2 ms·
This is true of more than video games; "board games at the extreme" are not really comparable to how the designers played - and that is often not how it's even
by bombcar 3y ago
This is true of more than video games; "board games at the extreme" are not really comparable to how the designers played - and that is often not how it's even played by most people. Monopoly, of course, is an extreme case of this, but there are others.
The signs of this are in features/functions in the game that are just ignored; sometimes you can figure out what the designers intended them to be used for - and with modern games being patched (even board games get rule clarifications and changes, and add-ons and expansions almost always changed some rules) you can see it live.
Heroes III is a perfect example; watch some online videos of pro players and it's nothing like the compstomps we did back in the day.
- gowld 3y agoMonopoly is different because players ignorantly change the rules. Scrabble is an example of Ayers following the rules while distorting the game.
- tedunangst 3y agoPlayers at Monopoly tournaments are changing the rules?
- bombcar 3y agoHome players add the free parking rules because otherwise the game is a brutal winner’s snowball that is unfun for the losers, especially kids.
- whartung 3y agoGamers are gonna game. Rule lawyers too. It’s the nature of complex games with large rule sets. What is nice is if you have an active publisher reacting in a timely fashion. But then, if that’s the case, you as a participant need to keep up. Mind this only happens in competitive tournaments. While at home and in clubs folks tend to favor fun, gameplay, and goodwill over pedantic rule making. It can lead to interesting discussions at high volume however. That said, I’ve seen tournament games lost because someone whipped out an obscure ruling from an official source. In a “Sorry you can’t do that.” “What do you mean?” Kind of way. But it was good to participate in games with an active publisher, doing things like gathering after action reports across local tournaments nationwide, looking for unbalanced components or techniques and, rather than tweaking the game directly, just applying changes to the tournament rules set.