7 ms·
Bad writing can be fine if it expresses interesting ideas or a unique point of view. Banal ideas can be fine when they're exceptionally well written. Badly wri
by tptacek 3y ago
Bad writing can be fine if it expresses interesting ideas or a unique point of view. Banal ideas can be fine when they're exceptionally well written. Badly written banalities can be tolerable when they're not proliferating, and when they're accompanied by better stuff.
What we have now though is a firehose of badly written banality, with companies using LLMs to predict huge numbers of Google queries and generate the matching pages. That strategy had a name back in the heyday of SEO: "content spinning". It wasn't a good thing.
It's not that complicated an issue. It's the same reason we flag ChatGPT copy off the site here.
- micromacrofoot 3y agosome use a hammer to build a house, some use a hammer to tear it down
- simonw 3y agoI think it is a complicated issue. I agree that content spinning garbage is harmful to society. But... someone who has English as a second language being able to write a letter to an organization that still insists on written letters for things feels like a big win to me. The open question for me is if the positive applications of ChatGPT-for-writing will outweigh the negative applications. I'm currently still optimistic.
- tptacek 3y agoAbsolutely. I'm thinking mostly of the things "professional writers" complain about; I think "professional writers" are, for the most part, in the right about this stuff.
- crabmusket 3y ago> being able to write a letter to an organization that still insists on written letters for things Maybe I'm especially attuned to this due to my personal biases, but I see a lot of cases where AI is the "solution" to a problem that shouldn't exist. A real nuisance from my dayjob involves using AI to parse information out of PDF datasheets. If manufacturers would provide machine-readable datasheets, we could simply write code. But no, they for some reason only provide awfully-formatted PDFs at best, forcing the burden onto everyone aside from themselves, the people who have the data already. It's wonderful that we can make AI do this tedious and difficult data entry work now. But the problem should not exist in the first place.
- simonw 3y agoYeah, absolutely. I expect we'll increasingly notice that LLMs are being applied as stop-gap solutions to problems that would ideally be solved some other way.