5 ms·
I work in operating rooms, and while I think you make a good point, I don’t entirely agree with your comment. I do think that healthcare professionals have a re
by Quinzel 3y ago
I work in operating rooms, and while I think you make a good point, I don’t entirely agree with your comment. I do think that healthcare professionals have a responsibility to be held accountable for their behaviour - and the social medical MedTok thing is disgusting, and ultimately bad for healthcare as an industry that is in the business of caring - because this is exploitation of people who are generally vulnerable in one way or another.
I think using surgery/medical procedures for entertainment is unethical and irresponsible even if consent is given. Firstly in addition to privacy concerns, there is also concerns around being distracted while doing surgery, and infection control risks. For that reason, I don’t think any responsible healthcare practitioners that had their patients well-being at the forefront of their mind would be indulging in that kind of behaviour.
However, I think there is a place for surgery to be shown to the general public, but from an educational perspective for both healthcare professionals that are learning, but also for people to know what happens to their bodies when they have surgery. It should not be some unknown exclusive mystery. (I think the mystery of it is what makes it appealing as a form of entertainment.)
However, I think the sharing of medical procedures should be done responsibly, and accurately, and not for entertainment - which has a tendency to overdramatise things, or misrepresent things.
My biggest daily drama in an operating room is actually often dealing with the anxiety patients have around coming in for their procedures because what they expect to happen is so warped by biased representation’s of what happens in operating rooms.
I think the article does bring to light some issues in healthcare being used as a form of entertainment
- BSEdlMMldESB 3y agoyour comment reminds me of this very dark comedy skit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MR76R4gaC48 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MR76R4gaC48
- Quinzel 3y agoYeah that was quite dark. Also though, there was a case of a surgeon using diathermy to brand his initials onto patients organs. https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2022/01/13/doctor-branded-liver/# https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2022/01/13/doctor-bran... My personal experience is that some surgeons (definitely not all of them) are particularly prone to suffering from hubris - at which point they genuinely believe they can do anything they want and it’ll be fine, and god have mercy on anyone who tries to tell them they’re wrong.
- bombcar 3y agoYou almost have to have some bit of hubris to think “I’m going to cut open this living human and he will survive and I will be paid for doing so.”
- jollyllama 3y agoPeople have known this for a while. See the film "Malice" and Alec Baldwin's "I am God" diatribe.
- dashundchen 3y ago> However, I think there is a place for surgery to be shown to the general public, but from an educational perspective for both healthcare professionals that are learning, but also for people to know what happens to their bodies when they have surgery. Absolutely. Obviously not for every patient as some are more squeamish than others. I recently underwent a surgical procedure. It was great to be able to find several recorded procedures on YouTube. The videos were recorded in an academic context rather than sensational clickbait, it definitely made going into the procedure easier.