3 ms·
Gerrymandering can make it easier to flip a district. Gerrymandering means a small number of districts with a large advantage for party A and a large number o
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
Gerrymandering can make it easier to flip a district. Gerrymandering means a small number of districts with a large advantage for party A and a large number of districts with a small advantage for party B. So in a normal election party B gets more districts than they should. However, if sentiment swings enough to overcome the "small advantage" then party A can sweep the state. And if sentiment swings significantly towards party B they now no longer have the ability to steal a seat from party A.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Gerrymandering can make it easier to flip a district. Only if you do a bad job of it. > Gerrymandering means a small number of districts with a large advantage for party A and a large number of districts with a small advantage for party B. No, it doesn't. Suppose you had a 5-district, 50-50 population state, with the population distributed homogenously enough that without weird district lines you would get 5 competitive, near 50-50 seats. An effective partisan gerrymander might make one 70-30 seat for the disfavored party and four 55-45 seats for the favored party, every seat being less competitive than without a gerrymander.
- bryanlarsen 3y ago> with the population distributed homogenously enough that without weird district lines you would get 5 competitive, near 50-50 seats. Sure, if you assume something that never happens, then I would be wrong. In practice all states have D cities and R rural areas. To increase the number of R districts they create a bunch of districts that are mostly rural along with enough of the cities that instead of a small number of solidly R rural districts they have a larger number of mixed districts that lean R. (And D's do the inverse).
- LexiMax 3y agoGerrymandering is just one mechanism to rig elections. Voting laws can be changed to disproportionately affect certain demographics, and districts can even be targeted with special unnecessary "oversight." This is happening all across the country, and it reeks of a political and ruling class who is unwilling to cede power to fresh faces.