4 ms·
I buy the value of walkable neighborhoods, but it's hard to make this epidemiological claim hold up; Canada and the US have broadly similar infrastructure but s
by tptacek 3y ago
I buy the value of walkable neighborhoods, but it's hard to make this epidemiological claim hold up; Canada and the US have broadly similar infrastructure but sharply different rates of mental illness; similarly, mental illness rates don't appear to track walkability in Europe.
- loandbehold 3y agoWalkability is good for physical health. Walking is a light exercise. Physical health improves mental health. But I'm not sure if walkability directly improves mental health.
- eBombzor 3y agoCanada also has free healthcare. There are an infinite number of cultural differences that could affect the mental health rates in EU/CA more positively than in the US.
- glonq 3y ago"free", but you often get what you pay for. source: am canadian.
- groby_b 3y agoAs opposed to overpaying for things that aren't actually helping you, but sure make the insurance company happy? Source: Am USian. (Also worth noting that you can add private health care to your menu. If you balk at the cost, welcome to the US model)
- grumple 3y agoIn the US, you'll empty your bank account and still get terrible service - you've spent money but received terrible care. Maybe things change if you can afford your own full-time doctor for 500k / year. Canada ranks above the US in every healthcare measure.
- glonq 3y agoWell thankfully in my case, cancer treatment in Canada has been both free and quite competent. But for lesser things, you might linger for an intolerable amount of time waiting for care. I recall getting good, quick care when I worked in the US and had a good HMO.
- korse 3y agoHow/where? Is this actually a 'solid insurance is hard to get problem'? Neither myself or family (extended included) have experienced problems and we certainly don't have private doctors. The whole 'american healthcare bad/unaffordable' argument is something that I hear quite a bit on the internet, but pretty much never do in real life.
- grumple 3y ago> The whole 'american healthcare bad/unaffordable' argument is something that I hear quite a bit on the internet, but pretty much never do in real life. What bubble are you in? For some of us, we make enough money that paying 400/month for insurance while our employer does the same isn't a big deal. For us software engineers, it's no big deal. For the 50% of people making under 60k a year, that's a large chunk of their income. I hear it constantly from friends nationwide (I have a very large extended circle for a few reasons), media, and my wife, who is a healthcare worker and deals with insurance constantly (as does anyone in healthcare in the US) or my mother (also in healthcare). And of course, we have lots of friends who are in healthcare. And I hear it from my parents, who, as aging people, have more healthcare needs. Your insurance company gets to delay or prevent access to prescriptions, surgeries, or physical therapy as long as they desire. I'm in Philadelphia, which is one of the biggest cities in the US and where healthcare makes up a much larger than usual portion of our local economy [0]. You can find numerous other sources to support this, Philly is a huge biomedical / healthcare hub. It's almost like being in LA for film or SF for tech. Where insurance really starts to suck is if you and your healthcare providers think you need care, but the insurance company says no. My wife experiences rejections from her patient's insurance companies daily. Happens with Medicare too. 0. https://www.besthealthdegrees.com/careers/the-top-10-cities-with-the-most-health-care-jobs/ https://www.besthealthdegrees.com/careers/the-top-10-cities-...
- throw0101c 3y ago> "free", but you often get what you pay for. You pay your taxes and you gets your health care. As opposed to the US where even if you pay your premiums you may not get coverage if you go to the "wrong" (out of network) hospital, or the "wrong" (OON) doctor even if in the right hospital. Be sure to inform your ambulance driver of your in-network hospitals so you get taken to the "correct" hospital after a car crash. When my father had to get new heart valves the most that had to be paid was hospital parking. source: am canadian.
- glonq 3y ago[flagged]
- tptacek 3y agoRight, this is my point. I don't think mental health is as traceable to city planning as this thread hopes.
- moritzwarhier 3y agoI don't think it's hard to make this claim hold up at all. Have you looked at local differences apart from comparing HUGE countries with each other; one of which has an extremely low population density? Since you are mentioning walkable "very similar" infrastructure, how do you quantidy actual walkability? It takes a single search to find many different studies and meta-studies about correlations between noise, air pollution and mental illness, cardiovascular health, life expectancy and others. I encourage you to look for studies about a metropolitan area near you: Car traffic is not harmless. Noise is not harmless. It's just that those who contribute the most to pollution anr noise usually don't experience it every day for hours on end, or even during their sleep. If you prefer esoteric subjects to obvious ones, I'd recommend this study: https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/11/5/467 https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/11/5/467 If you are looking for proofs for the obvious (living at a busy road makes you sick), there are plenty of studies about this subject as well. Cancer rates rise, IQ drops, life expectancy drops, all in clear correlation to your immediate environment. As a German, also the pedestrian's and cyclist's utopia that Europe is painted as on US media also sickens me. It's purely a matter of money and inheritance. Good luck finding a non-toxic place to live in a big city with an average wage and *without owning a car*. Possible, but exceptional.