6 ms·
Most bosses regret how they mandated workers return to the office
- archo 3y agohttps://archive.is/rfErE https://archive.is/rfErE Comment by zamadatix 9 hours ago - Recent similar discussion :https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37093854 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37093854
- wilde 3y agoAh yes if only they had a survey to ignore instead of loud employee complaints in Slack telling them this would be the outcome. But nah, that’s just the troublemakers. The silent majority of employees love 2h commutes to reset for the work day.
- hpaavola 3y agoI wonder... It's absolutely clear that many hate their long commute. Do they, at some point, start to wonder what went so wrong that many (most?) have such an awfully long commute?
- dougmwne 3y agoThere’s no need to wonder. This isn’t a mystery. City planning in the US is totally screwed. No density, single family homes over dense multistory apartments, highways over rail lines, cars over public transit, parking over parks. Everyone was sold the dream of their own little tenth acre in the exurbs. The end result was a life spent in the car.
- kkfx 3y agoAs an European I think USA planning have two issues: - too dense, yes you read it correctly - too zoned Too dense in dense cities means too costly to evolve, that's most an EU problem, but is a USA problem as well in certain areas. Too zoned means to much space between work and living places. The modern ideal density IMVHO is homes, not apartments, mixed with small (one to three stories max) buildings, shops and so on to allow short-commute (also in bike/feet range) for findings small services (grocery, perhaps a nearby dentist, a gym and so on) and just for some also for work, plus the slice of remote workers (who are perceptually a significant slice of population in developed countries at least) etc. That's the "dense enough, but not too much" density for a modern economy of scale. We need to mix works and homes, at least for most productive activities, leaving districts just for things we can't do otherwise like certain manufacturing industries, automotive and so on.
- danuker 3y agoOn what basis do you call individual homes "ideal density"? I like to have a lot of amenities within 5-10 minutes of walking. That is not quite achievable without apartments.
- kkfx 3y agoI call individual homes intermixed with small buildings the ideal density. Like in some (not so much) EU areas, where for instance you have few schools in ~10km (~6 miles) radius, a couple of restaurant, maybe a small grocery shop, perhaps a pharmacy and so on. People still need to travel but being spread there are not much traffic nor parking issues and the ability to integrate remote workers and many in person workers keep the model functional. When some tech change there is space to change. Let's say there is room for a water-water geothermal heat pump instead of a previous methane combustion based heating, there is room for p.v., domestic charging for cars and so on. Something that can't be done in a dense city.
- zirgs 3y agoIt's very achievable in small towns. I grew up in a small town and walked everywhere.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vladvasiliu 3y agoProbably noise. As an apartment-dwelling European, maybe GP's point about density is based on the fact that having neighbors sucks big time. Sure, you can build apartment buildings that are well insulated, but most stock in my neck of the woods isn't built that way. You can hear your neighbor taking a piss at night. Of course, this doesn't help people making the median salary in the city actually afford those places. So, given my environment, if I want peace and quiet without having to try out living in multiple apartments until I can find the rare one built with care, it's much easier to just go live in a detached house in the suburbs. Also, despite dense public transport and "walkability", the traffic is still ridiculous so pollution is very high, too.
- helen___keller 3y agoI'm not entirely sure what you mean, but yeah sure I had a summer internship in the suburbs of boston and drove out from the city every day in the early 2010s. Practically door to door traffic, stressful unprotected left turns, masshole drivers abound, the works. After that summer I swore off car commuting. I ended up with the same commute after graduating but by public transit. Since transit to the suburbs is awful, it was a 3 seat ride - train to the commuter rail station, commuter rail to the suburbs, then bus to the workplace, about 1-1.5 hr each way. After quitting that job for a job in the city (with about 20-30 min commute by train each day) i swore off the suburbs altogether. Life is too short for that nonsense.
