4 ms·
RIAA and ISPs to police your traffic starting July 12
- dreadsword 15y agoWow - this agreement has been in effect for a year? TL;DR: The delay in implementation has been bureaucratic. To quote Ars: ""The system" according to Torrent Freak, involves major labels monitoring BitTorrent and other peer-to-peer networks for copyright infringement, and then reporting that infringement to ISPs, who will monitor their networks for the transgressors." I know labels and so on monitor networks in a variety of ways, but ISPs folding and given entertainment co's an open window into customer identity and raw traffic seems like unhealthy collusion. Shouldn't this come into conflict with various privacy legislation?
- wmf 15y agoISPs giving entertainment co's an open window into customer identity and raw traffic Good thing they're not doing that.
- dreadsword 15y agoIn the past, I understand entertainment co's have identified transgressors from looking at the IPs that are making movies available for download, for instance, and then subpoena-ing account holder info for that IP from the ISP. Or similarly, finding the IP that a torrent is being served from, or whatever. What I read from Ars is that now entertainment co's will have some means of "...monitoring BitTorrent and other peer-to-peer networks" that bypasses the steps required today. What's that mechanism? And whatever it is, is there anyway that a giving entertainment co's a means of monitoring ISPs customers isn't corrosive to privacy?
- wmf 15y agoThey're doing the same kind of monitoring they used to do. It might be better, because now I think they're required to document how their monitoring works and (supposedly) independent experts can comment on the accuracy of these systems.
- mindslight 15y agoFinally! A million thanks! Mark Klein didn't change user complacency, but this will.
- wmf 15y agoExisting discussion here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3711430 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3711430 Ars/TorrentFreak have done a better job explaining the system than CNet.
- mark_integerdsv 15y agoFYI: this has been going on here in South Africa for some time... The first I heard of someone being issued a warning was around 2008, not sure exactly how long it has been going on though. One thing to note is that by and large the ISP just emails you to say 'we are obligated to inform you that Warner Bros is getting uppety' ...I have friends who have received several of these over the years without any further action having been taken.
- shad0wfax 15y agoOne of my friend got a notice from Optimum Online for downloading Adobe Photoshop sometime last year. So I think yes, there is marginal policing that is going on form ISPs already. I think this probably is a better solution than RIAA going after people and suing them for absurd amounts of money. While I don't agree on policing on principle, this could be the least acceptable alternative. Though, I think this is also a good time maybe for VPN services to mushroom around other parts of the world that could be used from USA? (Though, technically you are more easily traceable when using a VPN, since you have signed up with some identifiable information.)
- udp 15y ago> One of my friend got a notice from Optimum Online for downloading Adobe Photoshop sometime last year. So I think yes, there is marginal policing that is going on form ISPs already. That wasn't necessarily the ISP intercepting traffic. When you download a torrent, everyone else active in that torrent gets your IP address.
- astrodust 15y agoAlthough stopping "piracy" is something that's not without merit, isn't this like the post-office opening all your mail to make sure you're not trading bootleg tapes and CDs with your friends?
- djKianoosh 15y agotangentially @ "isn't this like the post-office opening all your mail"... Iran does exactly this. When my grandmom used to send stuff here from Iran, sometimes the letter or package got to the US already shredded open and in a plastic bag from USPS saying sorry it was already like this when we got it. Same in the other direction. Just sayin...
- eternalban 15y agoAziz, the entity is called "The Islamic Republic of" Iran, not Iran. Iran does not materially exist at the moment. Please do not soil the name.
- bsphil 15y agoIran. Deal with it.
- rickmb 15y agoThis is strictly political agreement with very little effect in the real world. The ISPs want to be able to say "look, we're already doing everything we can to stop piracy, no additional legislation please", whereas the RIAA wants to be able to claim "look, we're already cooperating intensely with ISPs to stop piracy and it isn't working, more legislation please". So now the empty suits on both sides are happy and can report this wonderful political victory to their bosses, whilst actually having accomplished fuck all.
- Freestyler_3 15y agoBad thing that this is going to happen, good thing that usenet is out of the picture (for now). Another thing that will most likely happen is that they will use this chance to data mine and use our data for their own good. How good does SSL downloading protect from this?