3 ms·
What if there were solar sites with no endangered animals? Acres of rangeland, abandoned malls, warehouse rooftops, aqueducts, lakes... I dunno if it's really
by solardev 3y ago
What if there were solar sites with no endangered animals? Acres of rangeland, abandoned malls, warehouse rooftops, aqueducts, lakes...
I dunno if it's really an either or. Endangered species are often endangered because of extreme habitat loss, which means by definition there's not a lot of land left for them to live on, which means most projects won't intersect them. Of course the connection isn't that basic (desert is good for both tortoises and solar farms) but it does suggest one has more flexibility than the other.
What percentage of utility scale renewables projects are blocked by endangered species? One recent study suggests environmental impacts are a source of opposition in half of the studied projects: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421522001471#fig3 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030142152...
That's a lot, but doesn't necessarily mean it was the only (or primary) source of opposition.
A lot of these bigger projects have to undergo environmental review via federal (NEPA) and state (CEQA) processes, which are expensive and slow (by design, to ensure their validity) and many projects stall when developers move on to locales with laxer rules and neighbors -- essentially giving up before the environmental impacts could be fully analyzed.
My underlying point is that these things are rarely black and white, and there may be valid reasons to consider each project on a case by case basis. However, there might also be a valid reason to overhaul these laws to allow weighting climate priorities against individual protected species. If so, though, that should be very carefully and rarely done... once we lose those, they're never coming back. We can always find alternate energy sources/sites if we're willing to pay more. No amount of money will bring back extinct species (yet).