4 ms·
He gave sufficient numbers to do the math on how many people die while waiting for their turn. It is thousands in this case. Regarding the NHS you are falling
by adastra22 3y ago
He gave sufficient numbers to do the math on how many people die while waiting for their turn. It is thousands in this case.
Regarding the NHS you are falling victim to the binary choice fallacy. It is not a strict choice between NHS’s model and the American hyper privatized healthcare. Where I’m writing this, Taiwan, there is a first-class healthcare system that has national single-payer insurance for all residents (only $27/mo!!), and generally no waiting list and patients can normally see any specialist they wish with walk-in appointments during usual working hours.
You can have your cake and eat it too.
- sneak 3y agoAlso, almost anyone who wishes can, at any time, fly to a country that has affordable and efficient healthcare and be a customer. I have friends (Americans) who have had procedures recently in South Korea, Turkiye, and Germany. Sometimes it's just easier and faster, and isn't that expensive even if you don't use insurance.
- adastra22 3y agoThat's why I'm in Taiwan right now :)
- tenpies 3y agoI'm honestly surprised there is not an entire class of insurance programs for people who happen to live in a jurisdiction that has basically said "we would rather you die on a wait list than allow private healthcare" (e.g. British Columbia in Canada[1]). That insurance would cover healthcare abroad, maybe constrained to certain geographies and conditions. Unlike travel insurance it would assume that your care abroad is necessary due to a lack of services in your home jurisdiction. Perhaps the actuarial data is hard to collect, but I suspect it would be a booming business as most countries with socialised system seem to be heading towards a total decline, if not outright collapse. --- [1] https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/b-c-upholds-ban-on-private-health-care-clinics-but-case-expected-to-go-to-supreme-court https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/b-c-upholds-ban-on-priv...
- arrowsmith 3y ago> It is not a strict choice between NHS’s model and the American hyper privatized healthcare. You'd be amazed by how few people in the UK understand this.
- lostlogin 3y agoSame goes for the US.
- Loocid 3y agoInteresting that you framed it this way and not the other way around.
- arrowsmith 3y agoI don't understand. "The other way around" compared to what?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jopsen 3y ago> Taiwan, there is a first-class healthcare system that has national single-payer insurance for all residents (only $27/mo!!) How? At 27 USD/month/person, are you sure you're not failing to account for taxes and other government funding for healthcare? Don't get me wrong. Healthcare could be better and cheaper. We could train more doctors to lower wages :) But healthcare and care in general is a hard place to increase productivity. New treatments and drugs help, but anything advanced usually have to involve humans.
- xeonmc 3y agoSecret to Taiwan’s healthcare: slave labor of the doctors.
- adastra22 3y agoDoctors seem to get by just fine. They are paid a living wage like any professional, and take on little to no debt from medical school (one of the top schools is $4000/yr in tuition).
- adastra22 3y agoYes I said it was nationalized healthcare. But Taiwan’s tax burden isn’t oppressive either. Tax brackets are pretty similar to the US. They start by not paying the insane wages the rest of the first world has normalized. There is no reason a typical doctor should be expecting half a million $$ in total compensation. They also cut out a lot of middlemen. No private insurance. Doctors offices are also pharmacies. No domestic pharma industry abusing the paten system to extract rents from medications. Etc.
- jopsen 3y ago> Yes I said it was nationalized healthcare. But Taiwan’s tax burden isn’t oppressive either. Yes, but let's be clear: It's not 27 USD / month per capita. I live in Denmark with public heathcare, it's not horrible, but wait times for non-critical things are longer than it was in the US (with a great insurance). Not that it's been a huge issue for me. In any case, I'm pretty sure our healthcare system is more than 27 USD/month per capita :D A random search for healthcare expenditure puts the number around 650 USD/month per capita (probably you can find a different number and make it larger/smaller, so I'd take this as a ballpark figure).