5 ms·
There won't be a "doom loop", just a market correction to relatively normal levels. Free market at work - everyone speculating on real estate professionally kno
by mschuster91 3y ago
There won't be a "doom loop", just a market correction to relatively normal levels. Free market at work - everyone speculating on real estate professionally knows the risk (or should have known after the 2008ff subprime crisis). Bailing out morons should not be a thing - if no one suffers this time, it's just an invitation for an even worse bubble. The problem is that instead of eating their loss like they fucking should, it seems like the uber rich are funding endless "return to office" campaigns in media, and once again try to let the 99% suffer from worse employment conditions and onerous commutes to the office instead.
The only people I actually feel sorry for are regular homeowners who bought way overpriced properties because they had no alternative.
- echelon 3y ago> The only people I actually feel sorry for are regular homeowners who bought way overpriced properties because they had no alternative. Many markets in other states are still going up. The condos in my building are selling for $100 - $150k more than they did in 2022. Lower inventory and volume, but the demand is red hot.
- idopmstuff 3y ago> There won't be a "doom loop", just a market correction to relatively normal levels. Free market at work - everyone speculating on real estate professionally knows the risk (or should have known after the 2008ff subprime crisis). Bailing out morons should not be a thing - if no one suffers this time, it's just an invitation for an even worse bubble. The difference is the doom loop leads to things going below "normal" levels (and "normal" is not really a useful term here). Also, I don't think it's fair to say elevated office building prices in SF were the result of wild speculation - it was one of the most booming employment markets in the US with an incredible dearth of supply. High prices are just economic principles at work. Then something totally unexpected came and upended how we work, and that changed the market entirely - it was an external force, not people paying prices that weren't supported by the rents.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Then something totally unexpected came and upended how we work, and that changed the market entirely - it was an external force, not people paying prices that weren't supported by the rents. The thing is, if one is investing money, one should also take into account risk. Remote work has been a thing for years now, with ever faster adoption of broadband Internet. But it seems like a lot of people have either put way too much money into one single asset class or preferred to distribute money to shareholders instead of building some buffer for when tides start to turn. Either of these mistakes is completely avoidable and part of virtually any economics class, it's not rocket science - it's just plain old greed all around.
- idopmstuff 3y ago> The thing is, if one is investing money, one should also take into account risk. This is true, but I think the idea that people should have priced in a black swan like a pandemic (and not only a pandemic, but a pandemic that changes the way we work) is not a reasonable one. > Remote work has been a thing for years now, with ever faster adoption of broadband Internet. This makes exactly the opposite point that you intend - despite the fact that people, especially those in tech, have had the infrastructure to work remotely for many years, SF's market still continued to go up in value and have incredibly high occupancy rates. If the condition existed for remote work for years and yet it had no appreciable impact on the use of office space, it wouldn't make any sense to assume that there will be a sudden change to cause everyone to work remotely and the market for office space to crash.
- mschuster91 3y ago> This is true, but I think the idea that people should have priced in a black swan like a pandemic (and not only a pandemic, but a pandemic that changes the way we work) is not a reasonable one. The world has become ever more chaotic the last years. Natural disasters, general political instability, even geopolitical instability has been on the table for a long LONG time now. Acting like a "black swan" event is unthinkable has been beyond foolish.
- readthenotes1 3y ago"The only people I actually feel sorry for are regular homeowners who bought way overpriced properties because they had no alternative. " No alternative? Highly doubtful. More like they were just the "greater fool". I can feel sorry for them in that because someday I may be in their shoes. But they did have alternatives.
- paraboli 3y agoThe worry about the doom loop is not that rich people lose money but that the current budget is tied to high tax receipts and when assessments go down tax revenue will plunge. Services will have to be cut to balance the budget.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Services will have to be cut to balance the budget. No. The US could also go and fix their tax code for once - start taxing the uber rich. Warren f..ing Buffet complained years ago he has to pay less tax than his secretary. A lot of the issues that cripple many Western countries relate to stupid tax breaks for the rich and mega corporations who have bought out politics.
- anonuser123456 3y agoNot everyone believes taking Bill Gates’ money and sending it to random drug addicts in SF is very good policy.
- ipaddr 3y agoBad example as his foundations probably does this through outreach programs
- Tyrek 3y agoFoundations that are probably better run than local government.
- mschuster91 3y agoWhich is true but extremely problematic in itself. The poor and destitute should not depend on the graces of billionaires (or, worse, churches) for their basic needs, society should take care of them.
- GenerWork 3y ago
- Manuel_D 3y agoThe apartment I used to rent for $3,600 is now renting for $3,300 on Craigslist. I don't think the massive collapse of office building rents will be reflected in residential real estate. People still want to live in SF, it's companies that have realized that an office is a waste of money. Or maybe just rent an office with a few conference rooms to host meetings with business partners, let the bulk of your workforce WFH.
- mistrial9 3y ago> regular homeowners for years there have been fewer and fewer of those "regular homeowners" and increase in offshore money speculation, purchase-to-AirBNB, and other non-obvious transactions. A recent examination of US Tax filings (posted on YNews IIR) show that +1 million adults in the USA have the financial ability to purchase a home, and have not done so.
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> A recent examination of US Tax filings (posted on YNews IIR) show that +1 million adults in the USA have the financial ability to purchase a home, and have not done so. That doesn't seem like a good measure. There are a lot of people with means who would rather rent a space downtown that own a SFH in the suburbs. Those people would/should not be considered "regular homeowners".
- ren_engineer 3y agoif remote work stays SF will be in a similar situation to Detroit, although they will be somewhat better off just due to the climate and location of SF making it a desirable place to live. But SF will still lose a ton of tax revenue if fewer tech workers are living in the area