3 ms·
> In January, Newt Gingrich’s space ambitions were mocked by many experts as well as the public, particularly his vow that a moon colony would be established by
by philwelch 15y ago
> In January, Newt Gingrich’s space ambitions were mocked by many experts as well as the public, particularly his vow that a moon colony would be established by the conclusion of his “second term.” Musk isn’t committing to a timeline nearly so ambitious; when pushed by Wright, he suggested that this could be a reality within the next 30 years.
Gingrich's moon base by 2020 is probably less ambitious than Musk's Martian colony by 2042. The moon is orders of magnitude closer, doesn't involve leaving Earth orbit, doesn't involve the radiation hazards, and we've actually been to the moon before. I don't want to get into a political argument, but going back to the moon and staying there is not an especially difficult or onerous goal for the next eight years.
- meric 15y agoYou're forgetting the economy and number of technological achievements grows exponentially. At 4% per annum growth the world economy will be triple the current size in 30 years. (assuming no technological singularity event). An economy triple the current size doesn't seem like it can easily afford a colony on Mars either but I think Elon Musk thinks my assumption is wrong.
- philwelch 15y agoThe economy is irrelevant. Technology just takes time to develop sometimes; nine women can't have a baby in one month.
- meric 15y agoIt's not irrelevant. If our economy one thousandth the current size, even a trip to the moon would be difficult. It just wouldn't be producing enough fuel, metal, ceramics and quality human capital necessary for a trip to the moon. It is a lot easier to takes these things from a much larger economy than a small one. Larger economy can speed up technological advancements too, but I guess that is irrelevant here.
- philwelch 15y agoThe economy already isn't the limiting factor on establishing a Mars colony; technology is. So it's irrelevant.
- meric 15y agoIt'll be much more difficult to convince citizens to set up a Mars colony at a cost of $1,000,000 per citizen as opposed to only $1,000 per citizen. Therefore, I'd argue it is relevant. If you were talking about setting up a privately owned colony - a larger economy means there is more chance of a company large enough to take on this task. (In large economies capital is more concentrated, at least that's what I'm observing from history. It would be difficult to have a company the size of Apple in an impoverished country whose GDP per year is less than Apple's quarterly income, for example.)
- philwelch 15y agoSo every citizen spends $1000 and suddenly you have a Mars colony? No, you have to develop the technology, and that takes time no matter how much money you throw at it. And when you look at the year 2042 and imagine having a Mars colony by then, having an order of magnitude more money rolling around by say 2022 or 2032 won't help if it takes longer than 10-20 years to develop the needed technology.