3 ms·
I've tested the writing loop you describe and the biggest problem seems to be that currently GPT4 is good at generalities, but gets into loops of generalities t
by vidarh 3y ago
I've tested the writing loop you describe and the biggest problem seems to be that currently GPT4 is good at generalities, but gets into loops of generalities that doesn't drive things forward when you expect too much detail.
It's not that it can't improve the writing further per se, but that it takes very detailed prompting to get it to give a detailed enough critique to do so consistently enough across even a page (e.g. ot might come uo qith a great lone but proceed to edit out the best paragraph elsewhere) to the point that I tend to agree with you in as much as it at least will take a much more convoluted chain of prompts to maybe get there at the moment, and you'll be fighting GPT4s tendency to actively cheer on really juvenile prose the whole way.
In a way I think the biggest hindrance to get it to write better at the moment is that it has awful "taste", and having to explicitly give it a long list of rules to check against is a poor substitute.
As an aide, though, I think you could get reasonable but not great results at "bridge these two paragraphs and maintain the style" type tasks, or expanding descriptions into a paragraph or two, though more so for non-fiction writing.
For fleshing out the basics of a technical spec and pointing out what I've missed I've had decent luck, on the other hand. It's not come up with any Earth shattering revelations, but for a dry spec that's not the point.