3 ms·
I work in solar and support renewables projects, but I found this article really one-sided. What were the reasons these groups opposed the projects? What did t
by solardev 3y ago
I work in solar and support renewables projects, but I found this article really one-sided.
What were the reasons these groups opposed the projects? What did the national groups have to say about their local chapters' priorities? Were any of them aware of the climate impacts, and if so, what was their counterarguments? Surely it's not as simple as "tortoise good, solar bad".
NIMBYism is everywhere, but only rarely does it intersect with protected species habitat. Solar is not particularly land constrained, and much of California etc. already has more than its grid can store. Wind is much more susceptible to land use conflict because it's harder to site, but its bird impacts are minimal and can mitigated. Meanwhile, plain ol "it's ugly and noisy and causes EM pollution and gives me headaches" NIMBYism happens even without endangered animals.
Is it the case that these groups support renewables except in exceptionally sensitive areas? Do they make a case by case judgment call? Do they fight climate policy and renewables development across the board? Did they consider more than just the tree impacts of high density urban development? None of this was really explored or discussed in the blog.
I've been to several public meetings discussing these sorts of land use conflicts, along with chapter meetings of both pro and anti development groups. They usually are complicated and backed by numerous stakeholders of both sides, each with studies presentations and lots and lots of public comments and controversies. They were never as one sided and simple as this article paints them to be. YMMV, but I have a hard time believing that without details...