6 ms·
I know most HN commentators are thinking about Terraform, but I think this change was done with Consul and Vault in mind. Plenty of companies (including my emp
by alephnerd 3y ago
I know most HN commentators are thinking about Terraform, but I think this change was done with Consul and Vault in mind.
Plenty of companies (including my employer) have been building fully monetized software using Consul and Vault under the hood and not paying them a dime. We're a company that's valued/market capped in the Billions btw and I know plenty of other large software companies doing the same thing.
- proxysna 3y agoYes, people underestimate how important consul and vault are in modern infra. There is no direct replacement for vault or consul in how versatile and powerful these tools are.
- linuxftw 3y agoI definitely underestimate them because in my last 7 roles I haven't used either. I don't know how far back 'modern' goes, but 3 roles were over the last 24 months (just started a new role) and none of those roles the companies used consul or vault to manage anything.
- alephnerd 3y agoIf you've ever done a credit card transaction or any form of dollar based transaction, it's using software directly built on top of Consul.
- dralley 3y agoAre there public details about this? Are you referring to the Visa Network or something related?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cthalupa 3y agoI'm assuming you're missing some words here, probably "with Stripe" The idea that every credit card transaction or any form of dollar based transaction works on software directly built on Consul is patently false.
- jen20 3y ago“With Visa or Mastercard” are likely the missing words.
- ckdarby 3y agoThat is not the case unless you're talking about the underlying raft protocol.
- proxysna 3y agoAsk yourself how much of the industry your experience represents. Should answer your question.
- izalutski 3y agoIndeed - but the Terraform community appears to be hit the hardest. Because unlike Consul, there's no open-source hostable anything. It feels just an arbitrary restriction for a language + CLI; the terms of the licence can be viewed as if whatever you ship has Terraform cli embedded, you're in breach. I can see the reason for SPL like Mongo did - it is indeed unfair for AWS to make money off hosted open-source mongodb. But this move by Hashi I'm struggling to wrap my head around
- bityard 3y ago> it is indeed unfair for AWS to make money off hosted open-source mongodb Why? If software authors don't understand that releasing their code under an open source license means someone else other than them may potentially benefit from it, that's really on them.
- hashtag-til 3y agoAuthors do understand the benefits of OSS development. Predatory unethical open source freeloaders don’t.
- _msw_ 3y agoDisclosure: I work for Amazon. Amazon has never offered a database service based on the MongoDB server software. Not when it was AGPLv3 nor when it was SSPLv1.
- redwood 3y agoBut Amazon did copy the software and continues to sow confusion in the community about which is which
- _msw_ 3y agoNo, it didn't copy the software. That's like saying min.io copied S3 software, which would also be false. It implemented a wire protocol for interoperability purposes, similar to functionality in IBM DB2, Azure CosmosDB, FerretDB, and other databases.
- robertlagrant 3y agoThis is why they're having to make these moves. How much value have they given you vs how much have you paid? If the gap is too large, they have to start locking some things down.
- linuxftw 3y agoDo you think Google should lock down the go language and compiler, considering how much value they've given Terraform and likely how little Terraform has paid for go itself?
- alephnerd 3y agoAlphabet doesn't generate revenue from Go. Following your example, Alphabet should open source all the weights they use in their current search algorithm as well as the algorithm itself. And extending that principle, they should also open source the machine translation model and weights Robert DeNero made for them when at Google Translate. Both of these are dumb hypotheticals but serve to point out the fact that there are loss leaders and revenue generators at each company.
- linuxftw 3y agoNo. My point was, companies should make money from services, not software. I believe all software should have a FOSS license.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yellowapple 3y ago> Alphabet doesn't generate revenue from Go. Hashicorp doesn't generate revenue from Terraform. (They do generate revenue from Terraform Cloud, but that's a backend for Terraform, not Terraform itself)
- systemBuilder 3y ago
- rubiquity 3y agoDo you resell services that would be competing with Vault and Consul? If not I don’t see how this applies to your company’s product. Side note: I’m not defending the license change and generally think most of HashiCorp’s products are not that great.
- alephnerd 3y agoYou can't use BSL licensed products in production without paying the provider. Plenty of companies are using Vault and Consul in this manner.
- morgante 3y agoThat is not accurate. BSL does not prevent simply using the products, it prevents packaging them into a competing offering. Review the FAQ here: https://www.hashicorp.com/license-faq https://www.hashicorp.com/license-faq
- yellowapple 3y ago> BSL does not prevent simply using the products, it prevents packaging them into a competing offering. The problem is that "competing offering" is poorly defined.
- gkapur 3y agoDon’t think it’s targeted at Vault. Vault has APIs so in the enterprise, you can self host and a vendor can manage vault through the APIs. Terraform specifically is built CLI only in the OSS so you have to repackage the underlying binary and hence are subject to the license as a vendor.
- igorzij 3y agothat's the most puzzling bit. Do they not want to anyone offering anything that could compete with any of Hashi's products to be able to use terraform binary at all? if so, that's similar to proprietary programming languages. Not a thing. The community can just agree on a similar but open alternative and the original company is left behind. That's why all languages and frameworks are open-source with permissive licenses. and if not, if it's just about the hosted / managed parts - then what exactly is it that I can use wrongly? Terraform Cloud / Enterprise was never open source. There's nothing I can self-host and charge users for...
- gkapur 3y ago> Do they not want to anyone offering anything that could compete with any of Hashi's products to be able to use terraform binary at all? I think they want to make it difficult for SaaS products that embed terraform (or an altered version of terraform I would assume where they have built APIs) in their product. That said, customers can install terraform so you can still hypothetically have an "integration" with Terraform where you call the raw binary (like Atlantis). So basically, they want terraform cloud to have a "privileged" user experience is my guess.
- tetha 3y agoOn the other hand, we wanted to give them money to have a support contract, maybe some yearly architecture reviews or a call with a consultant to point us towards new features. We have similar agreements with e.g. AWS, we're looking at setting something like this up with a postgres consultancy. However, the smallest offering was solidly in the six figures a year. That put it into a very different investment process, the board got involved and you can all guess where it went from there.
- jnsaff2 3y agoI had the same experience, wanted to give them money but not six figures for each service we used.
- Nilithus 3y agoI'm also surprised no one is really mentioning Nomad in this discussion either, I know for a fact circleci used nomad at some point to schedule CI tasks on worker machines. If I create a SaaS product that runs programs which get scheduled with nomad under the hood is that a breach of the license?
- yellowapple 3y ago> I know most HN commentators are thinking about Terraform, but I think this change was done with Consul and Vault in mind. Clearly Terraform was also in mind, since Terraform is now under the BUSL: https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/blob/main/LICENSE https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/blob/main/LICENSE