3 ms·
The distinction does matter. Racism is wrong because race is without substance. Your genetics don’t determine anything about you that would matter to people liv
by rayiner 3y ago
The distinction does matter. Racism is wrong because race is without substance. Your genetics don’t determine anything about you that would matter to people living around you.
Everything else is fair game. Having people in your community who don’t share your language, or your cultural context, etc., makes your life more difficult. Those difficulties are what cause Japanese and Chinese people frustration even with foreign-born Japanese and Chinese people. (Which is why you can’t chalk it up to “racism.”)
Moreover, that sentiment is not limited to China and Japan. Indians, Bangladeshis, etc., don’t want mass immigration either. It’s not as much of a political issue in this countries because those countries don’t have inverted population pyramids. I suspect most people in the Middle East or Africa would feel the same way if immigration were a major phenomenon in those places.
Now you can say “the rest of the world is just wrong” but you’re going to need more than that ipse dixit.
- tptacek 3y agoI am not required to take seriously the concern that people who "don't share your language" "make life more difficult". Coping with, and eventually prospering from the complexities of other people is part of building a western-style free society. If this is an elaborate rhetorical ploy to get me to say that American culture is superior to that of the rest of the world in this regard, you needn't have been so coy, because I'm happy to come out and say it. You can decode a lot of our political differences to my lack of contempt for American culture and civic values.
- rayiner 3y ago> I am not required to take seriously the concern that people who "don't share your language" "make life more difficult". Of course you are. It’s a social problem that is so recurrent that it’s literally in the Bible: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tower_of_Babel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tower_of_Babel. Disunity and a diversity of languages was God’s punishment for humanity’s hubris. > Coping with, and eventually prospering from the complexities of other people is part of building a western-style free society. This is an empty assertion. How does “coping” with “complexity” result in “profit?” Does America seem to you like a country that’s on a good track as a result of the “complexity” caused by immigration? > If this is an elaborate rhetorical ploy to get me to say that American culture is superior to that of the rest of the world in this regard, you needn't have been so coy, because I'm happy to come out and say it. I get you think American culture is better. I’m blown away that you think the American approach is a moral imperative. > You can decode a lot of our political differences to my lack of contempt for American culture and civic values. My contempt is for the version of American culture that was manufactured in the 20th century to create a moral justification for globalization. That certainly wasn’t the sentiment of the framers, who rooted their theory of society and government in the history and tradition of the English. Even though the founding documents tackle cultural diversity as a matter of necessity—among different subgroups of English-you don’t see that “complexity” being framed as a positive thing. I think the “culture and civic values” you’re referring to reflects a minority of Americans even today. Of course, half the country voted for Donald Trump. Among the other half, there are many who prefer to live in cultural enclaves. Bangladeshis in Queens aren’t thinking that what their blocks need is more non-Bangladeshis. By contrast, what is a fundamental American civic value is self governance. And mass immigration fatally jeopardizes that. You can’t have real, bottom-up democracy where large swaths of the population lack generational experience in democracy, or are insecurely rooted in this country and will vote for whoever promises them support and services. That’s a recipe for oligarchy.
- tptacek 3y agoYou've confused American values for those of Stan Kelly. Here's an actual founding father: The citizens of the United States of America have a right to applaud themselves for having given to mankind examples of an enlarged and liberal policy—a policy worthy of imitation. All possess alike liberty of conscience and immunities of citizenship. It is now no more that toleration is spoken of as if it were the indulgence of one class of people that another enjoyed the exercise of their inherent natural rights, for, happily, the Government of the United States, which gives to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance, requires only that they who live under its protection should demean themselves as good citizens in giving it on all occasions their effectual support. I don't see anything about "Bangladeshi or non-Bangladeshi" in there.