5 ms·
If you compare it with 19th century polar expeditions, a trip to Mars doesn't look that bad. They sometimes took multiple years, with men trapped in iced up shi
by arethuza 15y ago
If you compare it with 19th century polar expeditions, a trip to Mars doesn't look that bad. They sometimes took multiple years, with men trapped in iced up ships, usually with no chance of rescue or even communication - at least we know how to prevent scurvy now!
Have a read of the book "Barrow's Boys: A Stirring Story of Daring, Fortitude, and Outright Lunacy":
http://www.amazon.com/Barrows-Boys-Stirring-Fortitude-Outright/dp/B006J45Q4G http://www.amazon.com/Barrows-Boys-Stirring-Fortitude-Outrig...
NB Having read too much Kim Stanley Robinson and Zubrin, I'd jump at the chance to go to Mars.
- rbanffy 15y agoAn expedition to Mars would cost a lot more, with a much smaller expected ROI. I too would love the idea of going to Mars, but, in order to build a sustainable colony, you'd need to put in place a whole lot of infrastructure to make interplanetary travel cheaper. And, right now, it's not even feasible.
- ramidarigaz 15y agoInsurance for humanity against disaster is a small ROI? Not trying to offend, but how do you define ROI of a colony on Mars?
- bdunbar 15y ago...is a small ROI? You, me, and the original poster agree: it's cheap compared to the potential downside. Now, go try and tell guys with actual money about this, see if you walk away with the bucks for a Mars-based insurance policy.
- chc 15y agoAs far as I can see, there are very, very few disasters that would render Earth less inhabitable than Mars but not also destroy Mars in the process. Even if Earth were reduced to a cold, lifeless rock with almost no atmosphere or water, high radiation levels and almost all sources of energy gone (including geothermal and wind energy and things as simple as burning wood), that would just put it in the same ballpark as Mars. Basically, if you have the technology to support human life on Mars, you have the technology to disaster-proof Earth.
- didgeoridoo 15y agoThe scenario that comes to mind is a massive asteroid impact, but your final sentence sums up the objection nicely: identifying and redirecting a space rock seems at least an order of magnitude less difficult & technologically distant than building a self-sustaining colony on Mars.
- ars 15y agoEven the worst asteroid impact would not render the planet uninhabitable. It might kill lots of people, but it wouldn't kill all of them.
- rbanffy 15y agoAnd yet, again, a Moon colony would be handy to counter an asteroid too. The far side could host very powerful telescopes that could map NEOs with unprecedented efficiency and clarity. On Earth, you have a couple hours of sensor exposure. On the Moon, you have two weeks to trace stuff. And most of the heavy parts could be manufactured in situ, be lighter and higher quality (made in a high grade vacuum). And that's to say nothing about the ability to launch spacecraft from a lower gravity and/or using a magnetic rail. One could even turn the asteroid into dust (which is less dangerous than a ferrous mountain falling from the sky) with a kinetic impactor packing enough energy.
- ramidarigaz 15y agoWhat about virulent plague? Chemical warfare? Disasters don't have to come from far away.
- chc 15y agoIf you're going to survive on Mars, you already need the ability to sustainably disconnect yourself from the surrounding atmosphere (we don't know of any virus that's as lethal as lack of air), so just apply your putative Mars tech to Earth.
- 15y ago
- rbanffy 15y agoThe odds of extinction within the next 50 years are still low. A self-sufficient Moon colony would cover most of the disaster scenarios adequately while being a lot cheaper to build than a Mars colony. Besides, having a self-sufficient lunar colony would probably make building a Mars colony much cheaper. On the Moon, solar energy is abundant (close to the Sun, no atmosphere) and so are the metals used in spacecraft construction. Without atmosphere and with a low gravity, launching cargo to Mars is easier and can be done with a magnetic rail launcher, effectively using solar power to launch a spacecraft to Mars. I's even greener to go for the Moon first ;-)
- mindslight 15y agoSo, I'm not that guy, and really trying not to be that guy, but wouldn't it be fair to summarize your general point as: "That's no moon. It's a space station." ? (mainly mentioning it because it could be taken for an inspirational saying in this context)
- rbanffy 15y ago> Insurance for humanity against disaster is a small ROI? A self-sufficient colony on the Moon would be efficient insurance against most disasters I can imagine and much easier to build. A colony on Mars offers negligible benefit over one on the Moon for the purpose you mention.
- greeneggs 15y agoFurthermore, as technology and quality of life increases, risk tolerance decreases. I think this trend will continue. Historically, technology has increased fast and uniformly enough that we've still been able to do great things. But if health care technology improves much faster than space technology, then we may never leave orbit again. (This trend holds at least at the societal level, and over long terms. For individuals over the short term, it can be weaker, e.g., you might buy a helmet or a safer car, and then ski or drive more dangerously.)