5 ms·
This is a fairly content-less piece. As near as he comes to naming a specific problem or proposing a specific solution is this quote: > Robert Reich, for examp
by twoodfin 15y ago
This is a fairly content-less piece. As near as he comes to naming a specific problem or proposing a specific solution is this quote:
> Robert Reich, for example, has long argued that "professional companies should not be permitted to become publicly held corporations." As he puts it, "Such a step puts them into high-stakes competition for investors, pushing them to maximize profits over their responsibilities to the public."
And even that's pretty hand-wavy. What makes a "professional company" and why would such a thing have a "responsibility to the public" above and beyond any other company?
Goldman may be a bogeyman to a lot of folks, but at least they had the sense to get out of the crazy CDO world as fast as they could. If you're going to spend pages explaining how "toxic" the environment is there, some specific, verifiable examples would be nice. Neither Smith nor Lessig provide any. Goldman's clients aren't morons, and if they thought they could do better elsewhere, they were and are free to stop doing business with GS. Until you can really nail Goldman with black and white evidence of fraud, it's hard to take these generalized allegations seriously.
- JoelSutherland 15y agoAssuming this comment is a response to what the article said, your reasoning is circular. Lessig blames both the change in laws/regulations and Goldman going public for the issues. We can't nail Goldman with fraud under the existing laws. That's his point: laws and regulations should be reverted/changed to criminalize some of their current behavior. Professional Companies are companies that provide professional services. These are companies that are hired because they are licensed to do something. They need to be licensed because their field is sufficiently complex or opaque that their clients cannot evaluate their competence or trustworthiness. He suggests these company should not be able to go public because this class of companies cannot be fairly evaluated by the market without creating perverse incentives.
- twoodfin 15y agoI'm sorry, Lessig didn't name a single repealed regulation in his piece, nor how maintaining such a regulation would have concretely affected some action that Goldman took. As I said, it's hand-waving.
- Hubbert 15y agoAside from the rule against incorporating, the Glass-Steagall Act was very helpful in preventing the Too Big To Fail bailouts for many decades. While the author may have omitted some specifics (in part due to column length), to those who follow the industry even casually, it's hard not to consider the changes self-evident, like a statement "CPUs are more powerful today than in 1990". Even if the regulations were unchanged, top levels of government are almost 100% Goldman alumni and/or future Goldman people, so enforcement is comical. Imagine if Ford and GM executives had been running the EPA for the last 20 years.
- anamax 15y ago> These are companies that are hired because they are licensed to do something. What fraction of GS biz actually involves licensed activities? Yes, stock brokers are licensed, but bankers aren't. Most types of financial advisors aren't licensed. Are any traders licensed?
- hncommenter13 15y agoThis is not quite correct. Senior bankers (and certainly senior institutional salespeople, of which Greg Smith was one) are typically required by their firms to be licensed by FINRA. Certainly not all investment bankers or traders are required to be licensed (and I don't think they should be), but a significant fraction are. Also, fwiw, mortgage brokers and lawyers are required to be licensed in almost every state. Licensing--or lack thereof--has little to do with ethical behavior.
- Drbble 15y agoLicensing almost always includes a legal commitment to specific ethical behaviors, fiduciary duty and the like. That is one of the main differences between licensed professionals and flea market vendors. Doctors, lawyers, and engineers all make specific ethical commitments in order to win authorization to practice.
- hncommenter13 15y agoThat's true, almost every license for any profession (including everything from accountants to sports agents to, in some states, interior decorators and hair braiders) has an ethics component. My point is that it's trivial to find examples of unethical behavior by folks with licenses, so clearly the license alone isn't sufficient. Many bankers are already licensed, and licensing won't change the behavior of the ones inclined to take huge risks. Maybe it helps at the margin, but it's not a cure all by any means.
- toufka 15y agoI believe you are missing the point. It is not about who provides a better service, or fraud. It is about long-term stability. Goldman has made extraordinary profits. And done well for their customers. But it is becoming increasingly clear that the outlook is becoming more and more myopic. Profit ≠ Profit, if one is short-term and one is long-term. They are different beasts. Goldman used to be the king of kings with respect to earning long-term profit. Mr. Smith points out that long-term profit has been sidelined for short-term profit. Both are still profit - but one has a sustainable culture, one does not. This is a more nuanced issue than 'good company', 'bad company' - the qualification, 'in the moral way' becomes necessary.
- 286c8cb04bda 15y ago> And even that's pretty hand-wavy. What makes a "professional company" and why would such a thing have a "responsibility to the public" above and beyond any other company? I suspect he's using the word "professional" here in the more traditional form. He's roughly referring to careers like doctor, lawyer, banker, where there is usually formal licensing based on public interest. That's e.g. why there is a lot more paperwork to file when you start a hospital or a bank than a widget shop.
- huherto 15y agoI may be wrong but I interpreted a "professional company" as a "professional services company" Companies where the main value offered is the services of the partners of the firm. As far as I knew, these companies were not public because they reserve stock for the professionals working in the firm.
- m0th87 15y ago"The Big Short" provides a great deal of context to the behavior of financial services firms, and Lessig's arguments seem to completely align. The problem with financial services companies being public is that the investors aren't leveraging their own money when they make risky bets. If a bet goes sour, the stockholders are ultimately responsible for absorbing the loss. Goldman and its ilk are scrutinized for good reason. It's strange that you should compliment them for exiting the CDO market. Shouldn't they instead be condemned for entering it in the first place? What about the SEC investigation into Goldman knowingly selling junk securities to customers [1]? The fact that they were only fined $550m suggests that - as Lessig argues - we are under-regulated. This shouldn't be allowed to happen in the first place. 1: http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2010/2010-123.htm http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2010/2010-123.htm
- Drbble 15y agoThe problem you describe infects all public corporations, not just in the finance industry. It is why management of big public companies tend to pillage, not produce.
- ScottBurson 15y agoA professional corporation is a specific type of corporation. Legal regulations applying to professional corporations typically differ in important ways from those applying to other corporations. Professional corporations [...] do not usually afford [...] the same degree of limitation of liability as ordinary business corporations. For more info: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_corporation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_corporation