5 ms·
If something is obviously not working, or doesn’t make sense, it’s important that the public be able to criticize it by reference to common sense and lived expe
by rayiner 3y ago
If something is obviously not working, or doesn’t make sense, it’s important that the public be able to criticize it by reference to common sense and lived experience. Otherwise, you’re turning over the policing function entirely to the same people who are deeply invested in protecting the legitimacy of a field of inquiry.
Legitimate fields of study usually do not have trouble establishing their legitimacy to ordinary people. My undergraduate degree is in aerospace engineering. I’ve never had to argue from authority to get people to accept that’s a legitimate field that produces actionable facts.
- chasing 3y agoSeems a little naive to believe engineers don’t make arguments from authority all the dang time…
- xyzzyz 3y agoThe point is that they earned this authority, because their planes fly, whereas, for example, experts on childhood education cannot point to such obvious undeniable achievement that laypeople cannot reach.