5 ms·
I don't want to be some sort of Kevin Rose defender in this thread, but I don't think it's fair to say that he just "had an idea". He had an idea and spent year
by untog 15y ago
I don't want to be some sort of Kevin Rose defender in this thread, but I don't think it's fair to say that he just "had an idea". He had an idea and spent years working on it, iterating and improving until Digg finally hit the big time. I think he deserves credit for that.
As a developer, I agree that some "ideas guys" suck. But some of them are fantastic, and have a huge talent in taking a core concept and fleshing out requirements, objectives and so on. Often we developers are actually really bad at that, and we end up getting distracted by endless refactoring, or bringing down response times, etc. etc.
There is nothing wrong with a mix of the two.
- samstave 15y ago>He had an idea and spent years working on it, iterating and improving until Digg finally hit the big time. I think he deserves credit for that. I don't think anyone has argued against this. He does deserve credit for this. The problem is that he has been given too much credit. I.E. that there were far more ideas of the same caliber. I am sure this must have been tough on him, to fail at producing again like the early digg iteration. I see the evolution of the social content site to be: Slashdot --> Digg --> Reddit. Each a stepping stone for the next. And I do not think this is about THE CONTENT -- I think this is about the UX you provide the users, and the control over that UX you leave to the users. Digg evolved /.'s model. Reddit evolved Digg's. Reddit has provided a UX which allows for a VERY fluid and quick experience with the content, given FULL control to the users on what content they see, how it is categorized, modded etc. Kevin took money from ivestors for his own little think tank - that money was largely given to him by charismatic reputation alone. Now, after a very short period, he isn't even pivoting, or "shooting this idea in the head to work on others" -- he is abandoning the whole freaking endeavor and taking (unknown) position in struggling social company, Google. This doesn't leave a good taste in anyone's mouth (Sour Milk? (Sorry)) because being given $1.7MM which he gets to walk away from is a slap in the face to the people who work their asses off on good ideas and don't get any of the valley coddling as Kevin.
- PhrosTT 15y agoMy main problem with Digg is it blew up largely because Rose got to shamelessly plug it on ScreenSavers. A LOT of ideas can succeed when you get to skip the whole network effect hurdle. I think he has some insightful thoughts once in a while (like predictions he makes on Diggnation), and he did a great job parlaying Digg into Rev3. I'm also pretty jealous he'll get a paycheck to say "Hey this feature would be cool" or use his celebrity to push Google+.
- temphn 15y agoBut he got to plug it on ScreenSavers because he worked his way up from being the IT guy on the show to cameo appearances onscreen to actually having his own show. Major props on the hustle there.
- alaskamiller 15y agoThis is the wrong storyline. Reddit didn't evolve from Digg. They started around the same timeframe and it was as much Mac/PC in terms of fanboyishness. Reddit won because of the power of subreddits and capturing the long tail for content and communities. What's out of touch with your story is that Digg users thought Reddit's UX was horrifying and avoided it like the plague. Even to this day without enhancement suites I wouldn't crown Reddit to be the pinnacle of UX. It's very much Linux terminally compared to Digg's Mac. Finally, this jaded bitterness that Kevin Rose got $1.7MM to piss away... If you were worth getting $1.7MM to piss away you would have had $1.7MM to piss away.
- rythie 15y agoAnd Digg 4.0 was a more complicated attempt to solve the long tail problem, by creating personalized sub-reddits essentially.
- samstave 15y agoI was not trying to imply reddit evolved FROM digg. (I have been using all three sites since their inception - starting with /. in 1997, I am familiar with their history). I am saying the IDEA of social content sites evolved from one, to the next, to the next. As I mentioned, it is not about UI, or content, it was about UX! The UX that digg had, especially in V4 wrapped too much UI around the content resulting in a poor UX! Reddit, while seemingly ugly - allowed for far faster and more fluid consumption of the content. It also left more control over what content users wanted. >It's very much Linux terminally compared to Digg's Mac I think you're putting too much weight on the shiny. I think anyone would agree that the speed and agility one gets on a CLI (linux) vs any GUI when you're a savvy user is incomparable. Finally, I am not jaded/bitter because Kevin Rose got 1.7MM -- I am jaded bitter that anyone would get 1.7MM and so nonchalantly walk away from it AFTER making the types of comments he did. I think I just have a different perspective than you, I also think you believe I am focusing on things which I am not. :)
- joering2 15y ago> If you were worth getting $1.7MM to piss away you would have had $1.7MM to piss away. So you are implying that a luck and contacts and more other things such as your experience, geolocation, etc. don't matter as long as you are worth getting $X, you will have $X to piss away. uhm, is there any website to sign up? I want to try my skills against it -- perhaps I am "worth it".
- mikeryan 15y agoHe had an idea and spent years working on it, iterating and improving until Digg finally hit the big time Um he had an idea, paid someone to build it (ojbyrne on HN). Promoted it on air in his role at TechTV and had it take off. Its not like he toiled in his basement for years slaving over it. (Though he did seem to spend a lot of time on it once it became his day job, I don't want to discredit that) You can also say that the Digg 4.0 was his "idea" and its what effectively buried Digg and started the mass exodus to Reddit (which is now very true to the original digg).
- untog 15y agoUm he had an idea, paid someone to build it (ojbyrne on HN). Promoted it on air in his role at TechTV and had it take off. Right, so he made it a success. I just find it disheartening sometimes that developers (and I am one) seem to think that good code is all that matters. It isn't. You can have the most functional, highly-tuned web site in the world and have no-one use it. Even if Kevin Rose is nothing but a giant hype machine then he deserves credit for being a giant hype machine. Digg would have failed if he wasn't.
- anon808 15y agoKnowing that Digg succeeded because a 'giant hype machine' isn't the same as knowing that it would have failed without it.
- beatle 15y agodevelopers are a dime a dozen. I can hire ten people from India or China who are better than you (xpose2000). most developers hate successful people who don't have technical skills (Steve Jobs, MBAs, managers, non-technical founders, etc.) because they make the developers look a lot less important.
- functionform 15y agoMaybe you've never heard the famous expression "Ideas are like *, everybody's got one".
- surgeterrix 15y agoHe also wrote some of the code for the first iterations of Digg himself, so its not like he didn't do any coding originally. He just passed in on to more skilled people once the requirements were out of his league.