7 ms·
Microsoft continues right to repair about face, makes its hardware easier to fix
- not_your_vase 3y agoAs long as there are no board schematics provided, things are not reparable. Just certain modules containing 100s-1000s of components can be changed (and thrown directly into the trash).
- greggsy 3y agoIs that where faults really occur though? Could repair shops troubleshoot and repair a bad trace or capacitor on a multi-layer board? I recognise that there is environmental and functional value in repairing a $600 part, but the reality is that it’s not currently economical, even with schematics.
- junon 3y ago> Could repair shops troubleshoot and repair a bad trace or capacitor on a multi-layer board? With schematics, in certain scenarios, absolutely.
- naikrovek 3y agonot for less than the cost of a new board. not at scale. a small shop can do it if they grow slowly. a component-level repair shop run by Microsoft which did not swap parts, but repaired them, can not scale quickly. there just isn't that much talent available to do this, and even when there is, it would be tight, economically. it costs Microsoft less to build a main board than the price they sell it for. the hourly time of the repair person multiplied by the time to diagnose, repair, test, document, and clean a main board would quickly go beyond what a new one costs Microsoft. component-level repair just is not feasible at scale. should they make schematics available anyway? yes.
- Zagitta 3y agoExcept if the environmental cost wasn't externalized it would be unfeasible to not do component level repair at scale. Another aspect to this is that it board repairs could be made significantly easier if companies bothered designing boards with proper test points and expected values documented in a diagnostics manual. Just take a look at how old school oscilloscopes and other test equipment was designed with not only full schematics but well defined diagnosis procedures.
- blackoil 3y agoA repair person near customer in US may have a very large environmental cost.
- tinus_hn 3y agoWhy would you have it repaired by an expensive American when someone in China will do it for next to nothing?
- naikrovek 3y agobecause we should not be relying on employment practices which are effectively slavery, no matter what country it is.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kalleboo 3y agoLouis Rossman ran a profitable repair shop doing precisely that. Lots of minor damage like water damage that kills a computer is just a board-level single fuse or chip replacement. Some specific computer models have weaknesses where you can diagnose it pretty quickly.
- Vogtinator 3y ago"ran"? AFAIK he still does, he just moved from New York to Austin, Texas.
- kalleboo 3y agoThe last time I watched him he was putting himself down about how much his business is failing (=unprofitable) since he started the move, it was probably just modesty but I hedged my wording...
- not_your_vase 3y agoThere are small specialized shops doing that using schematics that fell off the schematics-delivering-truck. Their success rate is not 100%, but enough to make a living. If it could be done officially, even with real support from the originator companies, it could be even better economically. Doing these programs is just hindering the real right-to-repair cause. They pretend that these programs help, but once they get bored of selling these parts 3 years later, nothing changes. Everything becomes e-waste at the exact moment when it was planned in the original powerpoint they created before starting the development of the product. At the same time if you know which capacitor to change, you will be able to do it 50 years later too (with a bit of hand-dexterity) - or you can ask someone else to do it for you. It is not expected that whatever basecomponent will go out of production (with the exception of specialized MCUs). An "xbox controller left trigger sensitivity assembly (rev 6)" on the other hand was never meant to be manufactured longer than the life of a domestic hamster.
- 533474 3y agoIndeed, like those old CRT service manuals....Any new legislation on the matter should promote sharing of schematics or at least a substantial list of troubleshooting tips...reverse engineering modern multi-layer boards is such a pain otherwise...
- bpye 3y agoAfaik framework does provide those, MNT Reform is obviously fully open - any others?
- 666satanhimself 3y ago[dead]
- tmikaeld 3y agoI'm not an English native speaker, but what does that headline even mean? " Microsoft Continues Right to Repair About Face"
- bleachedsleet 3y agoAn “about face” is a term commonly called in military cadence indicating the soldier should turn around, completing a 180 degree turn. So when used colloquially it means someone or some business had a complete change of mind on some topic. In this case, Microsoft has changed their approach to repairability.
- tmikaeld 3y agoAh, you learn something new every day! Thank you
- pessimizer 3y agoEnglish is mostly military metaphors, sports metaphors, and gambling metaphors stuck together.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- greggsy 3y ago‘About face’ is refers to ‘a reversal of attitude, behavior, or point of view’. In this case, they used to be against allowing users to repair their devices (using glue, usually), but they took an about face and are making it easier.
- junon 3y agoI'm a native speaker and I didn't even know what it meant. Don't worry lol.
- tmikaeld 3y ago
- haunter 3y agoWe need this for consoles too!
- kjkjadksj 3y agoThe best way to repair an xbox shouldn’t be with a home oven but here we are
- smileybarry 3y agoThat's the Xbox 360. From 18 years ago.
