7 ms·
The life of a lawyer in the late Roman republic
- robga 3y agoWhile interesting, very little of the content is Late Roman. Hard to see why it was tagged as such.
- gostsamo 3y agoThere is a republic somewhere there. Though the text itself lacks certain coherence and a main focus beyond listing people and some details around them.
- thom 3y agoCicero was one of the central figures of the Late Republic (or at least made sure he was seen as such, while others decided the actual fate of Rome). What’s your objection here?
- mywacaday 3y agoIf you have the time the Cicero trilogy(Imperium/Lustrum/Dictator) by Robert Harris are a great read.
- rsynnott 3y agoNearly all of this does seem to be in reference to the late Republic (ie 1st century BCE)
- noam_compsci 3y agoTLDR lawyers became politicians
- A_D_E_P_T 3y agoWhat the article glosses over is that Roman lawyers were nothing at all like today's lawyers. "Lawyers" in Ancient Rome were generally patricians who owed assistance to their cliens. There were no formal schools of law, and the law in Republican Rome was a changeable and largely customary thing, with a considerable religious component. What's more, from 204 BC onwards, these "lawyers" were legally barred from charging for their services, thanks to the Lex Cincia -- but even before, and well after, the passing of that law, it was considered beneath one's dignity to charge for legal counsel and advice. In short, it wasn't a profession. Roman patricians generally knew the customs of Rome, and were capable of advising their vassals, retainers, and various plebians on points of law which reflected those customs. (Where the law was codified, it was extremely clear.) Some of these patrician-lawyers were orators and made pleadings before the court -- most did not, and in most cases pleadings were made directly by the parties involved. Also: In Republican Rome, Judges (judex) were private arbitrators. They were not officials. So it was what we'd call a customary and amateur legal system.
- throwawaylinux 3y agoPrivate legal system with non-profit counsel. Would be interesting to try it again, but no state would ever revert that kind of power to its citizens.
- HeckFeck 3y agoQuite. There is something deeply appealing in making the law much more immediate and accessible to the commons. The labyrinthine system we have today makes me wonder how many people don't bother even when there are genuine disputes and injustices everywhere.
- SanderNL 3y agoI think this is romanticizing the past a bit. I'd hesitate to call it real power as well. You could not just go against someone of let's say senatorial class or god forbid, the Emperor himself, without substantial (military) backing and/or being an untouchable demi-god yourself. Today you can take the government itself to court and actually win. There is to my knowledge no historical precedent for the amount of practical power the common citizenry has over the powerful classes today.
- throwawaylinux 3y agoI think you're romanticizing the present. There is no law that results in monotonic increase in "goodness" of social systems over time. It can appear that way if you look at the past few hundred or thousand years because incredible technological advances do tend to result in more, but that can also mask inequality and injustice on the fringes. Would I prefer to live now than 2000 years ago? Certainly. Is that because of today's systems of governance, rather than today's technology? No. It's a fantasy to believe the ruling class are not in an eternal struggle to take more, or that they have ever only restrained themselves due to the threat of revolt. > I'd hesitate to call it real power as well. You could not just go against someone of let's say senatorial class or god forbid, the Emperor himself, without substantial (military) backing and/or being an untouchable demi-god yourself. I wouldn't hesitate to call it real power. You're trying to make it an all or nothing thing, but it's not. There's a lot of power between cockroach and omnipotent. > Today you can take the government itself to court and actually win. And what does "winning" mean? It means the government decides that it must take some money from other citizens and give it to you.
- arisAlexis 3y agoIf you are into it, read "The Cicero trilogy" , a most amazing series of books of historical fiction.
- dinkleberg 3y agoAgreed, it is a fantastic read.
- ggambetta 3y agoAnything by Robert Harris. I love Fatherland.
- arisAlexis 3y agoI'm reading Act of Oblivion now. He literally transfers you in the specific era.
- 0xffff2 3y agoSadly doesn't seem to be available in e-book format?
- arisAlexis 3y agoYes it is I got it from Amazon on kindle
- 0xffff2 3y agoCould you provide a link? I looked at several variations and all where dead tree only.
- jimmySixDOF 3y agoI just started the 126 1/2 Hour Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire mostly because it is 1 credit on Audible. So far Gibbon is setting the stage but it is clear the many levels of Roman organization is a main factor he credits in thier ability to control such a wide empire. The rights enjoyed varied from who was a real Roman, who was conquered and under what terms, who fought for them, who was enslaved by them, taxed by them, how successful you were in your trade, or how far you were geographically from the centers. The law, and lawyers, had to operate outside the city of Rome in context for each of these factors in each of the lands where it was enforced along with a mixture of the local laws/customs/religion(s). It was their legal flexibility to absorb all these gradients that held the Empire together in its prime.
