3 ms·

> I have a couple Google accounts that are just pulling email to a separate mailbox and who knows if that's active or not. Probably not. I think the point is t

> I have a couple Google accounts that are just pulling email to a separate mailbox and who knows if that's active or not. Probably not. I think the point is to ensure there's human interaction. Don't expect any automated activity to affect the timer.

mcny 3y ago
I didn't realize that. So if I have Mozilla Thunderbird running on a computer fetching emails from an account, it isn't good enough? > Reading or sending an email I would need to actually mark incoming emails as read?
- dataflow 3y ago
  I mean, this is just my guess; I could be wrong. But the vibe I get is that you basically have to do something non-trivial via the web (log in, create something, delete something, whatever) to show that a human is paying attention to the account and not just an automated system. Don't rely on automated means like IMAP, regardless of what actions you're performing with those.
  - zarzavat 3y ago
    I assume it’s tied to logging in or using the account while logged in. Email is a separate system, it’s possible they linked up the email system to the accounts system, but the easiest way to implement this would just be to update a timestamp every time someone logs in or makes an authenticated browser request.
    - mcny 3y ago
      Welp, back to Firefox containers it is then. For those who don't know, you can have multiple Google sessions in different Firefox containers in a single Firefox profile/window. This is an official Firefox adding as far as I know. It works with Firefox sync for me (not enabled by default). https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account-containers/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account...
    - dataflow 3y ago
      > but the easiest way to implement this would just be to update a timestamp every time someone logs in You don't have to speculate here. They clearly say "Activity might include these actions you take when you sign in or while you’re signed: Reading or sending an email, Using Google Search, etc." So it's not just "did they log in".
zuccs 3y ago
> Probably not. 100% not. I have a bunch of Google Accounts (not even with a Gmail inbox attached) that just forward on email alerts from Google Ads, etc. And have been getting these update emails since July 14th.

mcny 3y ago

I didn't realize that. So if I have Mozilla Thunderbird running on a computer fetching emails from an account, it isn't good enough? > Reading or sending an email I would need to actually mark incoming emails as read?

dataflow 3y ago
I mean, this is just my guess; I could be wrong. But the vibe I get is that you basically have to do something non-trivial via the web (log in, create something, delete something, whatever) to show that a human is paying attention to the account and not just an automated system. Don't rely on automated means like IMAP, regardless of what actions you're performing with those.
- zarzavat 3y ago
  I assume it’s tied to logging in or using the account while logged in. Email is a separate system, it’s possible they linked up the email system to the accounts system, but the easiest way to implement this would just be to update a timestamp every time someone logs in or makes an authenticated browser request.
  - mcny 3y ago
    Welp, back to Firefox containers it is then. For those who don't know, you can have multiple Google sessions in different Firefox containers in a single Firefox profile/window. This is an official Firefox adding as far as I know. It works with Firefox sync for me (not enabled by default). https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account-containers/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account...
  - dataflow 3y ago
    > but the easiest way to implement this would just be to update a timestamp every time someone logs in You don't have to speculate here. They clearly say "Activity might include these actions you take when you sign in or while you’re signed: Reading or sending an email, Using Google Search, etc." So it's not just "did they log in".

zuccs 3y ago

> Probably not. 100% not. I have a bunch of Google Accounts (not even with a Gmail inbox attached) that just forward on email alerts from Google Ads, etc. And have been getting these update emails since July 14th.