3 ms·
> Can you imagine the outrage if Trumps' AG was appointing special prosecutors to oversee criminal cases of his children? No, because I think Trump’s political
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Can you imagine the outrage if Trumps' AG was appointing special prosecutors to oversee criminal cases of his children?
No, because I think Trump’s political opponents understand that legally:
(1) that's who, under the law, appoints Special Counsel, and
(2) the appointment of Special Counsel is the legal mechanism for minimizing political influence in a particular sensitive criminal investigation, so its good when that happens.
And we don't have to speculate much, because the DOJ under Trump did appoint Special Counsel, and I remember mostly positive outcry from Trump's opponents and negative outcry from his supporters when Trump's (acting) AG appointed Special Counsel to investigate Trump himself. (There was negative outcry at the later political interference with the Special Counsel’s report by Trump’s later AG, but that’s a different issue.)
The “well, if the roles were reversed” counterfactual style of argument is usually a dumb way of the speaker just injecting unsubstantiated speculation to do whataboutism without facts, but its at its worst when the proposed counterfactual or something very close to it actually happened, and the treatment was exactly the opposite than what the argument presupposes.