- OfSanguineFire 3y ago> a main factor he credits I won’t dissuade you from reading (listening) to Gibbon as he is something of a literary classic, but you must always be aware that Gibbon was writing two centuries ago and had his own ideological ax to grind. Historians today, drawing on a wider range of sources than Gibbon had access to, ascribe many developments in Roman history to very different factors than Gibbon claimed. In fact, it is advisable to read several more recent works on Roman history first, so that you are then reading Gibbon purely as a literary classic and not as any authoritative source.
- edgyquant 3y agoAny you’d recommend? I’ve listened to the History of Rome podcast and read SPQR. I’ve thought about Gibbon but it is long and everytime it’s brought up online people say it’s outdated.
- clarionbell 3y agoModern historians have largely gone away with attempts to do works like Gibbon. Perhaps in part because of how his attempt ended up. So if you want to take a look at Roman history in general, you have to dip into popular history. And that is very uneven. Alternatively, you can get books about specific periods, like say late republic, and read those in sequence. But that takes more time. Finally, and this is my preferred approach, get things written by Romans. Yes, they were biased too, and often quite obviously. But at least they didn't have stake in modern society and politics. As long as you pay notice to fact that they are mostly recording either hearsay, or propaganda, you should be fine. In that course I would recommend Twelve Caesars by Suetonius (hearsay) and Commentarii de Bello Gallico by Caesar (propaganda). It's not always true, but it gives you a good idea of how they were thinking, what was their morality like and their values.
- throw0101a 3y agoSee The Medieval Origins of the Legal Profession by Brundage, which has some early chapters on the Roman time period: * https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/M/bo5620943.html https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/M/bo562094... * Review: https://forhistiur.net/2011-05-munzinger/ https://forhistiur.net/2011-05-munzinger/ * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_A._Brundage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_A._Brundage
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoThere's a very good overview of the Ancient Greek legal system here: https://acoup.blog/2023/04/07/collections-how-to-polis-101-part-iic-the-courts/ https://acoup.blog/2023/04/07/collections-how-to-polis-101-p...
- throw0101a 3y agoFor an academic-leaning book on contemporary thinking on it, see Ancient Greek Law in the 21st Century: * https://utpress.utexas.edu/9781477315217/ https://utpress.utexas.edu/9781477315217/ * Review: https://bmcr.brynmawr.edu/2018/2018.10.49/ https://bmcr.brynmawr.edu/2018/2018.10.49/ Did you know that one of the largest banks in Athens was owned / run by two slaves? > Edward E. Cohen returns to the issue of slave-owned businesses previously addressed in his work on Athenian banking, reasserting his view that enslaved business owners were liable for their own debts. Through comparison with the Roman system, he argues that the Athenian conventions of credit worked alongside this legal liability. IIRC, the slaves incorporated the bank, and then the bank (as a legal entity) paid the master of said slaves for the services of the slaves through a leasing arrangement.
- zirgs 3y agoWe can read what some random Roman lawyers did 2000 years ago. But what did people who lived near the Baltic sea do at that time? We have no idea. They might as well have not existed at all as far as historians are concerned.
- clarionbell 3y agoWell they didn't really write a lot, so it's understandable.
- qwytw 3y agoWe're extremely lucky in a way. Others civilization like the Etruscans or the Carthaginians which existed during the time of the Roman republic had an extensive literary tradition (according to the Greeks and Romans) but we have no surviving works written in their languages at all.
- lizardking 3y agoCarthage - FAFO Champions, 149 BC
- sdsd 3y agoWhen I was 16 I lived with my sister for a few months, which were among the best of my life. She was in university and I'd moved in to help her take care of her infant so she wouldn't have to drop out. Anyway, at her university library she got me a book on Cicero. I remember at one point, Cicero in the book travels around asia minor or somewhere trying to collect evidence to make the case for a client. However, he comes to the conclusion later on that facts and evidence don't really matter so much, as creating a compelling narrative.
- billfruit 3y agoSounds a very interesting book, do you remember the title or authour..
- Pigalowda 3y agoMaybe Robert Harris Cicero trilogy? In those it is sicily not Asia Minor. Great books though, I really enjoyed them, especially the first 2.
- sdsd 3y agoIt was nonfiction! In fact, it was in that library 15 years ago, and I think they have a website... However, after a brief search it seems they have a lot of books on Cicero. I was obsessed with Rome (thanks to my high school Latin class) and the name Cicero seemed so cool and elegant to me. I remember I'd stay up all night reading it. But I was such an idiot. At the break of dawn, I'd throw seeds at passersby beneath the window (high window) and yell I AM ELZIO REX OF THE BRITTTOOOONNSSS until my sister yelled at me to stop.
- madethisaccount 3y ago[dead]