5 ms·
Ourworldindata claims that the 20th century saw the relative wealth of the western powers continuously decline from ~70% of the world economy to ~40% today [0].
by roenxi 3y ago
Ourworldindata claims that the 20th century saw the relative wealth of the western powers continuously decline from ~70% of the world economy to ~40% today [0].
We can't be sure why, it is a very political question. The idea that western powers should control 70% of the world economy is certainly questionable. But something that the west has been doing has killed off growth and put it in a relatively weak position. Corruption of the banking industry away from making good investments and towards supporting government policy objectives is a candidate for contributing to that. It's gotten to the point where as far as I can tell the US has capital controls in place because foreign banks won't take US customers. Not an American so I might just be wrong on that point I suppose.
[0] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/gdp-world-regions-stacked-area?stackMode=relative https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/gdp-world-regions-stacked...
- joshuaissac 3y agoFrom that graph, it seems to just be about other parts of the world catching up, rather than an actual decline in the West. It is clearer after switching the graph from relative to absolute mode.
- ajross 3y agoYeah, that argument was taking data that says essentially "global trade driven by western rule of law regimes lifts all boats" and tries to say "western rule of law is bad because the other boats were lifted". The ideological bent on HN threads really has gotten a little out of control in recent years. We're literally in a topic where the bulk of the posting volume is from the "money laundering is good, actually" camp.
- roenxi 3y agoIf you are ahead and then everyone else catches up, what does that say about your running performance? It says achieving average speed, but recent performance was a bit sedentary. And it isn't KYC/AML laws doing that in isolation because it is too big a trend and too much happens over a century. But "Western capitalism was going gangbusters through the whole period in the 20th century where cash flow tracking was being introduced." - no it wasn't. Western capitalism has been slowly mean-reverting to fall in line with all the authoritarian states and tinpot dictatorships. The economic strategy that the west has been using does not seem to be creating vast amounts of wealth in the west. Most of the wealth is being created in Asia. And big investments take 20-30 years to pay off, so we're probably seeing the results of policies from 1940 through to around 2000 in that chart.
- ipaddr 3y agoIt's free trade which was pushed aggressively and enpowering China
- roenxi 3y agoSure, but when a country with "People's Republic" in the name outperforms the US on economic policy after the US had a jaw-dropping lead coming out of WWII? It is worth getting into the weeds of what the US screwed up. The authoritarian streak in financial markets (of which KYC/AML are a major plank) is probably a significant factor. The US banks aren't running rings around the Chinese financiers with all the paperwork they have to do. Although I'll say again that the whole thing is intensely political and I doubt there is any consensus on what just happened in the last 50 years beyond China is building stuff and the US is not.
- jkaplowitz 3y agoMany foreign banks will take American customers even if many others won’t - both policies are common in Germany for example, and in Canada accepting Americans is routine. Plus, even most foreign banks that won’t accept American customers still routinely transfer money to and from the US, just as most US banks routinely transfer money to and from other countries. Nothing like capital controls.