6 ms·
Why doctors pay millions in fees that could be spent on care
- offsky 3y agoI was recently at a museum and I had two choices to buy a ticket. Buy a paper ticket from a real person or use a self-service kiosk which emails me a ticket for a $5 electronic delivery fee. Why?? I am always baffled by fees for electronic delivery of anything.
- alexpotato 3y agoB/c think how easy it is for someone to say to the finance folks: "Marginal cost of delivery for an electronic ticket is essentially zero so if we can get $5 of marginal revenue then our MR/MC ratio approaches infinity!"
- za3faran 3y agoYou're paying for convenience. Why go wait in line for God knows how long when you can pay a fee and get it immediately? Otherwise I agree that the charges can be exorbitant.
- tredre3 3y agoBut he said he was at the museum. At this point a paper ticket is the more convenient option, rather than have to find your smartphone and open your emails.
- maerF0x0 3y agoIMO they're blaming the wrong group for the issue though. Financial transactions should not cost much more than compute + software they run on. This is one angle where I actually respect a portion of the crypto community -- they've called out some things that were stagnant in the financial sector. Of course it remains to be seen if they can come up with viable alternatives, but agreeing on a problem is a good step forward.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThere would be three ways of solving this. Government breaks up managed care organizations so that they are small enough such that their counterparties (e.g. smaller doctor organizations) can tell them to pound sand when asked for ludicrous fees. Government legislated that electronic ACH payments or transactions have to be offered free of charge. Government operates electronic money accounts and electronic money transfers as infrastructure.
- tmpz22 3y ago> Financial transactions should not cost much more than compute + software they run on. The fees aren't pure profit for financial institutions. Its used to subsidize consumer protections like fraud prevention and reversal. > This is one angle where I actually respect a portion of the crypto community Is there a portion of crypto platforms that don't take in fees?
- thrill 3y agoAny crypto platform that doesn't charge a fee will be swamped (even more) with spam transactions along with all those who validate that chain.
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoIt's also used for cashback credit cards to attract high income people with good credit scores, at the expense of everybody else.
- gmane 3y agoI mean, sure they talk big, but isn't one of the largest complaints against crypto the fact that transaction fees are high [0,1,2] and processing times are long [3]? [0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/crypto-and-its-many-fees-what-to-know-about-the-hidden-costs-of-digital-currency-11639825202 https://www.wsj.com/articles/crypto-and-its-many-fees-what-t... [1] https://www.investopedia.com/tech/how-much-does-it-cost-buy-cryptocurrency-exchanges/ https://www.investopedia.com/tech/how-much-does-it-cost-buy-... [2] https://www.makeuseof.com/crypto-exchange-fees-explained/ https://www.makeuseof.com/crypto-exchange-fees-explained/
- BSEdlMMldESB 3y agobecause rent i.e. taxes i.e. licensing fees i.e. insurance coverage i.e. rent is just too good when you're collecting it and nobody would give it up
- mattw2121 3y agoWould love to see doctors and medical facilities nationwide convert, en masse, to paper checks. Let's see how quickly the insurers back off the fees.
- lkjafdsadsf 3y agoThey would absolutely love it. Paper checks extend their accounts payable.
- marcus0x62 3y agoPlus think of all the opportunities for checks to get “sent” but “lost in the mail”, sent for the incorrect amount (always lower than the amount owed,) and not be eligible for payment at all until the provider accrues a certain dollar amount… Endless possibilities!
- darth_avocado 3y agoLooks like it may be cheaper to hire a guy to go around town and collect checks. Maybe that’s a startup idea there.
- tomalaci 3y agoI could already see the scenario there. The startup gets very successful and entrenches itself as this middleman. Eventually someone figures out that this cheque system is dumb and everything should be digital by default. The startup then starts lobbying and further locks in the archaic cheque system.
- koolba 3y ago> Many insurers, after whittling down physicians' reimbursements, now take an additional cut if the doctor prefers — as almost all do — to receive funds electronically rather than via a paper check. What’s the angle here? Classic rent seeking because they can? Profiteering collecting interest on the float? Banking on doctors being slow to cash physical checks? There’s some heavy stickiness to using one of these paperwork handlers for doctors. The switching costs are significant. But you’d still think there’s enough money there for someone to step up and offer the service without the fees. There’s enough money in fee per service to eat the big guys’ lunches. It’s ridiculously close to the payroll business and we all know what happened there over the past 5-10 years.
- bombcar 3y agoIt's doubly strange because usually it's the other way around; if you want the paper check you have to pay for it, otherwise they transfer (slowly) electronically. Some places have a "pay you before" option that is electronic and fast and also takes a fee.
