4 ms·
> if the richest countries opened their borders for everyone in the world, at least hundreds of millions (if not billions) of people from the world's poor count
by ben_w 3y ago
> if the richest countries opened their borders for everyone in the world, at least hundreds of millions (if not billions) of people from the world's poor countries would immediately immigrate there
Why do you believe this would happen, given that internal migration between rich and poor parts of counties without internal travel restrictions is nowhere near that significant?
It's not like NYC collapsed from all the people leaving Detroit.
- constantcrying 3y agoBeing a welfare recipient in Germany earns you vastly more monsy than working hard in Nigeria. Almost every single Nigerian has a direct economic interest to get to Germany.
- ben_w 3y agoI moved to Germany from the UK before Brexit happened. Doing so roughly doubled my pay. Why do you think so few other British people did what I did, despite this economic incentive? Deutsche Sprache, schwere Sprache. Kuma a cewar abokin aikina na Najeriya, yaren de-facto a Najeriya Ingilishi ne, ba Hausa/Igbo/Yoruba ba.
- constantcrying 3y agoYou can not compare migration of (presumably) high skilled workers with unskilled workers. >Deutsche Sprache, schwere Sprache. So what? Where I live you can get by just fine if you speak turkish or arabic.
- ben_w 3y ago> You can not compare migration of (presumably) high skilled workers with unskilled workers. Why not? Is there a "benefits trap" here in Germany, like in the UK, where working makes you worse off? > So what? Where I live you can get by just fine if you speak turkish or arabic. Have you tried living without the local language? As an outsider, first few times at the supermarket checkout was mortifying, just because there's three different common ways people ask if you want a receipt. The government bureaucracy? Getting my Anmeldebestätigung sorted was intimidating (in the UK, the equivalent is posted through your letterbox and you fill it out and post it). Mandatory health etc. insurance? I misunderstood, picked an irrelevant kind of insurance instead of what I needed, only found out when I got a job and HR told me and sorted it for me.
- constantcrying 3y ago>Have you tried living without the local language? No.
- defrost 3y agoHaving a job in Germany earns you vastly more money than being a welfare recipient in Germany. Almost every single Nigerian has a direct economic interest to get a job in Germany. Hard figures demonstrate that immigrants frequently work harder and deliver more than many of those in the country they immigrate to.
- constantcrying 3y ago>Hard figures demonstrate that immigrants frequently work harder and deliver more than many of those in the country they immigrate to. over 50% of syrians do not work at all. >Having a job in Germany earns you vastly more monsy than being a welfare recipient in Germany. Not really. You just need to have a couple of kids.
- ben_w 3y ago> over 50% of syrians do not work at all. Would those by any chance be either (1) asylum seekers who are banned by law from working, or (2) children or spouses? > You just need to have a couple of kids. Child benefits come with the rather high expense of looking after kids. Also, while Germany has excellent child benefits, they not that high. Also also, the UK says much the same thing even with much worse benefits.
- constantcrying 3y agoNo. 50% receive "citizens money". >or spouses? Women can work too, you know? >asylum seekers who are banned by law from working No such law exists in Germany. You are explicitly allowed to work even while waiting for the decision for being granted asylum is being made.
- ben_w 3y agoIn English, "spouses" is un-gendered; whoever looks after the household may commonly be a woman, but what I wrote doesn't presume that. > You are explicitly allowed to work even while waiting for the decision for being granted asylum is being made Only three months after applying for asylum, with the permission of the Federal Employment Agency, and not if they live in a reception facility.
- badpun 3y ago> Why do you believe this would happen, given that internal migration between rich and poor parts of counties without internal travel restrictions is nowhere near that significant? Because quality of life in Detroit is miles ahead quality of life in Nigeria, Gabon, rural Russia and countless other poor places with no good opportunities.
- ben_w 3y agoThat doesn't seem like a sufficient reason; if we were really just Homo Economicus then any opportunity should have us move to the best opportunities when we can. I posit that we don't because humans are not primarily focusing on economic opportunities, but rather on social ones. That's certainly why my relatives have so many Philippine in-laws back in the UK: they all wanted to be with each other when they moved. Know what's really hard to do when you move? Social opportunities. Especially when you have to… использовать другой язык. Likewise from Gabon: Le français est romantique et tout, mais pas beaucoup d'opportunités aux États-Unis si vous êtes du Gabon et c'est tout ce avec quoi vous avez grandi grâce au colonialisme. Canada might have Francophone job opportunities, but I can't imagine Quebec being much fun to move to if you're used to the sub-Saharan climate.
- qwytw 3y agoSaying that entire populations would move move is course a huge exaggeration. Especially because after 30-40% leave the people remaining would have access to more resources, land etc. which would make emigration less appealing. However 214 million people live in Nigeria alone. If all of them had the right to move to Europe it would not at all be unreasonable that say 30-50 million would do that (just look at what happened in the Eastern European countries which joined the EU in 2004 and the disparity between those countries and WE wasn't even close to being as big as between Nigeria and the richer EU countries today). That's just one country. I would say that 100-200 million Africans moving into the EU over say 10 years if they could would be a pretty conservative estimate. Only around 450 million people live in the European Union and relatively few immigrants would probably move to Eastern Poland or Bulgaria so the immigrants would be concentrated in a few areas where they would quickly outnumber the local population. > because humans are not primarily focusing on economic opportunities I don't think this is true at all in general, especially longterm. > but I can't imagine Quebec being much fun to move to if you're used to the sub-Saharan climate. Have you heard about a country called Sweden? It's cold, dark and damp..