by continuing on the exact same path. Are we going to just pretend that when your country has just lost a huge are to a larger neighbour who doesn't like the direction you're moving towards, that the right thing to do is to double down on that direction and hope that you'll have the support of your neighbour's enemies when conflict eventually comes is a sustainable way to govern? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity#Foreign_involvement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity#Foreign_...
- jacquesm 3y agoWhy do you continue to spout Russian propaganda and disinformation? By now all of this stuff has been solidly debunked and yet you persist.
- brabel 3y agoListen here: I have done the utmost effort to present the facts as they're. You choose to call my arguments, which are based in nothing that's not widely accepted by anyone who actually read what's going on for more than a few seconds, propaganda, while probably believing your narrative (which is basically Russia bad - Ukraine good) is completely propaganda-free?! Please illuminate me: what have I said that has been debunked?
- Melting_Harps 3y ago`> Please illuminate me: what have I said that has been debunked? The fact that they invaded Georgia, during Xi's Olympics no less and did it again in Ukraine during the Winter Olympics, after the West capitulated and the 'separatist' argument was used to justify this abomination [0]. The same was done in '14, and then in '22 to justify it's illegal annexations and war; nothing Russia has done in good faith and their pretext for war is something akin to 17th Century 'well I want it' decree from a monarch, which is what Putin has made himself to be in Russia looting from it's people and then killing them in senseless wars. People seem to forget that a lot of Ukrainians are actually part Russian, and it's not only the Russian speaking parts either (though now no one will will speak it after this atrocity) which is what makes this genocidal mess even more absurd. Your Pravda speaking points are like that of the Russian propaganda you'd see on TV that make Russia seem like the victim, when in fact the West was completely fine with Ukraine sliding into insolvency fighting Russia on the East while the EU got cheap gas/oil. It's really messed up, but Purin's inept geopolitical blunder is what made the West unify and finally step up and commit to actually doing something after neglecting the Budapest memorandum. I cannot say for sure why you are doing this, but it's clear you are either exposed or entirely believe this BS propaganda; this senseless war ends tonight if Russia leaves Ukraine. They won't, they are far too deep and want the Donbas even if they leave it a smouldering heap like Bauchmut; but if it's true that Wagner troops are returning back to Russia from Belarus after the Kremlin stiffed them on their pay they likely have another coup in their midst, and this is in addition to troops being sent to the front line with no training or equipment pay etc... That is more likely to end the war in my view, it just leaves a horrible power vacum not unlike that of Gadahffi's Libya, or Hussein's Iraq and always leads to chaos. Honestly, this will be seen by posterity as a 'how to f-up your natural resource rich Nation' 101 by Vladamir Putin; it should be mandatory reading and taught in all schools because this kind of BS shouldn't be tolerated in the 21st Century. It's sad Russians are so easily placated by propaganda into utter apathy--the calls from these people's relatives held as POW is spine chilling, the jaded side of me lets me think it is so bleak that it makes dying in a pointless war almost sensible alternative from their lives in Russia from their perspective. 0: https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/d/echr/HUDOC_38263_08_Annexes_ENG https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/d/echr/HUDOC_38263_08_Ann...
- Melting_Harps 3y ago> And the same people seem to forget that the ultimatum in 2021 was during the war of aggression launched in 2014, not before a conflict that started later. 2013, the Maidan Revolution had very clear motivations to oust the Russian links and when Yanukovych was being ousted bodies were being piled up in Kyiv; the fighting in the Donbas region took place with Putin's little green men afterward, but the first shots and casualties were felt in Kyiv. I highly recommend Vice's Russian Roulette series, how it never won a Pultzer for it is beyond me; I was dealing with the Maidan Revolution from the Bitcoin side and then eventually the Come Back Alive campaign and they covered so much of the minutia of that conflict it was really commendable--they were the first to go into Crimea and do investigative journalism into the financial dealing in the annexation and documented the migration of Crimean people to Western Ukraine, And I agree with what you said, Russian never intended to do anything but exert its geopolitical muscles and had no intention of peace agreements despite the rhetoric-- the peace deals in the onset where being conducted while Russia was bombing residential buildings in Kharkiv and committing war crimes in Bucha, Irpin, Sumi! But I need to take you back even further to 1994 and the Budapest Memorandum where Russia vowed to retain Ukraine's borders and agreed not to invade as the signees (US, UK) all signed to protect it and subsequently looked the other way during the invasion of the Donbas/Luhansk while simultaneously dealing with hyper inflation and capital controls. And Germany and the rest of the EU valued cheap oil/gas more than Ukrainian lives. I really hate to say this as I'm anti-nuclear proliferation, but History has shown time and again that even a pariah State like N. Korea gets to do what it does because it is a semi-nuclear armed nation. Ukraine should have never trusted the West or Russia and kept maybe even 1/8th of the arsenal just in case there border's integrity were challenged. Putin's Russia cannot be trusted, and the sad truth is that there is no one who really could replace him: Medvedev is his puppet and is even more insane with his rhetoric and Lavrov is a senile old kook who lives in a fantasy World that no one wants anything to do with. Alexi was a proponent of the 2014 invasion, too. And I'm not even going to touch on Prigozhin. Nadia from Pussy riot could be a unifying voice/figurehead given her outspoken activism and alliances with the Westand sympathies with Ukraine, but she knows f' all about Geopolitics or how to deal with a crumbling economy marred with plutocrats/oligarchs in every sector with some of the worst standards of living and crippling fertility rates (even before the invasion). It's just sad... and to be honest the fact that Belarus and Russians are fighting on the Ukrainian side makes me hopeful that their is a contingent willing to sacrifice to oust the Putin regime, but what comes next is not clear and that is what worries me most.