- prirun 3y agoWhen Microsoft does not have market-share lead, they are pro-customer in that market - hardware in this case. If Microsoft has the leading market-share and doesn't feel threatened, they are anti-customer, ie, Windows. This usually holds for any large corporation. "Elsewhere, Microsoft has been doing a better job ensuring that consumers have access to both service manuals and essential parts needed to independently repair the company’s hardware, ranging from its Surface tablets and laptops to Xbox game controllers." Microsoft's Surface tablets and laptops (I didn't even know they sold laptops!) are a blip compared to Apple. Notably absent are Xbox consoles; they don't have a market-share lead in consoles, although though with their recent acquisition, they might in a few years. So yeah, no console right-to-repair nonsense. Corporations are just like people: they act in their own interest, with the big difference that most people are moral and will consider how their actions might adversely affect others while corporations don't give a shit.
- bobboies 3y agoSomewhere along the line they changed the Xbox UI to sell more widgets. I hate that—let me see all my apps first and foremost, not apps that I don’t want. If I’m in a shopping mood I’ll open the store… and they brought that same pattern to Win11. Stop selling us shit we don’t want please MSFT. Customer first vs corporation first. The truth is, if they don’t see lots of returns on software they force it down customers throat. If that doesn’t generate enough revenue they just kill it on the spot. Microsoft had some great products but it’s hard to want to buy anything from them now because it’ll be EOL in one or two years… feel bad for folks who bought surface duos, to name a more recent one.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y ago> This usually holds for any large corporation. This is the whole concept of market competition being a good thing for customers. Its also the thing that is hugely lacking in most major industry sectors because of decades of mergers and laws making it harder for new entries. As you've pointed out, Microsoft will screw over customers the nanosecond it sees it can get away with it.
- nolok 3y ago> Notably absent are Xbox consoles; they don't have a market-share lead in consoles, although though with their recent acquisition, they might in a few years. It's important to understand that Xbox is almost a non entity in the rest of the world, it's irrelevant in Japan and distant third in Europe (beside UK where it's first/equal with playstation). Xbox 360 carved a bit of a share in the rest of europe but then Xbox One destroyed that in one fell swoop and it never recovered since.
- RandomWorker 3y agoWhen it comes to choosing between a Mac and a PC, many people opt for a Mac because of its superior build quality. However, it's worth noting that Apple products have consistently received low scores from iFixit, indicating that they are difficult to repair. For Microsoft to win, maybe the strategy is to advocate for repairability and encourage Apple to prioritize it in their designs. Thereby taking Apple s focus away from innovation to repairability. iPhone 14 was underwhelming in sooooo many ways, but it's repairability went up! My sense is that the iPhone 15 will lack innovation due to the USB C conversion... and we will see what the iPhone 16 will bring. But legal troubles force Apple's hand, and they can't focus on adding value in other ways.
- rat9988 3y agoThe usb c tangent is kind of weird. It feels like an anti regulation stand for the sake of it.
- TazeTSchnitzel 3y agoIt's not like switching to USB-C will be any great technical feat for Apple. There is already USB-C on the iPad, and the iPhone is just a smaller iPad. It won't even cost anything: they are going to need to reconfigure their production lines anyway for whatever other changes they make in that generation.
- DaiPlusPlus 3y ago> It won't even cost anything: It's costing Apple probably tens of millions of dollars of annual revenue from Lightning cable/connector sales and MFi licensing fees to other vendors. At the same time, Lightning has been getting a bit long-in-the-tooth (USB2.0 speeds are impractical for making local backups of iPhone photo libraries) - as much as I want to believe that Apple would have switched the iPhone over to USB-C within a few years, I realise it's equally possible they'd have introduced a "Lightning 2" or similar. --- There are still rumours out there that the iPhone 15 could be port-less in Europe, and so only charge via Qi - which coincides with Apple actually increasing the physical spec gap between North American vs. East-Asian models of iPhone for example (e.g. no SIM tray in NA vs. but people in SE Asia get physical dual-nano-SIM trays - and still no return of the headphone jack.
- chaostheory 3y agoIt’s not perfect, but I like Microsoft under Nadella’s reign.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zlg_codes 3y agoI really don't trust Microsoft to stay on the correct side of anything. They might play along for now, but how long? Generally, I consider Microsoft software and hardware to be of lesser quality than others. I cannot trust that my ownership of the computer will be respected.
- notatoad 3y agoYeah, calling this an about-face on right-to-repair seems wildly optimistic. Making some products that are repairable is really not the same thing as supporting your right to repair any product you own.
- temac 3y agoIf we are talking about Microsoft as a whole, then there is no “about face” unless they change their mind implied by their planned obsolescence decision about Windows 11 not even running on Zen 1 or Skylake for no real reason.
- nomadspiritweb 3y agoWhen will they let us unlock our Surface RT bootloaders?
- gigel82 3y agoDon't know, I have a Surface Laptop 4 with a cracked screen and it's cheaper to buy the whole laptop on eBay than it is to buy the replacement screen from Microsoft Store.