5 ms·
How to Roman Republic 101, Part IIIa: Starting Down the Path of Honors
- diego_moita 3y agoI've seen some interest on HN for the Roman Kingdom, Republic and Empire. For a very interesting history of Rome, from the 2 foundation myths (Romulus vs Aeneas) until the end of the "Pax Romana", I strongly suggest the book "SPQR", by Mary Beard. She is a very respected scholar on Ancient Rome and she has a lot of documentaries on Youtube. I just started the famous "Decline and fall of the Roman Empire", by Edward Gibbons, covering the period after the SPQR book. Still in the beginning, to early for conclusions.
- doctorwho42 3y agoDropping my own favorite review of the contributing factors that led to the downfall of the republic and rise of empire: "Storm before the storm".
- philipov 3y agoThat's the book that Mike Duncan wrote following up his work on the History of Rome podcast. The first of the two books he wrote while running the Revolutions podcast, with the second being a biography of Lafayette.
- placesalt 3y agoThe basic premise I got from Mike Duncan's podcast was that: when Rome ran out of dangerous external enemies to fight (ie Carthage), people in Rome found internal enemies to fight. That was fine for a few centuries, until external enemies re-emerged, and then it really fell apart.
- arrosenberg 3y agoEh, kinda. It was more that they overextended themselves and could no longer defend their borders with their citizen-soldiery that expected to be home in time for harvest. Multiyear campaigns and distant conquest required a professional army. Because of that, Marius reformed the army to allow the proletarii in, pay them from the treasury and outfit them from state arsenals and armories. Prior to the reforms, soldiers were patricians and wealthy plebeians who could afford to outfit themselves with equipment and supplies. The wealthy of Rome were not willing to pay for all of this, so the practice was for generals to pay their soldiers out of taxes and loot. Thus the legions became loyal to their generals instead of to the Republic, which essentially made them warlords. There were plenty of places left to conquer - Augustus would somewhat famously and disastrously try to conquer Germania east of the Rhine, Egypt was assimilated after Pompey's defeat, etc.
- philipov 3y agoBoth you and the person you're replying to are correct. These are not mutually exclusive factors. (Well, except the part about egypt: that was assimilated after Anthony and Cleopatra's defeat, not after Pompey's defeat. Caesar allowed Cleopatra to remain a client monarch.) Interestingly, that disasterous campaign you mentioned by Augustus to try to conquer up to the Rhine was done exactly to address the difficulty of defending Rome's extended borders. He felt that it was important for the empire to achieve its natural borders, just the same as France sought to do after the revolution. However, even had those natural borders been secured, it would have done nothing to address the internecine strife that was was instrumental to the decline and final collapse of the western empire. It is necessary to look at a combination of both internal and external pressures to explain what happened.
- diego_moita 3y agoAccording to Ms Beard the most basic cause for the Roman republic downfall was the establishment of private armies. Julius Caesar amassed an enormous military power with his private army on his military campaigns on Gaul and used it to just grab the power in Rome. Truth, it was his nephew Octavian/Augustus that finished and buried the Republic, but he wouldn't be able to do so unless Caesar hadn't given the mortal blow before. No wonder Putin tried to put a leash on Prigozhyn before it would be too late. Also, Imran Khan must understand very well what happens when the military isn't under the government control.
- mmanfrin 3y agoYou're replying to a comment about a book that details the events prior to Julius Caesar, who was at the very end of the republic, not its cause.
- philipov 3y agoThe cause of what? We don't know much about the cause of the republic because any records of that were lost in the first sack of Rome. As for the cause of the fall of the republic, Julius Caesar did not cause those factors to exist, but in him we see the culmination of a hundred years of learning how to abuse the flaws in their civic constitution. He wasn't the first, but he put all the pieces together. In fact, I think he's quite similar to Philip II, who put all the pieces together in Macedon. Alexander the Great was able to reach such heights because he had the way paved for him, the same way Julius Caesar paved the way for Octavian.
- thom 3y agoI don't disagree with the central thesis, and you can argue all sorts of moments for the fall of the Republic, but the establishment of client armies started with Marius, not Caesar. Even then, it was in response to political, economic and military issues which predated even Tiberius Gracchus whose tribunate many use to mark the beginning of the end. Rome's constitution was a marvel, as noted by Polybius, and it granted stability for a long time. But by the time of Sulla (who marched an army into Rome decades before Caesar), all pretence of a government that intended to give equal voice to all factions had disappeared. The idea that Ceasar or Octavian dismantled a functioning or even salvageable republic seems fanciful to me.
- philipov 3y agoCheck out the History of Rome podcast by Mike Duncan if you haven't already. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_History_of_Rome_(podcast) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_History_of_Rome_(podcast)
- Simon_O_Rourke 3y agoI've got total respect for the scholarship of Mary Beard. She got into a recent online argument with one of my other intellectual heroes Nassim Taleb about the genetic makeup of Roman Britain.
- cdcarter 3y agoI have to shout out the “Masters of Rome” series by Colleen Mccullough. It starts with “The First Man in Rome” covering Gaius Marius’ rise to power, and proceeds through the fall of the Republic and the establishing of the Empire. These books are incredibly well researched and informative, but also have SUCH a compelling narrative style and characterizations. It’s very immersive.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoAnd the Historia Civilis series on YouTube.