- ghaff 3y agoWell in MA between the city itself (a couple of them actually), Metrowest, North Shore, and South shore people and companies are spread over a very large area and a lot of people and their partners are only willing to compromise so much for a better commute. I’ve only had one really bad one - about 90 minutes way into the city but not every day. But when I was going into an office-which I haven’t regularly for a long time a 30 to 45 minute was pretty normal once I bought a house that wasn’t basically next door to the office. There basically weren’t tech jobs in Boston proper in my memory though that’s changed quite a bit.
- cpfohl 3y agoCurious where your job was? Assuming Woburn or anywhere in the westernmost stretch of 95/128? My first job out of college was at BBN Technologies in Cambridge, but I was living in Beverly on the north shore. I quit shortly after my first 3h commute (most days were 1.5). The commute situation in the greater Boston metro is pretty awful…
- ghaff 3y agoPart of it is that’s it’s just a big area. I live in a Metrowest exurb just a few mile drive from commuter. I’m still a 90-120 minute commute each way depending upon where the 2 stations are to where I’m going which isn’t sustainable anywhere daily IMO. But I’m actually less than 30 minute from my main office though I haven’t been in there in years.
- firstplacelast 3y agoMiddle managers have very little power…they know or at least the good ones do. If you’re in even a medium COL area, housing has sky rocketed. Even the old boomer middle managers worth their salt know this. I quit a job in biotech earlier this year bc I would always be paid less for my skills and cannot afford it anymore. Great boss, great director, they know. They can’t just magically pay me more when tons of people (H1B’s included) will do my job for the same or cheaper…it would make them bad at their job.
- wilde 3y agoThe prisoner’s dilemma of existing residents resisting density thinking it drives up their home price.
- ghaff 3y agoMany people have constraints on where they live—cost yes, but also partners, kids, desire to live in the city even though that lucrative job is way out in the suburbs. Many people who have well-paying jobs could have shorter commutes but they’d probably need to compromise things.
- bart_spoon 3y agoIt isn't rocket science. Cities in the US are pretty undesirable places to be outside a very select demographic of the population. Decent areas tend to be expensive, public transportation is generally bad, walkability is often poor, schools tend to be very poor, and they tend to have more crime. So what you get is a living situation where you either pay out the ear to live somewhere with the actual benefits of living in a city (walkability, public transportation, lots of public services/amenities), or you pay to live in an area that doesn't actually provide many of those benefits, is actively hostile to families (especially with young children), is more dangerous, all so you might have a shorter commute. So the people who end up actually making the most of the city tend to be: - Rich, young, childless - Less affluent but still young and childless and able/willing to live with roommates Once you fall out of those two groups, the benefits of living in an American city do a huge nosedive, and so it's no surprise that people move to the suburbs or more rural areas. I lived in Japan for several years, and I may be overly harsh in judgements due to the fact that Japanese cities are possibly in contention for the best, most functional, livable cities in the world. But in my opinion American urban development has been an unmitigated disaster that will take decades to heal, if it ever does.
- Lutger 3y ago> The problem, they said: They didn’t have access to workplace data to help them make their decision. > Without that data, nearly a quarter of them admit to making decisions based on “gut instinct > I don’t have data to back it up, but I know it’s better. To me its rather obvious most management (and sales) do not actually understand what work means, other than sitting in meetings the whole day talking to people. That's their job. Management wants everybody in the office to facilitate them, they don't care about what their employees need to do their jobs, let alone the personal well-being of workers. We don't need data, just talk to employees as if they were normal adult human beings and try to understand their perspectives. Management is there to help employees do the work that actually brings value, not the other way around. In management-speak: management is waste. Companies who understand this will get all the talent, the rest will need to compensate with very high salaries to attract good developers.
- kkfx 3y agoThat's "romance" :-) RTO is needed to keep up a slice of businesses useless for the society, but profitable for some, let's start from high rise buildings rentals to services for those working there, living around. Only marginally is a middle managers and lower management issue, whose job is actually in the series of "not really useful jobs".
