4 ms·
> Beyond the new routing, they also completely changed the school schedules to 'stagger' the starts for groups of kids and schools. Some kids were getting on th
by toast0 3y ago
> Beyond the new routing, they also completely changed the school schedules to 'stagger' the starts for groups of kids and schools. Some kids were getting on the bus as early as 5am, and elementary school children were dismissed at like 2 in the afternoon; meanwhile some high school schedules ran past 5pm.
The details matter of course, but staggering start times is good for two things. a) seems like high school aged kids are more responsive to a later start time than younger kids, so better for the students maybe. b) staggered start time can reduce the number of busses and drivers needed if you don't want to mix kids of different age groups (which you probably don't!).
However, it comes with a big downside, cascading failure. If bus X does routes A, B, and C in order, and gets behind schedule for route A, route B starts behind schedule, and likely route C as well; depending on how far behind and how much slack is in the schedule.
For school bus routes, morning pickup can often recover, if the bus is late enough, some students will find an alternate route which means fewer pickups which speeds the route. For afternoon drop off, you're pretty stuck, drivers can't leave the school until loading finishes, even if it's delayed or just slow as students get used to the bus. Drivers can't skip drop offs when they're behind schedule.
Reducing the number of routes is probably required to match up the number of drivers with the number of routes... but if each route hits more points, the routes become longer and the slack between runs gets shorter.
- eutropia 3y agoThe start time changes can of course make sense (e.g. teenagers later in the day), but a big issue for smaller kids ending significantly earlier is childcare. Who's going to look after your second grader from 2pm-5pm+ when you get off of work? Keep in mind, the kids riding the bus are not the kids whose parents can drop them off and pick them up; and one of the education system's primary functions is childcare. But sure, in principle - if you are thoughtful, changes from the status quo can be better.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoHell, who's going to look at them at 5am if they're having to get up that early? You're asking probably working parents to sacrifice at least 2, if not more, hours of sleep. For parents who work overnights, they may not even be home yet. Staggered schedules might make sense, but not the way this was done.
- toast0 3y ago> The start time changes can of course make sense (e.g. teenagers later in the day), but a big issue for smaller kids ending significantly earlier is childcare. Who's going to look after your second grader from 2pm-5pm+ when you get off of work? This is like the daylight savings debate. Just like you can't make more daylight, just move it around the clock; the school system is only going to mind your kids for a certain number of hours, you can start it earlier or later, but they're going to do the number of hours they want, and you need to figure out the rest. Yes if you've got multiple generations of kids, and they all get home around the same time, the olders can mind the youngers, and you miss out on that if the olders get home much later because of staggering. But if your school district is an extensively bussed district and doesn't have the budget to attract enough drivers, you've got to make it up somehow. In my area, we have a lot of bussing because of the rural nature, not for integration, but all of the congregate childcare options are accessible by busses (or are literally across the street from a school, and send a person to collect children at dismissal time and safely cross the street). Sending your children to congregate childcare certainly costs money though.