- User23 3y ago[flagged]
- ggm 3y agoThat's a very pejorative way of saying "I don't agree" and unfortunate in the context of her specifically, since she's been the recipient of foul sexist abuse from her media presence, and even from some of her peers. There's room for scholarly disagreement. There's no need to be nasty. She's not a racist revisionist. Ethnicity across roman times, and the degree of ethnicity in the forces stationed in the british islands is complicated. There is some reason to believe there had been trade links into the islands of greater britain from distant economies long before the Roman invasion, and there were Romans, Auxilliaries, traders and slaves from across the Roman empire into North Africa and the middle east who would have found themselves in the margins, by virtue of the economics and politics of the time: you don't leave conquered peoples in-place if you want to ensure there's no slave revolt, you deploy them elsewhere.
- lmm 3y ago> There is some reason to believe there had been trade links into the islands of greater britain from distant economies long before the Roman invasion, and there were Romans, Auxilliaries, traders and slaves from across the Roman empire into North Africa and the middle east who would have found themselves in the margins, by virtue of the economics and politics of the time All true, and all irrelevant; Middle-Eastern and North African people do not (and did not) have the skin tones that were being depicted in the cartoons in question. > There's room for scholarly disagreement. There's no need to be nasty. She's not a racist revisionist. It wasn't scholarly disagreement, it was deception. She used her erudition and her position to wilfully mislead the less sophisticated; she said things that while literally true were intended to create a false impression in the minds of those reading. That is absolutely something to be condemned in the strongest possible terms; it's very much akin to when a physically strong person uses that strength to bully those weaker than them.
- ggm 3y ago
- cat_plus_plus 3y agoSo sounds like same problem as we have in USA today - complex system that only works if people follow established conventions in addition to codified laws. Like us, Romans probably thought it was not necessary to call out the obvious and then centuries later their successors disregarded the norms and tore the empire apart.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- golergka 3y agoI paint Rome as if it was politically stable, but it was always very far from it. People have been killing each other throughout the republic, and the mere establishment of empire was exactly a blatant disregard for the norms — they essentially got the KING, the one thing that the republic was built to prevent, even if he was called something else. Even two centuries of "Pax romana" were filled with constant bloody struggle for power between nobles, only five good emperors giving some semblance of stability. And after that, crisis of the third century and switch from principate to dominate was even more severe change in these unwritten rules. US, on the other hand, now has 158 years without internal military conflict, so it's doing extremely, unfathomably well by roman standards.
- asdff 3y agoNow imagine if Ft. Sumter happened today. It would be over in a flash but the other way: positions firing onto the fort would be lit up in minutes by ordinance coming out of orbit.
- Kamq 3y agoMy understanding is that political violence was really only an issue that crept up after the killing of Tiberius Gracchus, so you're really only looking at the last century or so of the roman republic.
- thom 3y agoThis isn't really true, given the Conflict of the Orders etc. Even in the Gracchi's case, they were essentially trying to pass land reforms, and Rome had a history of responding to that with violence since at least 486BC. Nobody in Rome's history had a particularly good solution to the central problem that they wanted a massive and expensive army, but didn't want it dominating politics.
- 221qqwe 3y agoIt's interesting that options for Patricians were so severely restricted. After Questorship 2 out 4 Aedile spots were reserved for Plebians and of course they were also barred from being elected as Peoples's Tribunes (10 other spots). Seems like a form of ancient "affirmative action". I guess it's more likely that were able to just skip a step and jump straight to Praetor and the weren't that many Patricians left by the late republic. Then again it's interesting that these laws were instituted in the first place (IIRC one the Consuls had to be a Plebian as well).
- whakim 3y agoThese restrictions originated during the Struggle of the Orders, when the patrician/plebeian distinction was extremely important (at least as far as we can tell - most of our sources for this period were writing much later). By the middle and late Republic (the period which TFA mostly covers), many of the old patrician families seem to have declined making the restrictions much less relevant.
- HDMI_Cable 3y agoI guess the real question is whether those offices were proportionate to the amount of patricians. If there were only 100 patrician families, and by the Middle Republic many of those families had died out, then perhaps the patricians remaining would have found those offices sufficient (even though they shared them with plebians).
- uxp8u61q 3y agoI always find it hilarious when people look at past societies and simply assume they'd have been born in the upper classes. It is overwhelmingly more likely that you'd have been born a plebeian. This isn't "how to roman republic", this is "how to roman republic's aristocracy". It's like larping as a billionaire today. It's fun, but it's a life you'll never have.
- snarkerson 3y agoThis is the tyranny of documentation. We really have little insight into the plebian life. Most direct information comes from funerary inscriptions and graffiti.
- qwytw 3y agoWe do know quite a bit about Cicero (possibly more than about any other Roman) and he was a plebian (just like Gaius Marius, Pompey, Cato (both) etc.)
- resolutebat 3y agoAs Part I of the same series explains, the patrician/plebeian distinction was basically irrelevant by the mid-third century: https://acoup.blog/2023/07/21/collections-how-to-roman-republic-101-part-i-spqr/ https://acoup.blog/2023/07/21/collections-how-to-roman-repub... Of course, you would still need to be born a wealthy plebeian if you wanted to climb the ranks of Roman politics.
- amenhotep 3y agoOf this author's many excellent series, one is about Sparta (https://acoup.blog/category/collections/this-isnt-sparta/ https://acoup.blog/category/collections/this-isnt-sparta/), and it makes this point practically word for word. He is vehement in deconstructing the idea that Sparta is represented by the Spartiates, repeatedly emphasising that the majority were helot slaves who are invisible to history but whose lot we'd be far more likely to share. Your observation stands as a generality but it's somewhat ironic still, making this complaint about a post by a historian who is very very aware of what you're saying.
- deleted 3y ago