3 ms·
> “Montanans can’t be blamed for changing the climate—even the plaintiffs’ expert witnesses agreed that our state has no impact on the global climate," Flower s
by palata 3y ago
> “Montanans can’t be blamed for changing the climate—even the plaintiffs’ expert witnesses agreed that our state has no impact on the global climate," Flower said.
That Flower person just doesn't have a clue.
- HPsquared 3y agoI guess it's a question of "absolutely none" vs "proportionally almost none". The legal issue being of environmental damage done to the state of Montana by climate change, the actions of Montanans do indeed have a negligible impact. (Population 1.1 million)
- unlikelymordant 3y agoThis argument could be extended to anything by just dividing up the target into smaller chunks, just because individuals have negligeable impact on global climate doesnt mean nobody has any responsibility to reduce emissions. No raindrop thinks itself responsible for the flood.
- InSteady 3y agoAn individual gun, let alone bullet, kills so few people you can practically treat it as zero if you zoom out far enough. Therefore any regulation whatsoever is meaningless. Yeah, this is a very convenient rhetorical device for someone looking to trivialize important issues in bad faith.
- HPsquared 3y agoCost-benefit analysis is where we need to go.
- esafak 3y agoMontana is not an island. Behaviors and precedents spread.
- Mordisquitos 3y agoHowever negligible the impact, the State Constitution says what it says. Imagine if a local US government were to pass a law that totally banned the possession and ownership of firearms within city limits. They could analogously argue that this law does not violate the 2nd Amendment, because the right of the people to keep and bear arms in just this city has a negligible impact on “the security of a free State” overall.
- tareqak 3y agoFrom the article: Experts told Scientific American that Montana's emissions are significant given its population size, emitting in 2019 "about 32 million tons of carbon dioxide." That's "about as much as Ireland, which has a population six times larger," Scientific American reported.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoI guess it's a question of "absolutely none" vs "proportionally almost none". So if you died of 1000 cuts and I inflicted 1 cut, then I am not guilty of any crime because proportionally my impact was almost none?
- lukas099 3y agoThey have about the same share of the responsibility as they do of the consequences. (actually greater share of the responsibility and lesser of the consequences, but still)
- pauldenton 3y agoAre there many car factories in Montana? Are there strip mines? Frakking oil fields? This is Montana not North Carolina
- hobs 3y agoJust the coal power plants that TFA mentioned that got to skip regulatory evaluation because of friendly politicians.
- tareqak 3y agoFrom the Reuters page for this story: In a June trial, the youths had argued that despite its sparse population, Montana is responsible for an outsized share of global emissions. The state is a major producer of coal, oil and gas that is shipped elsewhere and is also the home of pipelines and other infrastructure needed to ship those fuels. https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/montana-judge-hands-historic-win-young-plaintiffs-climate-change-case-2023-08-14/ https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/montana-judge-h...
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoI hate driving into Billings. Huge oil refinery or something right next to I94. Smells like poison. Edit: found this link https://www.eia.gov/state/analysis.php?sid=MT#:~:text=Montana%20has%204%20refineries%20with,are%20in%20the%20Billings%20area https://www.eia.gov/state/analysis.php?sid=MT#:~:text=Montan....
- COGlory 3y agoAre you seriously asking if there are strip mines in Montana? I can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not.
- wildzzz 3y agoWhat a ridiculous claim. Does this guy think there's just a single pollution factory in China doing all the damage? Whole Montana cannot be solely to blame, they can certainly share some blame just like any government that has any sort of greenhouse gas production within its jurisdiction. Oh wait, they aren't allowed to do environmental impact studies that consider greenhouse gas so there's no data to support the claim that Montana produces any!