3 ms·
This is why they're having to make these moves. How much value have they given you vs how much have you paid? If the gap is too large, they have to start lockin
by robertlagrant 3y ago
This is why they're having to make these moves. How much value have they given you vs how much have you paid? If the gap is too large, they have to start locking some things down.
- linuxftw 3y agoDo you think Google should lock down the go language and compiler, considering how much value they've given Terraform and likely how little Terraform has paid for go itself?
- alephnerd 3y agoAlphabet doesn't generate revenue from Go. Following your example, Alphabet should open source all the weights they use in their current search algorithm as well as the algorithm itself. And extending that principle, they should also open source the machine translation model and weights Robert DeNero made for them when at Google Translate. Both of these are dumb hypotheticals but serve to point out the fact that there are loss leaders and revenue generators at each company.
- linuxftw 3y agoNo. My point was, companies should make money from services, not software. I believe all software should have a FOSS license.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yellowapple 3y ago> Alphabet doesn't generate revenue from Go. Hashicorp doesn't generate revenue from Terraform. (They do generate revenue from Terraform Cloud, but that's a backend for Terraform, not Terraform itself)
- systemBuilder 3y agoTrue, just like Qualcomm bought Eudora (mac) email for fame, Google started the Go project to keep Rob Pike (of UNIX fame) happy and to help their own internal SRE teams. The public "good will" and benefits to Google SRE have more than paid for their efforts to create the Go language, plus also there is some publicity and fame for Google having most of the remaining early UNIX guys on staff ...
- pjmlp 3y agoMy employer pays for Visual Studio, JetBrains, Mac tax + dev license pays for XCode, Oracle, SQL Server,... I guess it is up to Google to decide how to monetize Go, or who knows, maybe some day they will put it into a foundation of sorts that should find a way to keep sponsoring its development.
- jen20 3y agoTerraform would have avoided years of stringly typed mess had it not been written in Go. I’d estimate that half the provider bugs I saw were either because of a lack of generics (and correct unwillingness to generate code), or because of casting empty interfaces. The only advantage was static binaries, which not many other languages in a usable state supported at the time. It’s not even like there was an ecosystem at the time - HC had to maintain an AWS client for Go for several years, and similarly for Azure.
- alephnerd 3y agoExactly this. Open Source software quickly becomes a tragedy of the commons because most organizations are unscrupulous. Look at how AWS destroyed the entire Elastic, MongoDB, PostgreSQL, Kafka, etc ecosystems by abusing overly permissive licenses.
- koolba 3y agoSince when is abiding by the license abuse? Oh you mean the unwritten, unenforceable, undefined, romanticized spirit of the license?
- alephnerd 3y agoYou ain't wrong! It's a major reason why I'd never release a core revenue generating feature of mine under a permissive Open Source License. Unsrupulous implies some form of an ethical code, whereby you are judged by intent, not by action - which is an idealized view of the world but an unrealistic one at that.
- robertlagrant 3y agoThey're not unscrupulous. They're using the software as it is licenced, which is the software's declaration of how it is allowed to be used. The problem lies with OSS, not with people using it.
- yellowapple 3y agoThe problem lies with people expecting to apply non-FOSS monetization strategies to FOSS.
- SAI_Peregrinus 3y agoParticularly with corporate charity (aka "permissive") licenses. If you want the source to stay open for users further down the chain, use a license that requires that.
- znpy 3y agoOne should wonder why companies love "open source" software so much and despise "free software" even more. On the matter, Grafana has relicensed most of its software to AGPLv3 (eg: https://github.com/grafana/grafana/blob/main/LICENSE https://github.com/grafana/grafana/blob/main/LICENSE)