4 ms·
> Of all the posts I ignore on social media… the ones I ignore most thoroughly these days, almost with a vengeance, are the results of prompts to AI chatbots. T
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Of all the posts I ignore on social media… the ones I ignore most thoroughly these days, almost with a vengeance, are the results of prompts to AI chatbots. The tell-tale fonts and formats of these posts allow me to spot them instantly…
Factually (other than screenshots of the UI of a particular known web frontend), no, “fonts and formats” won’t tell you that at all.
> Part of what bugs me about these documents, whether they’re generated in the form of college essays, poems, newspaper articles, or screenplays, is the implication that they’re ingenious, and that the people who ordered them are ingenious by association. But I am underwhelmed by the performances. When you consider that the human race has moved the ball of language down the field for millennia upon millennia using nothing but its throats and tongues and sticks with ink and graphite on their tips, the idea that advanced computer networks are able to kick the ball into the net repeatedly and with little effort, in all kinds of showy ways, isn’t as impressive as it’s made out to be.
This criticism seems to be based on the premise that “advanced computer networks” are fundamentally and obviously more advanced than the combination of “throats and tongues and sticks with ink and graphite on their tips” and, implied but unstated, brains that humans are equipped with, such that the former being able to do what has in the past been done by the latter is trivial.
It is, essentially, implicitly assuming artificial superintelligence has not only been achieved, but is already widely acknowledged to be achieved, and thus that it is simply trivially obvious and unimpressive that the systems involved should be able to do well at language tasks that humans have done in the past with their less-advanced tools. Otherwise, dismissal on the grounds stated makes no sense at all.
And I agree that, yes, if you buy into AI hype much more than even most of the really enthusiastic hypesters themselves propose, yes, all of the accomplishments of modern LLMs would be trivial. But that’s a dismissal of the specific results that requires a ludicrous view of both the factual and widely perceived general capabilities of the involved systems.
- tedunangst 3y agoFactually, people do post readily identifiable screenshots.
- evan_ 3y agoA lecturer I know showed me a PDF one of their postgraduate students turned in- every line had a light gray background the same color as the default light-mode ChatGPT interface background.
- mcphage 3y ago> It is, essentially, implicitly assuming artificial superintelligence has not only been achieved, but is already widely acknowledged to be achieved, and thus that it is simply trivially obvious and unimpressive that the systems involved should be able to do well at language tasks that humans have done in the past with their less-advanced tools. More like a recognition that structural text generation doesn’t need artificial superintelligence, and so what we’re left with is a text generator, and… well so what?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]