4 ms·
With respect to the idea of hosting personal websites without using hosting companies, why does it have to be port 80. Port 80 is what commercial hosting uses
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
With respect to the idea of hosting personal websites without using hosting companies, why does it have to be port 80. Port 80 is what commercial hosting uses, but this proposal is fundamentally different from commercial hosting. I'm not sure I understand why using an agreed-upon high port would not be an acceptable alternative.
As for non-rooted Android not allowing use of port 80, this is just one symptom of the larger problem of not allowing the computer owner to have root privileges. And letting an advertising company have them instead. IMHO.
Unrelated perhaps but it is possible to forward port 80 in Android. For example, I forward tcp/80 to a computer running NetBSD. This can be done using an app, e.g., NetGuard. TLS zealots might want to try this sometime and observe some of the unencrypted egress traffic.
Thought experiment: Imagine you make a salary or other financial gains by applying what you know in the subject matter area of X. Someone comes along and proposes that they want to teach more people about how X works. What is the likelihood you will respond with something like "no one really wants to know how X works". You want to maintain the status quo because you understand that an information asymmetry between people who understand how X works and those who do not must exist in order that you may continue to be paid for or otherwise profit from your knowledge.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoI saw some statistics showing that the majority of people in the US don't even have broadband (speed) internet, let alone a second computer. Here's an uncomfortable thought: The modern day personal website is someone's tiktok profile page. And it's thanks to the fact that everyone has a phone, and tiktok just works. There's an opportunity to learn from this model, though I'm not sure what the lesson is.
- dfc 3y agoI don't think you saw those statistics in the last decade. https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/fact-sheet/internet-broadband/ https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/fact-sheet/internet-bro...
- sillysaurusx 3y agoIt was actually a few months ago. They specifically took issue with the methodologies of broadband companies in measuring home internet usage speeds. When they conducted their own tests across residential America, they determined that most people were unable to connect to the internet at speeds that we’d consider broadband. As someone who was just in the hospital for nine weeks in an area where the cell towers didn’t seem to provide anything higher than 3mbit in downtown St Louis with a >2 second lag time, I can verify that at least some Americans in my corner of the world live in places where broadband is just not a thing. And most of America is rural America. I retweeted it at the time, but annoyingly it looks like twitter doesn't have a way to search for retweets older than 7 days. https://twitter.com/search?q=from%3Atheshawwn%20filter%3Anativeretweets&src=typed_query&f=top https://twitter.com/search?q=from%3Atheshawwn%20filter%3Anat... Here's some stats showing that some ~27M households (almost a quarter) don't have home internet at all, and presumably just use their phones: https://www.reviews.org/internet-service/how-many-us-households-are-without-internet-connection/ https://www.reviews.org/internet-service/how-many-us-househo... Frustratingly, I can find the wolfram alpha statistics I was calculating at the time, but not the article itself that I got them from. https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=162.8+million+divided+by+america%27s+population+age+9+to+80 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=162.8+million+divided+b... EDIT: Aha, 162.8 million was the magic number that started turning some some search results. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/04/technology/digital-divide-us-fcc-microsoft.html#:~:text=Over%20all%2C%20Microsoft%20concluded%20that,particularly%20stark%20in%20rural%20areas https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/04/technology/digital-divide.... The study was from 2018, so I wonder how it's changed in the past five years.
- vel0city 3y ago162.8 / 331.9 = 49% of the whole US population. That seems extremely different from loads of statistics which weren't tracking access but whether households actually had broadband at home. I'd like to see the actual proof of that and their real testing strategies instead of just taking Microsoft at their word on that one. https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/fact-sheet/internet-broadband/ https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/fact-sheet/internet-bro... > Among all households in 2018, 92% had at least one type of computer and 85% had a broadband internet subscription. https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2021/computer-internet-use.html https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2021/computer... > And most of America is rural America What? > Despite the increase in the urban population, urban areas, defined as densely developed residential, commercial, and other nonresidential areas, now account for 80.0% of the U.S. population, down from 80.7% in 2010. > https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2022/urban-rural-populations.html https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2022/urban-ru... As for those who just use their phones at home, if their phones do get above broadband speeds, would that not classify them as having home broadband?
