3 ms·
Computers are not necessary for K-12 education. They're more likely a hindrance.
by WalterBright 3y ago
Computers are not necessary for K-12 education. They're more likely a hindrance.
- mlyle 3y agoStudents getting experience doing computer things is nice. And there's things that are awesome to demonstrate with simulations. Spending a huge fraction of your educational day on them is dumb and ripe for abuse. This is a potential silver lining of the whole LLM thing: computers being used for writing assignments, etc, may become untenable.
- vxNsr 3y agoI had a teacher 15 years ago who didn’t trust us not to have family members edit our work to the point where it was no longer our work so he only gave in class writing assignments. Homework was always research or reading.
- sohex 3y agoWhether or not they're effective educational tools the fact is that they are used as such in most school districts (in the US) these days so far as I'm aware. Personally I agree for the most part, in general classroom instruction doesn't need them. That being said they're certainly indispensable for things like research in school libraries, running simulations for science classes, creating digital, and obviously teaching any kind of programming, so they definitely have their place. Having a dedicated computer per student is a huge benefit for less well off communities too. More than a few students won't have one of their own or even a family computer at home and having the school provide that for assignments is absolutely a boon so far as I'm concerned.