- codegeek 3y agoIt always is the "Insurer". The middle man mafia that has no reason to exist between a Doctor and Patient except for Catastrophic situations as all insurance should be. But not in America. We pay a heavy price for that.
- Vvector 3y agoImagine if we had "food insurance". Your grocery store is "in network", but the butcher sends you a bill because he is out-of-network. No prices on anything, because your insurance carrier has "negotiated" a price for you, which you only find out after the fact.
- codegeek 3y agoOr imagine you had Car Insurance butting in everything including an Oil change and dictating which shop you can use for the oil change. I bet it won't be a $20-$30 oil change anymore and your premiums will be much higher than it already is. Btw, don't give the Food industry these ideas :). It would suck if we now have "Food Insurance"
- alexpotato 3y ago> Or imagine you had Car Insurance butting in everything including an Oil change and dictating which shop you can use for the oil change. This kind of already exists with insurance and car repair. If I damage my car, I take it to an approved repair shop and they give me an estimate. It's in the car repair shop's best interest to provide a quick estimate and good repair. If they don't, I can raise the issue with my insurer who might even lose me as a customer. The repair shop would then potentially lose out on repeat business from the insurance company. Granted, this is a better example of a not-so-free market working vs the "locked in market" of healthcare but I think it's good to provide some counter examples to "it's ALWAYS bad to have insurers with preferred vendors"
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThat exists, they are called high deductible plans, and people still complain about the high deductibles. The root problem is the tail end of healthcare is enormously expensive, into the millions of dollars. Insuring a car is a minor expense, max $50k for the vast majority. It is the healthcare, that could require years of therapy and work done by extremely highly qualified people in short supply, using patented medicines, all wrapped up in liability protection, because if someone makes a mistake, you are eligible for up to millions of dollars in damages. And also, if you are under age 50 and/or healthy, you are not just paying to insure your health in this calendar year, you are paying for healthcare older and/or sicker people are receiving. Health insurance premiums are more similar to a tax than an insurance premium.
- tomalaci 3y agoAs an European it is unbelievable with the kind of crap Americans need to deal with. I would expect the bank to apply a microscopic transfer fee and that's it, not a normal company deciding an arbitrary insane percentage fee. It really feels like everything is trying to nickel and dime you guys over there.
- programmer_dude 3y ago>It really feels like everything is trying to nickel and dime you guys over there. This is what being American means. Capitalism and rent seeking to the max!
- intrasight 3y agoI am reminded by this story of the Canadian health care billing system. The government would pay doctors an additional 1% of the bill if it was submitted one month late. One billing software vendor had a flag to specify that bill should be sent late - and I think that it defaulted to "yes".
- ryzvonusef 3y agoSurely the govt should step in and say that if you are charging extra for electronic vs paper, that's illegal?
- miguelazo 3y agoHaha, the US government? Maybe some state insurance commissioners, but the American regulatory apparatus is mostly captured. The natural result of allowing corporations to buy politicians under the hilariously stupid pretext that it is "free speech."
- no_wizard 3y agoMedical Billing is ripe for disruption, but of note, I don't know of any startup that has made significant inroads into this market. Anyone know why its so tough to break?
- senectus1 3y agooh yes, lets apply gig economy thinking here. demand scaling prices and share doctoring.
- miguelazo 3y agoSeriously? Barriers to entry are massive. The insurance lobby is not going to just let their cash cow get "disrupted." Unlike those middle class taxi drivers that got obliterated by Uber, the healthcare industrial complex has a massive war chest and plenty of political clout.
- TuringNYC 3y ago>> I don't know of any startup that has made significant inroads into this market. Anyone know why its so tough to break? Because multiple parties in the system are both making money and control the standards of practice. This makes real competition incredibly difficult.
- zeruch 3y agoComplexity across providers and regulatory compliance are my most likely guesses.
- pc86 3y ago1. Good luck finding a startup, especially a VC-backed one (which for this kind of market I would expect is a borderline necessity), that isn't going to charge at least this much if not more per transaction. 2. Would their customer be the insurer or the doctor? If it's the doctor, I can't see insurers wanting to reimburse anyone other than the doctor. If it's the insurer, why would they farm out their billing to this third party when they already have the capability, and it's clearly lucrative? 3. Medicine in general is ripe for disruption, but it's so heavily regulated that eats into a lot of the potential profits from any service provider. Everything is an enterprise contract negotiation and the technical talent leaves pretty quickly when they see how slow everything moves. I've worked with large hospital systems that were still running Windows 7. Recently.
- deniz_tekalp 3y agoThe comments so far miss the point. Off-the-shelf software is not HIPAA compliant. Government restricts supply through regulation, monopolists collect rent. If HIPAA were to be relaxed, off-the-shelf software can be used and fees would plummet. Don't blame "insurers", "middlemen", "capitalism" etc; blame well-intentioned / poorly designed regulations.
