3 ms·
>Almost none of the people that I know that were born there could live there today. Is that bad? Should you have a right to live where you were born in perpetu
by gruez 3y ago
>Almost none of the people that I know that were born there could live there today.
Is that bad? Should you have a right to live where you were born in perpetuity? What about everyone else that wants to live in Amsterdam? If housing is limited and we need to ration it, why should it go towards people who were born there? Doesn't that create a class of landed gentry that have the "right" to live in amsterdam and everyone else who doesn't?
- politelemon 3y ago> What about everyone else that wants to live in Amsterdam? What about them?
- gruez 3y agoMaybe read the rest of the comment? >If housing is limited and we need to ration it, why should it go towards people who were born there? Doesn't that create a class of landed gentry that have the "right" to live in amsterdam and everyone else who doesn't?
- the_lego 3y ago> Is that bad? Yes. A home is not an economic asset like any other. It is the biggest link to one's community and people. Healthy communities cannot form from transient populations.
- gruez 3y ago>Healthy communities cannot form from transient populations. That sounds more like you're more against airbnb and other short term rentals rather than "Rich outsiders are buying up desirable property all over the world" or thinking that "I know that were born there could live there today" is some sort of wrong in and of itself.
- the_lego 3y agoA few tourists doesn't mean the community itself is transient. Even a great many tourists doesn't mean that, if the locals are mostly static. They form a community, and watch the tourists come and go.
- PicassoCTs 3y agoLets ask the lynch mob assembling right outside our door.. voting to turn us into chandeliers.. Srsly, free market autism fully go and all that, but maybe a trace of survival instinct? Like not every place on the planet is SF. And not every place on the planet wants to be shanghai and Dhubai, were the rich do as they please? And money as a protective shield can rapidly devalue in a crisis?
- gruez 3y ago> Lets ask the lynch mob assembling right outside our door.. voting to turn us into chandeliers.. >Srsly, free market autism fully go and all that, but maybe a trace of survival instinct? [...] So you're basically saying that that economic or moral justifications don't matter, and all that matters is how others feel? I guess that's true to some extent. If there was a bolshevik resolution tomorrow I'm certainly not going to advocate for free markets, but this line of reasoning is utterly toxic for rational discussion. It doesn't matter what's right or wrong, just whether you will get lynched for it or not.
- PicassoCTs 3y agoThere is a economic point were the fabric of society breaks down and some parts of the world go through that every day. All those philosophic and law-debates vanish behind that point. The law might return some day, but even then, usually a amnesty is declared on the past, so those alive can focus on repeating the mistakes that propel this loop happily ever onwards.
- eesmith 3y ago> Should you have a right to live where you were born in perpetuity? An absolute right? No, of course not. But no one is arguing for that. Various places say you have the right to live in your rented home for an indefinite period. Your landlord can't decide to kick you out directly, nor simple jack up the price as a way to force you out. But you still need to pay rent, not use it to run a criminal activity, not allow vermin to infest the home, and so on. > What about everyone else that wants to live in Amsterdam? What about them? > why should it go towards people who were born there? Because for most people forced relocation is very stressful. It means breaking friendships, emotional ties to a place, and possibly finding a new job. Not considering human emotions sounds inhumane. > Doesn't that create a class of landed gentry What an odd analogy. Landed gentry make most or all of their money from rental income. No. Nor does it make them serfs tied to the land. It makes them residents.
- fragmede 3y ago>> Should you have a right to live where you were born in perpetuity? > An absolute right? No, of course not. But no one is arguing for that. Laws like California's Prop 13 are actually arguing that you should have that right. The quintessential argument for Prop 13 is that your grandmother won't be able to afford property taxes if they match appreciation of housing prices, so a property that was several hundred grand when she bought it, with property taxes that are representative of that price, she can afford. Property taxes representative of the multi million dollar valuation that house now would go for on the open market, she could not afford. So she pays the lower amount. So she's able to live there in perpetuity, theoretically. (In reality, rising other costs mean that she can't, not on a fixed income.
- eesmith 3y agoAs you yourself pointed out, California's Prop 13 does not give anyone absolute right to live somewhere. If you cannot pay the taxes, you cannot live there. If you cannot pay the water/power/maintenance you cannot live there. Just like if you can't pay the rent, even in country like Sweden with strong renter protections, you can be evicted. Limited allodial title is rare. True allodial title is very rare. In the US the federal government can always assert eminent domain.
- happytoexplain 3y agoIt's bad to the people who feel that it is bad - that's the kind of topic it is. If I get priced out of my own neighborhood, it's going to be a traumatic experience that leaves me feeling disillusioned and bitter and sad. That's just how a lot of humans are - we can't ignore humanity. It's going to be great for those moving in! It may also be good economically, but lots of horrible things are economically positive. And no, of course it should not be a "right".