4 ms·
>Bioy Casares then supposedly took advantage of the moment to ask Kodama if he could photograph her, since she had “an ideal face.” The phrase was coarse, an ob
by coldtea 3y ago
>Bioy Casares then supposedly took advantage of the moment to ask Kodama if he could photograph her, since she had “an ideal face.” The phrase was coarse, an objectification
Asking to photograph her with a compliment is an "objectification"? Who even talks and thinks like that, much less put it to print.
- saagarjha 3y agoWho says that? I understand a pretty face, or an attractive face, but an "ideal" face? That's pretty weird. It's like a goal that can be optimized.
- layer8 3y agoThere may be something lost in translation.
- oh_sigh 3y agoIronically, ideal is the same in English as it is in Spanish. And German for that matter. And Turkish. Seems like the ideal word for the concept.
- layer8 3y agoThe space of meaning and the usage patterns of words are almost never 100% the same between languages. This can have the effect of a choice of word being somewhat less appropriate in one language than the other, even when the words nominally mean the same thing. In addition, there may be Spanish words other than “ideal” that nevertheless can be translated as “ideal” in English for one of their meanings, but that translation wasn’t the best in this particular case. Of course I don’t know if that’s what happened here, but it’s a possibility.
- coldtea 3y agoIdeal as in (one of the dictionary lemmas) "satisfying one's conception of what is perfect". Basically a more elegant stand-in for perfect. As artist-speak goes, for people familiar with the arts and aesthetic lingo before post-modern art, it's a very common expression, whether in Spanish, English, French, etc.
- atlantic 3y agoNo, "ideal" doesn't refer to optimization, because it's not a scientific term. The context is Platonic forms - something is ideal if it approaches its archetypal model. This is particularly applicable to beauty.
- junek 3y agoYes, it is in fact creepy, weird, and objectifying. Men's sense of entitlement to give "compliments" does not supercede women's right to not get creepy, weird, objectifying comments from creepy weird men.
- appplication 3y agoI’m not going to argue that it’s not perceived as creepy, because I can see that. But your second point is a little off the mark with how you phrased it. No one has a right to not be spoken to. I ride the bus to work. There’s a very large, imposing, but otherwise friendly fellow I frequently run into. He like to strike up a conversation with/at me every time he sees me. He actually will talk to anyone who is near him. It’s annoying and unwanted, but it’s not violating any fundamental rights. I understand where you’re coming from, but no one knows you don’t want to be spoken to until you inform them. And you certainly have a right to do that. It’s just a bit of a slippery slope wrt free speech to imply that someone’s speech infringes on a perceived right to not hear it.
- junek 3y agoIt's not a matter of not wanting to be spoken to in general, but specifically not wanting creepy, objectifying comments.
- coldtea 3y agoOf the kind that say "you have an ideal face"? No wonder there's a loneliness epidemic if people have labelling anything and everything as creepy.
- junek 3y agoYes, that comment _is_ creepy and objectifying (regarding a woman as an ideal object rather than as a person). If men want to be less lonely then they need to work on treating women as fellow human beings and not acting so entitled.
- 3y ago