6 ms·
Can we please just go back to using smaller wheels and tires?
- BugsJustFindMe 3y agoIt seems like the article should have been "Can we please go back to having spare tires in cars?" Shit happens. But these days half the cars available don't include spares or a place to put them.
- massysett 3y ago? I didn’t know not having a spare tire was even a thing. I’ve had flat tires twice and got back on the road in under 20 minutes after changing the tire. I’m glad I now know this is a thing, so I can research new cars for this and avoid any model that has no spare.
- newaccount74 3y agoI think the problem is that tires are getting so big there's no place to store the spare. Especially on EVs where you need all the space you can get for the battery. That being said all the cars I looked at when I bought my car had a spare tire as an option (by default you wouldn't get one)
- avar 3y agoIts also because a spare tire is counted in the curb weight if it's standard equipment. So it'll impact e.g. the fuel consumption you can advertise.
- spicybright 3y agoI've never seen a car without a spare in the US. Maybe only in sports/performance cars. What kind of cars are you talking about?
- LordGrey 3y agoI own a 2010 Camaro SS and it doesn't have a spare. Part of that because those tires are HUGE -- I doubt I could fit one into my trunk -- but also because the front and rear tires are of different sizes. Which size should you carry? Chevy also put my battery in the trunk for weight distribution reasons, which makes the available space there even less. Maybe they felt they could do that because there was no spare. I love my Camaro but it is definitely a "pay to play" vehicle.
- flutas 3y agoFWIW lift the liner in the trunk and there's space for a donut. They have it replaced with an air compressor, a fix a flat can and a giant block of compressed foam in the shape of a tire lol.
- justinator 3y ago>but also because the front and rear tires are of different sizes. Which size should you carry? Oftentimes, spare wheels are very tiny compared to the wheel they're replacing and just made to get you to the tire place.
- LordGrey 3y agoYeah, every car other than the Camaro I've owned has had a donut spare tire. I forgot to address that my original comment. The challenge with a donut on my car is trying to fit over/around the brake calipers associated hardware. I've been lucky so far: in the 13 years I've own the car, I've had only one slow leak due to a nail. I haven't needed a spare yet.
- logbiscuitswave 3y agoIf you don’t have a full size spare, you generally always want to put it on the back. (Even if it means swapping tires around if you blew out a front tire.) You don’t want to compromise steering by putting it on the front wheel.
- simplyaccont 3y ago
- eknkc 3y agoOne of my previous cars came with no spare but “run flat” tires (might be named something else). Basically they have strong sidewalls that do not collapse even without pressure. You can ride on them at much slower speeds to get to a tire shop. Loved those. My later cars both had no spares neither an emergency solution like the previous one had. I used a foam tire sealer once, worked wonders on a small puncture. Couple weeks ago I managed to completely fuck up a tire on my volvo with no spare. Had to call assistance number, they sent a tow truck.. Spent half a day sorting it out.
- orangepurple 3y agoPeople equip cars with huge wheels for the same reason homeowners plant large swaths of grass over highly productive land: the aristocratic image of being able to afford to waste and being above the peasantry. Donks are a clear cut example of this within that subculture.
- anon373839 3y agoWithin reason, larger wheels and slimmer tires do more for the car aesthetically. Look at any concept sketch from an automotive designer and you will find impracticably big wheels on the design.
- orangepurple 3y agoWhich is why I refer to the huge, not merely the above average.
- MrFoof 3y agoThe upcoming Cadillac Escalade IQ is going to have an optional 24" wheel fitment. With the 50mm sidewall, this makes the total outside diameter of the tire 35". That's the same tire diameter as you'd put on a rock crawling Jeep Wrangler to take to Moab, but it's instead on a (estimated) 8500lb (3855kg) full-size luxury crossover marketed as an "executive" vehicle. For comparison, the Hummer H1's tire outer diameter was 37". We're quite nearly to that level of insanity. I'd reckon just a tire is going to weigh nearly 50lbs (22.6kg), with the wheel about the same. I can't imagine how "fun" changing a 100lb wheel+tire is going to be when rotating tires. Moreover, the reality is the cost of the those tires will be comparable to near R-compound top-end performance car tires. Never having personally considered tires/wheels that weighed anywhere near this, I wonder what the point was when shops had to get entirely new wheel balancing machines, etc. to adequately accommodate these ever larger sizes and weights. The battery impact for an EV is also going to be substantial, as is the impact to braking performance. It's really just maddening.
- profile53 3y ago50mm sidewall /25.4mm/in = 2 in sidewall 24” wheel + 2 in above wheel + 2 in below wheel = 28” diameter, which seems much more reasonable. Am I missing something?
