5 ms·
Intellectually, I understand all this. However when I read a pile of steaming bull manure that is presented to me at the link as a political argument, I literal
by smsm42 15y ago
Intellectually, I understand all this. However when I read a pile of steaming bull manure that is presented to me at the link as a political argument, I literally feel sick a little. And that given that I am a libertarian (not a Ron Paul kind, but still) and so have significant affinity to some of the GOP positions and thus my prejudices lie rather in favor than against GOP candidates. I am not an US voter, but if I were, I would not be able to vote for a person that publishes such a vile idiocy under his name. I'm sure he could appeal to the same base without this - there must be other issues and things he could use as his special advantage. I don't believe one has to go that stupid.
- philwelch 15y ago> I am not an US voter, but if I were, I would not be able to vote for a person that publishes such a vile idiocy under his name. Unless you live in US flyover country and are intimately familiar with the types of people who live there, you won't understand Santorum. It's just a cultural gap. For what it's worth, I could name some popular opinions and ideas in, for instance, Europe that are just as shocking and repugnant to me.
- jvrossb 15y agoI don't think American culture is as uniform as you're implying it is. I'm from the bay area in california and Santorum's positions seem very foreign to me, but everyone in my circles around here at least thinks they "get" Santorum - it is accepted wisdom that's he's a crazy idiot. I don't think someone who isn't a U.S. voter is automatically more at a disadvantage than most Americans when it comes to understanding what's going on this election season. Curious to hear some European opinions that are shocking to you. I wonder if they would be shocking to Americans in general and I wonder if Europeans would agree that those opinions and ideas are uniformly European.
- dagw 15y agoCurious to hear some European opinions that are shocking to you. One European idea (as practised in a reasonable sub set of Europe) that I can see many Americans finding shocking are the legal limits to free speech. Gun control is another one which would shock at least a fair number of Americans (again this varies a bit across Europe, but is always far stricter than in the US). Various ideas on taxation is a third, depending slightly on your political leaning. The lax (from a US perspective) attitude towards punishing criminals as yet another.
- yequalsx 15y agoI do not get the lax jail sentences for violent crimes in Europe either. For me it's not about punishment but about preventing such people from perpetrating their violence again. I don't get it but here in Europe (at least until recently) they have less violent crime so it appears to work for them.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- saraid216 15y agoThe parent to your comment would have made a lot more sense to you if you had read its parent. Just saying.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- einhverfr 15y agoI have lived in rural parts of the US most of my life and I don't see Santorum's positions as being from most of there either. It IS typical of a small subset of people widely dispersed, though, and that includes some Catholics and Evangelicals I know.....
- philwelch 15y agoThe Bay Area ain't flyover country.
- stonemetal 15y agoI don't think American culture is as uniform as you're implying it is. I'm from the bay area in california When was the last time the bay area was referred to as flyover country? And so far Santorum has won 10 and seconded quite a few other primaries. Crazy or not he appears to reflect the ideas of a large portion of the american populous. He regularly gets 20-30% of the vote.
- josephcooney 15y agoPlease tell me what ideas euorpeans hold that you find morally repugnant.
- wickedchicken 15y agoPlease don't start "my country vs. your country" threads.
- josephcooney 15y agoI don't live in Europe. I was legitimately curious.
- swordswinger12 15y agoI find their criminalization of right-wing radical speech to be pretty repugnant, e.g. jail time for Holocaust denial in Germany. Don't get me wrong, Holocaust deniers are all mad as hatters, but they shouldn't be thrown in jail for expressing an opinion. See also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech_by_country#European_Union http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech_by_country#Eu...
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoI find many of these laws quite outdated as well, but you have to consider the historical context. These laws were made at a time when the nazis had just murdered millions of people, caused a world war, and most importantly, were still holding all the influencial positions in the country. The nazis were a broad popular movement. It wasn't just some dictator and his family who could be removed in a day. Most of the intellectual elite was either dead or had left the country. The nazis had replaced everyone who held any kind of official role with their own people. All the judges, university teachers, school principals, police officers, civil servants, etc, they were all nazis or opportunistic collaborators with questionable political attitudes. There was no way all these people could have been removed from their posts or put in jail where they really belonged. Preventing them from being politically active, banning their symbols and everything they might reunite behind in order to regain power, was seen as the only practical way to diffuse a very real threat. Also, the laws were made at a time when no law could be made without the approval the US government. After all, a large number of US, British, Russian, and other soldiers had just lost their lives liberating Europe and removing the nazis from power. It would have been insane to just let the nazis resume their political activities. But 66 years on they are no longer a threat. They have almost no popular support, and the very specific laws that violate free speech could now be replaced by general laws against inciting violence like they exist in all countries.
- Drbble 15y agoBelieving that the GOP that exists today is more libertarian in ways that actually affect your life, and what libertarianism means to you, regarding how government operates than the Democratic party is a mistake. Politics is not about grand philosophies and isms, it is about what set of deals and compromises each politician has made.
- smsm42 15y agoEconomically, the GOP, while being far from what I would like, is closer to that than the Dems. Of course, it is all relative - lately, by not letting a good crisis to go to waste, Dems moved severely to the anti-libertarian direction, and the GOP was dragged kicking and screaming a bit to the libertarian direction. So the choice here would be between quite bad and somewhat not as bad as that. Economic issues are usually far more pervasive than social issues - you can filter out 99% of social issues by turning off the TV, but the economy will influence your life whatever you do and wherever you are. I say if they raise taxes it would immediately hurt me both directly in person and through my employment (less free income - less money to buy stuff that I do - less income to the company I work for - no raises to the employees). If they accept or deny gay marriage, for example, with all my respect to people that seek or oppose it, it would not matter a bit in my life, regardless of my opinion on it. So in general I feel the GOP is, well, I wouldn't say more libertarian - it's like saying Al Capone is more pacifist than Pol Pot - but less anti-libertarian where it affects my life. Maybe I am mistaken but that's the conclusion I have arrived to so far.
- mturmon 15y ago"my prejudices lie rather in favor than against GOP candidates. [...] I'm sure [Santorum] could appeal to the same base without this - there must be other issues and things he could use as his special advantage. I don't believe one has to go that stupid." Alas, then you don't really understand the GOP. These beliefs are representative of a large chunk of the GOP base. Santorum's success is not a fluke in that regard.
- smsm42 15y agoThere's a large (large enough to be detectable) amount of people that believes 9/11 was organized by Bush and the moon landing was filmed in Hollywood. Yet you do not see Obama saying that or any sane politician promoting that. There's a difference between leading and appealing to the base (pun intended) instincts. I know politicians frequently do the latter, and it is disgusting every time.