3 ms·
Despite this, both groups do support renewables, at least nationally, with caveats: https://www.sierraclub.org/ready-for-100 https://www.sierraclub.org/ready-f
by solardev 3y ago
Despite this, both groups do support renewables, at least nationally, with caveats:
https://www.sierraclub.org/ready-for-100 https://www.sierraclub.org/ready-for-100
https://www.audubon.org/news/wind-power-and-birds https://www.audubon.org/news/wind-power-and-birds
- acdha 3y agoThis is true-ish but as someone who gets donation requests from both of them I’ve literally never once heard either group mention it. I think OP’s point is correct: these groups originated from relatively affluent communities and nobody wants to say “if you really treasure the sierras, don’t drive there - even in an EV”.
- solardev 3y agoI think the OP's point definitely stands -- don't disagree at all! Sorry, I was trying to illustrate that the chapters and national do have different priorities that sometimes conflict (or at least cause nuance). It's not a simple binary thing. Different chapters can disagree with each other. National can disagree with itself. I've volunteered with the Sierra Club both locally in different areas and on some national/regional climate programs. I've also sat in on local Audubon meetings when they've looked at and discussed the details of local wind projects to decide if they should support or oppose it, balancing local wildlife needs with national climate priorities. And often energy companies will hold environmental review meetings for the public, where these groups and others would send representatives. (Was an environmental science and journalism student in college, and our area had a looooot of meetings about land use conflicts, being both full of endangered species and ripe for renewables development). My underlying point is that these are inherently nuanced issues with local, regional, and national (and of course global) perspectives. The chapters and national groups understand that, and they are of course also concerned about climate change. They're not blind to these basic facts, but it's not as simple as simply developing over all our protected lands to build new energy projects if that means killing (too) many of the species they were trying to protect to begin with. It's also not as simple as simply rejecting renewables in favor of, say, using less energy. It's a hard problem all around, and balanced solutions require an understanding of all the costs and benefits involved, not unthinking adherence to any dogma. Even the elitism thing... yes, it's very true, especially historically. But there is a push in these groups (facing both internal and external pressures) to diversify both in ethnicity/culture and economic class so that conservation isn't just something for rich white hermits. Even Muir doesn't quite have the same worshipful status he once did. More diversity also means that environmental justice becomes a more significant factor -- where to site nuclear projects, for example, or whether rich NIMBYs displace poor NIMBYs because they are better able to put up legal hurdles and marketing campaigns. And as outdoor rec becomes more popular, accessibility vs preservation is an ongoing issue (but that's a while other can of worms). I think there will always be people who want to make nature an exclusive club for a small group of rich white hikers, and the only remedy to that is more diverse involvement in these groups (or other groups like Latino Outdoors). The chapter model actually makes that more possible because you're not directly tackling an old white board at the national level, but engaging with neighbors on shared issues.