4 ms·
As a corollary of these people problems, I would add: 1. Not correcting problem hires fast enough. First time founders are often too hesitant to give negative
by Aurornis 3y ago
As a corollary of these people problems, I would add:
1. Not correcting problem hires fast enough.
First time founders are often too hesitant to give negative feedback, demote a too-technical manager who should have stayed an IC, or remove a problem employee who isn’t working out.
The anecdote that comes to mind is a local startup that hired a C-level executive’s UI designer friend into their VP of Product role. He was wholly incapable of doing the job but they kept him in the job for 2 years to “give him a chance to grow into it.” Everyone below VP level openly talked about how the VP of Product was incompetent and how to work around him.
The company’s product initiatives ultimately failed to even get started and they had to pivot to entirely services based work. Do not stay at a startup that insists on keeping unqualified people in leadership positions long after everyone in the company has given up on them.
2. Firing the wrong people
The same startup was forced to downsize, largely because their product plans failed to even become defined enough to start under the incompetent VP of Product.
It was the perfect opportunity to fire the VP of Product and his sprawling empire of people who did very little, but they avoided that due to his connections to a C-level executive. Instead, they started cutting engineers. They focused on cutting engineers with the highest compensation out of a misguided effort to cut as few people as possible.
In the process, they lost their key engineers who were holding things together. They sent a message to everyone that incompetence is tolerated if you know the right people. And they lost even more core engineers who quit in the months after those layoffs.
Everyone makes hiring mistakes. It’s how you respond to those hiring mistakes that will seal the fate of the company.
- samhuk 3y agoThanks for your comment. Totally empathize with your experiences there.
- halkony 3y agoRay Dalio talks about this in his book "Principles." The specific advice he offers is "hire slowly, fire quickly."
- bcantrill 3y agoTerrible advice (from a broadly terrible book, I hasten to add). The reason that this is terrible advice: if you "fire quickly", it is because something is either grievously wrong (a mishire) or you are firing based on limited evidence. If the former, you have a hiring problem, not a firing problem; if the latter, you will generate a fear-based culture. Now, if you're running a prison, a fear-based culture may be exactly what you're after -- but fear is anathema to innovation, and if your endeavor requires any creativity whatsoever, you should be seeking to build mutual trust, not foster institutional fear.
- halkony 3y agoCould you expand on your other criticisms of the book? How does it conflict with your experience? I'm still learning.
- bcantrill 3y agoI honestly think the book is so bad that it's not worth a lengthy critique, but in short: 1. Dalio doesn't understand what a "principle" is -- but I can understand that "Aphorisms, Cliches and Hunches" is a less arresting title, if much more accurate. (See [0] for a fuller review on this.) 2. Dalio's version of Bridgewater doesn't line up with the experience of others -- which I have heard from so many people as to completely undermine whatever he might say. Now, in the book's defense: I didn't get through it and perhaps it got suddenly palatable or interesting. However: I also couldn't get through it -- it was just that bad. [0] https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/2233988523 https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/2233988523
- halkony 3y agoI agree that his descriptions are less "principles" and more like "heuristics". The overall message of the book, as the referenced reviewer points out, is "do what's sensible." As someone so young, what is sensible to me is not obvious, so I find value in this. What, in your opinion, defines what is sensible in business and leads to your frustration with Dalio's message? Can you give personal anecdotes?
- setgree 3y agoYep, this very much resonates with my experiences. At the end of the day, startups are run by people, who generally prefer to work with their friends, avoid conflict, etc. There's no great mystery. The mystery is when things work well.