- KineticLensman 3y ago> whose job is actually in the series of "not really useful jobs" Perhaps they should return to the Golgafrinchan 'B' Ark
- sidlls 3y ago"Management is there to help employees do the work that actually brings value, not the other way around. In management-speak: management is waste." This is self-contradictory. If facilitation is needed for "work that actually brings value", then the work required to facilitate also has value.
- Lutger 3y ago
- gumballindie 3y agoWorking in tech is atrocious. Imagine being expected to spend most of your life tied to a desk, carrying out useless meetings, chasing tickets, and long commutes, for pay that you will never actually enjoy as by the time you retire you will be dementia ridden. Worse, working in tech limits your understanding of things around you, essentially making you captive in a job with no life. Imagine as life flashes before your eyes most of the view will be a jira board, and office and petty office politics. Get out while you can.
- predictabl3 3y agoOr you could work 6 years, live within your means and semi-retire for... oh apparently 6 years, and if you can invest worth half a penny and avoid the American consumerism treadmill... A helluva lot longer. Get out while you can, indeed.
- helen___keller 3y ago> by the time you retire you will be dementia ridden Why? > working in tech limits your understanding of things around you, essentially making you captive in a job with no life What?
- k99x55 3y agoWhy? Sitting in desk for long periods and commuting by car/train in cycling-hostile countries is very bad for your health.
- pc86 3y agoThen imagine how bad doing the same shit for half the money (or less) must be. That's most of the other people in your office. Imagine how bad getting half of that must be but being on your feet all day, or even worse doing real manual labor. That's most of the people outside your office. I'm not saying we can't make things better - we can and should - but the only thing "atrocious" about working in tech is listening to coddled techbros whose first job was an $80k/yr internship talk about how hard it is to be in tech.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 5350-uiop-1130 3y ago> Most bosses regret how they mandated workers return to the office hmm, why would they want us to think that... fortune is just a PR for shitty execs.
- tagyro 3y agoDuring this summer, I found myself revisiting "Peopleware," authored by Tom DeMarco and Timothy Lister. One chapter is devoted exclusively to the productivity of creative professionals, including engineers and designers, in workspaces accommodating over three people – a norm in contemporary offices. It baffles me how some employers, in their attempts to economize on office rental costs, place more than 20 employees in a single space. This results in constant distractions that disrupt focus and hinder flow, consequently lowering the productivity of these employees. For employees that have a dedicated home-office, returning to office means constant distractions, coming in early or staying late to be able to actually get some work done etc. And then, the commute. Wasting my time because my employer is stubborn and wants me in the office.
- systems_glitch 3y agoWorked in a couple open plan offices in previous jobs. Had to be antisocial and wear headphones at volume level 11 to ignore everyone from the the FNG to the boss to get anything done. "But the collaboration!" What, you mean half the office bugging me because they don't want to read a manpage?
- iamthepieman 3y agoWhen I read about RTO, I always just wonder how many friends of Bezos or Eric Yuan are heavily invested in real estate.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] Large discussion on earlier post days back: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37093854 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37093854
- gryzzly 3y agoSo removed are the "bosses" from real people that considering the reality of their subordinates is impossible and they need data. Do they not have relatives or say parents of their kids’ friends, who are workers and not at the top of the capitalist pyramid? Is it that hard to understand that once someone saw their job can be done remotely no problemo, they will have questions why they need to commute and report to the office simply because of management’s "lack of data"?
- systems_glitch 3y agoRelatives and friends who are not mgmt are obvious failures or expendable :P
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> If only managers had taken the hint. Four in five (80%) of bosses told workplace software firm Envoy that had they had a better grasp on actual employee preferences, they would have taken a starkly different approach to their return-to-office plans. Oh STOP. This.Is.Literally.YOUR.JOB. And you FAILED at it.
- tb_technical 3y agoThey're "just doing their job". ROFL The work culture in the west is a panopticon.
- EPWN3D 3y agotl;dr managers are saying "If only I'd have had data showing that working from home was fine, I could've ignored it and ordered my employees back."