2 ms·
I think is true that C++ is the most complex programming language and historically didn't came with batteries included (e.g. basic stable and secure libraries t
by wslh 3y ago
I think is true that C++ is the most complex programming language and historically didn't came with batteries included (e.g. basic stable and secure libraries that really abstract the problem at hand).
But I don't think Rust is C++ done well. It is another programming language. The Err and Ok could seem weird, traits could really be confusing. This is not against Rust, just saying that it is another programming language.
- constantcrying 3y ago>The Err and Ok could seem weird, traits could really be confusing. C++ allows similar error handling with std::optional (Some()/None in Rust) or std::variant (Err()/Ok() in Rust). C++ also has something similar to traits (with really unreadable syntax). C++ just has a worse syntax for Error handling, since variants aren't enums. If you are using C++ I suggest you still make use of these concepts.
- wslh 3y agoI wasn't saying either C++ or Rust are better or worse, just saying that Rust is not C++ done well which I think it is a very exaggerated claim.
- constantcrying 3y agoAnd I pointed out that C++ includes somewhat worse versions of those concepts.
- wslh 3y agoAnd where do you think C++ is better than Rust?
- jandrewrogers 3y agoFor my use cases, modern C++ is clearly more powerful/expressive than Rust in a couple areas today: metaprogramming and software where object lifetimes/ownership are unknowable at compile-time. These have a large impact on development productivity and software quality, so I'd be reluctant to give them up. Rust has a bunch of other odd gaps, e.g. lack of proper thread-local support, but I can live with that.