4 ms·
Hm... the battery numbers are surprising. The battery is 43.5Wh, which is huge. Over 9.5 hours us "use", that comes to 4.6W average. My Dell XPS 15 L501x (ve
by ajross 15y ago
Hm... the battery numbers are surprising. The battery is 43.5Wh, which is huge. Over 9.5 hours us "use", that comes to 4.6W average. My Dell XPS 15 L501x (very much not a "light" machine!) has a 9-cell 91Wh battery and got about 5 hours continuous on it when it was new, for about 18.2W.
So the iPad 3 is drawing 25% the current of a beefy 2.9GHz Arrandale laptop? That's shockingly high, IMHO, especially considering that the screen area of the 15.6" laptop is twice that of the tablet.
Similar, the numbers they show aren't much higher than the range (30-50Wh, 6-9 hours) already achieved by a bunch of netbooks on the market.
- snowwrestler 15y agoWith LED backlighting, isn't most of the screen's power draw driven by the switching? And the iPad has a lot of pixels to switch--almost certainly more than your Dell laptop.
- ajross 15y agoHonestly I'm no expert. But I'd find it very surprising if there was much difference at the same lumens output. The backlight is not per-pixel in a LED-backlit display (maybe you're thinking of OLED displays?), though I understand it's often per-region to allow large dark areas to be under-lit. And note that LED backlights are routinely put up as having overall lower power consumption than CCFL panels like the one in my laptop. Really my point is this: that's a laptop-sized battery in that thing, and it's seeing only slightly super-laptop power draw.
- acqq 15y agoYour point misses the mark: with the 1/2 of the battery of your notebook iPad moves 50% more pixels for twice as long: It's 2 * 1.5 * 2 = 6 times more efficient than your notebook. Of course, usage patterns are also different, but it's still wonderful piece of engineering.
- ajross 15y agoMore efficient only in your oddball unit of pixels-joules/second. I'm not interested in arguing about features or the design tradeoffs of an Apple device, that always leads to a platform flame just like this one. I'm saying that the actual power draw of the iPad is much, much closer to that of a laptop than most of us expected.
- pja 15y agoIIRC the transistor on each pixel colour in the display blocks a fixed amount of light, so the increased pixel density means less area for light to pass through, so a brighter backlight is required to achieve the same light output. (It's possible of course that these high-DPI displays use a process technology with smaller transistors, anyone know?)
- gamble 15y agoHigh-DPI displays have a lower pixel aperture ratio than traditional displays, so the backlight needs to be brighter to give the same perceived brightness. Supposedly the new iPad retina display uses twice as many backlighting elements as the iPad 2. I don't believe switching is the major component in the display's power draw, since adjusting brightness has such a significant effect on battery life. If switching was the dominant factor, you would expect battery life to be roughly independent of brightness settings.
- acqq 15y agoYour Dell XPS has 1920 * 1080 resolution, that is, around 2M pixels. The iPad has 2048 * 1536 which is 3M pixels. Your claim "the screen area of the 15.6" laptop is twice that of the tablet" is actually irrelevant considering the number of pixels and the processing power needed to move all these pixels around for all smooth animations. iPad is definitely impressive engineering feat.
- ajross 15y agoNot sure what you mean. Pixels don't take power by themselves (and of course screen area does take power all by itself). Moving them does, sure, but the GPU (GeForce 420M) in my laptop is signicantly faster (literally 5x the GFLOPs per spec) than the 4x SGX 54x cores in the A5X. I'm not making a platform flame here or asking you to defend your favorite device. I'm just expressing surprise at the apparent power draw of a device that conventional wisdom claims is exceedingly thrifty.
- seanmcd 15y agoI think you are confused on how displays/graphics work. An active display needs to be lit, and the more pixels you have the more lighting is required, so physical size matters less than resolution. As for the GPU, moving the pixels can require more power but you must constantly redraw as your scene changes (you could cache static backgrounds as an image, but this is often not done). GPU power needed is most definitely impacted by resolution and has absolutely no bearing on screen size.
- themgt 15y agoYeah, comparing the specs (CPU/GPU performance/display resolution/weight/battery capacity/disk/RAM) of the iPad vs. MacBook Air over time is pretty compelling evidence that the touch / keyboard & mouse paradigms are converging and the current dichotomy between the two types of devices/OSs won't last much longer