3 ms·
That's a very pejorative way of saying "I don't agree" and unfortunate in the context of her specifically, since she's been the recipient of foul sexist abuse f
by ggm 3y ago
That's a very pejorative way of saying "I don't agree" and unfortunate in the context of her specifically, since she's been the recipient of foul sexist abuse from her media presence, and even from some of her peers.
There's room for scholarly disagreement. There's no need to be nasty. She's not a racist revisionist. Ethnicity across roman times, and the degree of ethnicity in the forces stationed in the british islands is complicated.
There is some reason to believe there had been trade links into the islands of greater britain from distant economies long before the Roman invasion, and there were Romans, Auxilliaries, traders and slaves from across the Roman empire into North Africa and the middle east who would have found themselves in the margins, by virtue of the economics and politics of the time: you don't leave conquered peoples in-place if you want to ensure there's no slave revolt, you deploy them elsewhere.
- lmm 3y ago> There is some reason to believe there had been trade links into the islands of greater britain from distant economies long before the Roman invasion, and there were Romans, Auxilliaries, traders and slaves from across the Roman empire into North Africa and the middle east who would have found themselves in the margins, by virtue of the economics and politics of the time All true, and all irrelevant; Middle-Eastern and North African people do not (and did not) have the skin tones that were being depicted in the cartoons in question. > There's room for scholarly disagreement. There's no need to be nasty. She's not a racist revisionist. It wasn't scholarly disagreement, it was deception. She used her erudition and her position to wilfully mislead the less sophisticated; she said things that while literally true were intended to create a false impression in the minds of those reading. That is absolutely something to be condemned in the strongest possible terms; it's very much akin to when a physically strong person uses that strength to bully those weaker than them.
- ggm 3y ago"in my opinion" ... <the above>
- lmm 3y agoNo, none of this is stuff that reasonable people can disagree about. No credible anthropologist thinks that middle-eastern/north african peoples of that time had the sub-saharan skin tones seen in those videos, and Beard is not ignorant enough to think so either (and indeed doesn't claim so - rather she sophistically pretends that people are asking a different question).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]