- vlan0 3y agoI think your take hits the nail on the head. Most people have zero interest in running their own website.we live in a world where people have no clue how things work. They just want it to work and not have to understand how. People could change their own brakes and oil too. But how many folks want to? Not many. It doesn’t provide value to them. Just like a personal website wouldn’t provide value to them. Hence, like you said, social media pages are their “personal website”.
- janalsncm 3y agoThe fact that most people don’t understand how things work is a testament to good design. You shouldn’t have to understand how a car works to use a car. You shouldn’t have to understand how a lightbulb works to switch on the lights. Abstraction allows us to build on prior technologies. It’s also a practical reality of living in a complex world. Someone using Excel isn’t thinking about how that app was programmed. Most computer programmers don’t have in-depth knowledge of how a CPU works. And they definitely don’t understand the chemistry of a transistor. The fact is we live in a world too complex to understand it all. That’s not necessarily a bad thing.
- _factor 3y agoIt’s only a bad thing if we live on a world we can’t breathe on anymore because the air filter guy fell asleep.
- nmz 3y agoThere's also environmental factors to consider in anything physical, sure, you changed your oil, but what do you do with the oil now? There's no electrical pollution in running a server.
- vlan0 3y agoIf you live in the US. Auto parts stores take used oil. As do Walmarts with auto service centers. I’ve never had an issue.
- samstave 3y agoI've actually thought a bit about this over the years, and wrote a whitepaper in ~2002 on such... (sorry that file evaporated a decade+ ago) Whereby ; And this was prior to Cloud BTW (and I met with some goog eng friends in 2006 or so about it, but they said it would never be a thing: I wanted a cloud based desktop, with your personal encrytped access key being your phone, which you would dock, and then grab an instance of your desktop from the cloud... (a while later motorola tried to launch such a device...) Anyway, here is my current take: Every phone should be able to have a way to manage your own APIs such that your links to whatever media buckets you have/sub to - you can very easily just create little widgets that will pull your IGs, HNs, whatever and you can just slide the content-boxes around and organize a page very easily... Add a content-box (we attempted to build a site around this idea in ~2005 - no bueno - as mobile didnt exist as it does today) the content box will be [text, pics, audio, links, etc] and you can nest one on top of the other... So add an element - then drop it on top of another to have the link (think tooltip hover to whatever child box on parent) etc... Cloudflare the F out of it - and allow for black/whitelists of content within the profile of the user (never link to FB or Twixxxter, whatever) You get the gist.;
- murphyslaw 3y ago> I wanted a cloud based desktop, with your personal encrytped access key being your phone Sun used to have a desktop product similar to this, it worked with an authentication token like a company badge or whatever. You could go sit at any desk and login and you'd have your own desktop environment including audio. Of course the whole thing was proprietary and it was server side so you needed heavy servers. Also logging in remotely wasn't possible IIRC cause it required a huge network pipe (aka on-premises). It died a quiet death.
- samstave 3y agoYeah, I recall those -- was that the invention of "zero desktop" nomenclature - even though a terminal to a mainframe/AS\400 was the same thing :-) (or a vax (never used a vax)
- eternityforest 3y agoI think the lesson is that stuff that just works is awesome, and it would be really cool if we had a platform with the expressiveness of raw HTML, with the ease of use of Tumblr, and the portability and backup-ability of GitHub. Most of the cool things about personal sites can be replicated without the needless toil of actually messing with hosting yourself. Even Markdown isn't enough. I want a site where we can view posts on a calendar, write things in full BBCode, view by tags or heirarchy (Or a hybrid, like #stories.romance), clone your stuff as a git repo and edit locally, etc.