- MrFoof 3y agoYes. The sidewall only accounts for a specific section of the side of the tire. You're excluding the portion which has to mate with the outer diameter of the barrel of wheel, as well as the entire outer tread. There's a LOT of material there in those two parts that aren't, "sidewall", nor accounted for in the size code. For example, I have 35mm sidewall sports car tires on 20" (only wheel offered by the manufacturer) diameter wheels. That would be less than 23" if we calculated as you did. The actual total diameter of an inflated tire though is ~27" (26.947") per the tire manufacturer (Michelin). I confirmed my assertion that it's 35s by running it through a tire diameter calculator (I do track days), and looking at outer tire diameters for tires for 23" wheels as a sanity check. Moreover, several media outlets (Autopian - partly run by a Jeep fanatic - The Drive, others) agree with me -- they are indeed 35". --- To be fair, for off-road tires, they're usually coded different. For example, a Hummer H1 which indeed has a 37" outer diameter tire, is coded as 37X12.5-16.5. But the Escalade IQs tires are coded as normal passenger tires, or 275/50R24.
- IronWolve 3y agoMixing tire sizes then mentioning EV's vs Gas and Trucks vs Cars, makes the article wrong. Same tire size with a 17 inch rim vs a 18 inch rim, the 17 will feel smoother ride for more tire wall size. So many different use cases, a blanket statement that small tires are better is wrong.
- digitalsushi 3y agoI just bought an mx5. I'm not a car guy so I don't know the right words, and that really just reveals I don't actually know how this functions. But I live in NH and "taco" these rims on our weather worn highways. My old jeep has thick, chubby tires that seem to only smoosh into them, and then deflect back out, intact. I'd love to "downgrade" the wheels on my mx5 and then put tires with a taller sidewall on it - picture the Delorean after Doc55 got it ready for 1885. But I think then, I am messing with the braking surface and reducing the car's stopping ability. Maybe. I did just learn that they're called 'tires' cause they are attire for cars. I think this is literal and not a lazy pun.
- dharmab 3y agoYou can get smaller wheels as long as the diameter of the new wheel and tire is close to your OEM diameter, and rhe new wheels are big enough for your brake calipers to fit inside them. Tire Rack's website has a good tool for finding a set.
- JakeAl 3y agoRemember the 70s and the energy crisis which spawned the sub-compact car? Can't we just go back to that instead of giant vehicles with an auto loan that is bigger than the mortgages of the 70s? Better gas mileage, traffic moves faster, more parking spaces, AND they are light enough they can handle driving in the snow far better.
- aitchnyu 3y agoDo bigger wheels imply better offroading performance? In India the capable Suzuki Jimny is mocked for being undertyred (15 inches) compared to mall going crossovers.
- tb_technical 3y agoThe size of the wheels and tires doesn't matter as much as the weight of the wheels and tires. We should be optimizing for puncture resistant tires with lightweight wheels. Size doesn't matter, except for aesthetics.
- elmerfud 3y agoSo much wrong in this article, but some things are correct. First a smaller rim and higher profile tire wouldn't have prevented the problem. Whatever was hit was hard enough to knock a dime-sized hole in his tire. That's almost three quarters of an inch or 18 mm for the rest of the world. This isn't some light scrubbing on the sidewall or damaging your rim from a curb scrape. This is full on you blasted into something and poked a god-awful-sized hole into the side of your tire. No profile is going to save you from that. Second the trend of using these wheels and tire combinations is partially because consumers want that look but primarily for stability of these obnoxiously sized chassis to body ratio that people want in vehicles. Partially due to emissions standards and partially due to ride comfort manufacturers are using car chassis and bolting on effectively high profile truck bodies to them (that's your typical crossover). You put on a 14-in rim with a 75% sidewall tire you have a handling nightmare that will result in rollovers. Sticking a large rim with a small profile tire greatly reduces that. Lastly, yes larger rims are heavier and result in more unsprung weight but the trade-off is (for a factory setup) always worth it for increased handling and stability. This can reduce ride comfort but since you're on a car chassis anyway the suspension is making up the difference for what the tires used to do back in the '80s and '70s and '60s. This author seriously needs to go find a bone stock car from the mid-70s or even the late 60s and compare it to what he has today. I give this your range because bias tires are just garbage and by the late 60s most manufacturers had started installing radials at that point. Still cars were given high profile tires. A sports car would not be uncommon to have a 225 65 R15 tire. Total mush with atrocious handling. Still if you're going to smack curbs enough to put dime-size holes in it the only thing it might save is scratching up your steel rim which was also god awful heavy compared to modern alloy rims that are bigger. If you want smaller wheels and tires you need to go with smaller overall vehicles. Manufacturers don't do this for looks as their primary reason. They do it because it's what's required to keep the car safe and stable and meet the safety standards that are mandated. Nobody wants smaller cars because the safety rating goes through the floor because smaller cars you can only make them so safe due to the weight constraints of having a smaller car.
- twoWhlsGud 3y agoConsumer Reports, which presumably has test driven a wider array of cars than you or me, is pretty much constantly complaining about how the trend toward larger wheels is compromising ride quality. (In particular, when discussing trim levels they often count the larger rims you get with higher trim levels as a negative.) Given that the weight and size of vehicles has constantly been increasing (largely due to the auto co's "nice family you got, pity if something ... happened to it" marketing campaigns) some increase in size would make sense from a perf standpoint. I think the author's argument is that it's gone far beyond that. And CU, at least, seems to agree.