4 ms·

Somewhat ironically, given how much we talk on this site about FOSS, HN categorically is not FOSS and it does not pretend to be. There are many little behaviors

Somewhat ironically, given how much we talk on this site about FOSS, HN categorically is not FOSS and it does not pretend to be. There are many little behaviors (such as quiet score adjustments) that the admins put in place in order to avoid the Eternal September. If those behaviors were public knowledge, I imagine that they wouldn't really work. If news like this bothers you, well, then stop giving HN your traffic and go use Lemmy instead :)

johnnyanmac 3y ago
>If news like this bothers you, well, then stop giving HN your traffic and go use Lemmy instead :) this isn't the breaking point, but this and a lot of other philosophical differences and cultural issues here is putting it close. I'm just tired of migrating. I especially don't want to think of migrating not even 6 months after I deleted my last Reddit account.
thousand_nights 3y ago
the only thing that bothers me about hn is that it doesn't let you delete posts so it gets annoying having to rotate accounts as you slowly dox yourself by revealing more and more info for a social website where so many users are privacy advocates this is surprising to me yes you can email dang or whatever but that is like having to phone up to cancel an online subscription, dark pattern friction bs
- prometheon1 3y ago
  HN is a forum, but also a valuable information resource. If it were easy to delete your historical comments, a lot of that information would be lost. If you make a contribution to a Wikipedia page, do you expect to be able to delete it? I know HN is not Wikipedia, but it is also not like Facebook, in the sense that one can actually learn useful things on HN.
- NewJazz 3y ago
  You also can't block people. I consider that a pretty important feature for mental health reasons.
  - dredmorbius 3y ago
    You can collapse threads, and the setting will hold until the post is about 2 weeks old (at which point it's locked from further comments). I am doing this with ... somewhat increasing frequency. It's probably possible to use Greasemonkey or similar to provide client-side JS for blocking users, though that would be cumbersome. Some of the alternate HN front-ends may also offer this.
  - idiotsecant 3y ago
    On the other hand, I don't think i've found much need to block people on HN due to the usually excellent community.
    - johnnyanmac 3y ago
      I've seen it here and there and have extensions for that. It's no Reddit, but far from perfect. Especially once you start poking at a few specific topics (some expected and practically universally controversial, others more "tailored" towards a technical community).
- wahnfrieden 3y ago
  You can't reliably email to request it. Their policy is that if you request your comments to be deleted, they will only delete some minority of them if there is a reason to that they like
- nvarsj 3y ago
  I’ve actually been doxxed from Hn comments and it wasn’t pleasant (although I don’t make a huge effort to hide my identity). Having said that I think it would be a much different site if comments could be freely removed. So I’m okay with the friction of having to email a human to get your stuff removed.

johnnyanmac 3y ago

>If news like this bothers you, well, then stop giving HN your traffic and go use Lemmy instead :) this isn't the breaking point, but this and a lot of other philosophical differences and cultural issues here is putting it close. I'm just tired of migrating. I especially don't want to think of migrating not even 6 months after I deleted my last Reddit account.

thousand_nights 3y ago

the only thing that bothers me about hn is that it doesn't let you delete posts so it gets annoying having to rotate accounts as you slowly dox yourself by revealing more and more info for a social website where so many users are privacy advocates this is surprising to me yes you can email dang or whatever but that is like having to phone up to cancel an online subscription, dark pattern friction bs

prometheon1 3y ago
HN is a forum, but also a valuable information resource. If it were easy to delete your historical comments, a lot of that information would be lost. If you make a contribution to a Wikipedia page, do you expect to be able to delete it? I know HN is not Wikipedia, but it is also not like Facebook, in the sense that one can actually learn useful things on HN.
NewJazz 3y ago
You also can't block people. I consider that a pretty important feature for mental health reasons.
- dredmorbius 3y ago
  You can collapse threads, and the setting will hold until the post is about 2 weeks old (at which point it's locked from further comments). I am doing this with ... somewhat increasing frequency. It's probably possible to use Greasemonkey or similar to provide client-side JS for blocking users, though that would be cumbersome. Some of the alternate HN front-ends may also offer this.
- idiotsecant 3y ago
  On the other hand, I don't think i've found much need to block people on HN due to the usually excellent community.
  - johnnyanmac 3y ago
    I've seen it here and there and have extensions for that. It's no Reddit, but far from perfect. Especially once you start poking at a few specific topics (some expected and practically universally controversial, others more "tailored" towards a technical community).
wahnfrieden 3y ago
You can't reliably email to request it. Their policy is that if you request your comments to be deleted, they will only delete some minority of them if there is a reason to that they like
nvarsj 3y ago
I’ve actually been doxxed from Hn comments and it wasn’t pleasant (although I don’t make a huge effort to hide my identity). Having said that I think it would be a much different site if comments could be freely removed. So I’m okay with the friction of having to email a human to get your stuff removed.