- triceratops 3y agoHow is the government restricting the supply of HIPAA-compliant software?
- dqv 3y agoSo I think there is some truth to what they're saying, although I don't understand how this applies to doctors receiving payments since you're not really attaching patient information to these payments AFAIK. HIPAA tends to create a situation where you have the minimum possible compliance (e.g. the most basic encryption that hasn't been broken or just disk-based encryption rather than doing something like individual record encryption and using a a pepper) for the highest possible cost. Companies who would provide more robust protection tend not to because of the legal risk, so you have companies that fill in the space with lower quality software but are willing to put their name on a business associate agreement. The focus then becomes the advertising of the product as HIPAA compliant rather than making it more compliant. You do have larger companies who seemingly have better compliance, but I remember someone telling me they had to pay $700 a month for Tiger Connect for example. There is more competition in this area today, so prices have gone down, but I remember a few years back it being pretty rough on what you could get where people would stamp their product as compliant. The least expensive options seemed like there was a "messages.php" file somewhere leaking all the secure messages. It kind of stifles innovation in a way as well. For example, there is no secure messaging product that I know of that uses the methods that Signal uses to encrypt messages. Notwithstanding the location of Signal's data, no one in compliance is going to allow use of the app without a business associate agreement. So the less-secure apps win.
- francisofascii 3y ago
- hedora 3y agoThe last time I checked, 33% of US healthcare dollars went to paying people at the insurance company and people at the healthcare provider to negotiate with each other. One way to avoid this in the US is to go with an HMO, since they can be wildly profitable and still be much more efficient than an insurance company + independent providers. Of course, the problem with that is that non-emergency care from third-party doctors isn't covered by the HMO. A better way to solve the problem is to go with a single-payer healthcare system, such as the one the progressives was proposing during the Obamacare negotiations. (As every other first-world country has done at this point.)
- codegeek 3y agoAnd don't forget the cost of health Insurance for the actual consumers including Premiums, Deductible, Co-Pays, Co-Insurance and all the other nonsense.
- scythe 3y ago>As every other first-world country has done at this point. This is simply not true, and there is another option that deserves to at least be mentioned: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All-payer_rate_setting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All-payer_rate_setting
- anonuser123456 3y ago>A better way to solve the problem is to go with a single-payer healthcare system Better for who, and under what circumstances?
- jewayne 3y agoNot every first world country has a true single-payer healthcare system. There are many variations that work better than what we have. The difference is that in the US we have accepted profit maximization as the legitimate primary goal in the healthcare system.
- qwytw 3y agoI think the majority of Western European countries don't even have it? Most seem to have mixed systems or no single payer at all like Switzerland (where healthcare is privatized to an even higher degree than in the US).
- miguelazo 3y agoYet another reason we need a public option. The market dominance and collusion of this oligopoly makes this behavior so easy.
- neerajk 3y agoPossibly naive, but hopefully trying to reason from first principles: The insurance companies are the ones paying for care. The hospital systems are the ones charging for care. The entity that pays for care has every incentive to keep costs _low_. The entity that charges for care has every incentive to charge as much as possible. i.e. The ire of consumers should be directed at hospital systems rather than insurance companies.
- christophilus 3y agoIIRC, insurance companies benefit from high prices, as it benefits their gross profits. I forget whether that was due to regulations sort of capping profit margins, or what the reason was. I’ll see if I can track down a reference. Edit: here’s an article on the topic https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/05/25/613685732/why-your-health-insurer-doesnt-care-about-your-big-bills https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/05/25/6136857...
- francisofascii 3y agoThat is the way it used to be. For many of us in high deductible plans, we pay thousands of dollars each year for care before the insurance company pays for anything. Not to mention the thousands of dollars we pay each year in premiums to the insurance company.
- rjmunro 3y agoIt's only in the interests of health insurance companies to make costs lower if they do it in a way that doesn't make costs lower for other insurance companies. As long as costs are high for everyone they can charge more knowing the competitors cannot undercut them. In fact it's often in the insurance companies interests to make premiums generally go up, because they make more actual money for taking the same percentage.
- nobodyandproud 3y agoIs it more efficient to get a bundle of cash spread over 5 years and to disincentivize abuse/overuse, get tax credit for unused money? The insane paperwork we've built-up thanks to the industry isn't really serving our colletive best interests.
- LatteLazy 3y agoThe US has two options: * Start from scratch with a new system. * Keep trying to make the current mess work. When it only came into existence as a way of evading price controls in WW2. And it's hopelessly wasteful and expensive and ineffective. But the US system is institutionally opposed to reform.