3 ms·
> Gerrymandering can make it easier to flip a district. Only if you do a bad job of it. > Gerrymandering means a small number of districts with a large advant
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Gerrymandering can make it easier to flip a district.
Only if you do a bad job of it.
> Gerrymandering means a small number of districts with a large advantage for party A and a large number of districts with a small advantage for party B.
No, it doesn't.
Suppose you had a 5-district, 50-50 population state, with the population distributed homogenously enough that without weird district lines you would get 5 competitive, near 50-50 seats. An effective partisan gerrymander might make one 70-30 seat for the disfavored party and four 55-45 seats for the favored party, every seat being less competitive than without a gerrymander.
- bryanlarsen 3y ago> with the population distributed homogenously enough that without weird district lines you would get 5 competitive, near 50-50 seats. Sure, if you assume something that never happens, then I would be wrong. In practice all states have D cities and R rural areas. To increase the number of R districts they create a bunch of districts that are mostly rural along with enough of the cities that instead of a small number of solidly R rural districts they have a larger number of mixed districts that lean R. (And D's do the inverse).