- dylan604 3y agoToday it's tiktok. Prior it was Facebook. MySpace. GeoCities. Notice the trend? It was always something else. Future tomorrow, it won't be tiktok
- paulcole 3y agoWhy is that an uncomfortable thought? Most people don’t want or need a personal website. I know I don’t — what the heck would I use it for?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hoherd 3y ago> Port 80 is what commercial hosting uses Port 80 is the standard insecure http port assigned by IANA. Whether or not the site is commercial has nothing to do with it. https://www.iana.org/assignments/service-names-port-numbers/service-names-port-numbers.txt https://www.iana.org/assignments/service-names-port-numbers/...
- judge2020 3y ago> As for non-rooted Android not allowing use of port 80, this is just one symptom of the larger problem of not allowing the computer owner to have root privileges. And letting an advertising company have them instead. IMHO. But then there is nothing stopping the user from installing spyware and becoming a botnet zombie by following a video tutorial about "how to install fortnite vbucks generator apk". Most people aren't your average HN reader or techie, they just want a device that facilitates accessing the web and using rich applications/games, all in a safe way that doesn't require them spending hours a week (initially) configuring or playing with their phone to make it work for them. In a world where every user has root privileges (and doesn't need to go through too much friction to "control" their device), and can't even say "I want to purchase an iPhone because it means I can consume content and use social media without needing to worry about malware", more people get hurt - because the average person doesn't know they need these manufacturer-imposed guardrails until they do something dumb one day and get hacked. The solution to fixing this and achieving utopia is education - standardized classes focused on proficiency in identifying scams, learning about how typical services operate and reasoning about what motives actors have. But this is extremely hard to do when the United States doesn't seem to care about this, and it'd be impossible to ensure on a global scale.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pizza 3y agoWhy not go the route of informed consent + sane defaults? It’s more respectful of the user. If informed consent is too difficult to do then there are deeper more fundamental issues with the OS.
- EMIRELADERO 3y agodo macOS users suffer from malware to an extent big enough that would justify the measures currently employed on phones and game consoles?
- judge2020 3y agohttps://www.techradar.com/news/macs-have-too-much-malware-according-to-apples-own-top-exec https://www.techradar.com/news/macs-have-too-much-malware-ac...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago"Security" has become a "justfication" used by so-called "tech" companies for taking control away from the computer owner. One can in fact see this type of rationalisation in this thread. This "justification" is pervasively used across popular consumer OS today.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoWhat would someone do with a "website". Well, what is a "website". People backing so-called "tech" companies will tell us, but the story they tell is biased toward using the web as an advertising and sales medium, from which they, as intermediaries, can profit. The surveillance they perform using this arrangement is other worldly. A website is a computer running an httpd. It's not a "platform" and it's not a means of drawing an audience. Those are specific uses of running an httpd, ones that happen to enrich so-called "tech" company intermediaries, but those are not the only uses. An httpd is a program that reponds to HTTP requests. There is much one can do with HTTP. Certainly, HTTP is not limited to the uses that so-called "tech" companies have chosen: attracting large audiences, mass data collection and the sale and delivery of programmatic advertising. For example, using only HTTP one can transfer and receive files, messages, audio, video, any stream of bytes, to and from one's family, friends and colleagues, directly, without using a so-called "tech" company intermediary. This has been demonstrated, for example, by a gentleman in Japan: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37044318 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37044318 Of course, people that profit from these so-called "tech" companies do not want any discussion of such other uses for HTTP. If the uses do not allow for advertising or some way for certain people to make money, then these people will talk them down. "No one wants that." "I don't want that therefore no one else wants that." "It will not work because..." "We tried it and it failed." We have seen these lame arguments so many times. The more empathic the negative responses from HN commenters to any proposed non-commercial, non-advertising-related uses of the web, the more we can be sure such uses are not only possible but highly probable. Time will show the wiser. It's early days.