4 ms·
The real limiting issue tends to be materials in the reactor - at some point, every known material is a liquid or a gas and the reactor stops being an ongoing
by lazide 3y ago
The real limiting issue tends to be materials in the reactor - at some point, every known material is a liquid or a gas and the reactor stops being an ongoing concern.
Usually reactors run cooler by several orders of magnitude, as this is referred to as a ‘meltdown’ and people get snippy about the releases of radiation and expensive cleanup crews, etc.
Space is more forgiving and has fewer HOA types, so they can go closer to the limits - but it’s still the same underlying issue.
- ridgeguy 3y agoYeah, the materials issues dominate design basics. They've looked at HfC and HfCN as nuclear engine materials (m.p. ~3950°C), pretty exotic. I feel like if designers would drop their effort to wring out the last increment of Isp from nuke engines and reduce temperatures to ~2000°C, it would give faster development. There are many materials that can live in 2000° hydrogen for >100K hours. There's an old Rand study that showed H2 would give an Isp >1100 at 1 atm chamber pressure (!), temp ~2000°C, exhaust pressure 10e-4 atm. Seems worth exploring.
- lazide 3y agoThat does sound more reasonable! Part of the issue I suspect why reasonable isn’t being considered is that I don’t expect anyone to have a reason to really use them right now regardless - all the nuclear propulsion designs have a high ‘fixed’ weight cost in the reactor, so would only make sense overall in a ‘hundreds of tons to Uranus ASAP’ type situation, where the overall weight for thrust can be lower due to the better fuel efficiency. So far we thankfully haven’t had a reason to really need to do that right now. And if we’re doing theoretical designs, why not make it ‘interesting’? On a side note, if we’re considering crazy ideas - my favorite is the one that makes Project Orion seem clean! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_salt-water_rocket https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_salt-water_rocket Any rocket which calls for ‘salts of plutonium’ as fuel has to be cool.