6 ms·
Is there any evidence this would even work? Surely Google determines "fresh, relevant" content according to whatever has recently been published, which this do
by crazygringo 3y ago
Is there any evidence this would even work?
Surely Google determines "fresh, relevant" content according to whatever has recently been published, which this doesn't change. If anything, doesn't Google consider sites with a long history of content with tons of inbound links as more authoritative and therefore higher-ranked?
This baffles me. It baffles me why this would be successful SEO -- and assuming that it actually isn't, it baffles me why CNET thinks it would be.
- SoftTalker 3y agoPerhaps sites with a small ratio of new:total content would be downranked --- but I really don't think that makes sense because that's going to be the case for any long-established site.
- laweijfmvo 3y agoI have noticed some articles (and not just "Best XXX of 202Y" articles) that seem to always update their "Updated on" date which Google unhelpfully picks up and shows in search results leading me to think the page is much more recent than it is.
- burnhamup 3y agoThe theory I've heard is related to 'crawl budget'. Google is only going to devote a finite amount of time to indexing your site. If the number of articles on your site exceeds that time, some portion of your site won't be indexed. So by 'pruning' undesirable pages, you might boost attention on the articles you want indexed. No clue how this ends up working in practice. Google's suggestion isn't to delete pages, but maybe mark some pages with a no index header. https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/large-site-managing-crawl-budget https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/...
- nevi-me 3y agoIt could be better to opt those articles out of the crawler. Unless that's more effort. If articles included the year and month in the URL prefix, I would disallow /201* instead.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoEven if that rule were true, why wouldn’t everything in the say, top NNN internet sites get an exemption? It is the Internet’s most hit content, why would it not be exhaustively indexed? Alternatively, other than ads, what is changing on a CNN article from 10 years ago? Why would that still be getting daily scans?
- kenjackson 3y agoThat's a good point about the static nature of some pages. Is there any way to tell a crawler to crawl this page, but after this date don't crawl again, but keep anything you previously crawled.
- bhandziuk 3y agoCNET* not CNN. But everything you say is still true.
- em-bee 3y agothe ads are different. i am tracking rss feeds of many sites, and on some i get notifications for old articles because something irrelevant in the page changed.
- progmetaldev 3y agoProbably bad technology detecting a change. Things like current news showing up beneath the article, which changes whenever a new article is added. I've seen this happen on quite a few large websites. It might be technologically easier to drop old articles than the amount of time to fix whatever they use to determine if a page has changed. You would think a site like CNET wouldn't have to deal with something like that, but sometimes these sites that have been around for a long time have some serious outdated tech.
- 3y ago
- meragrin_ 3y ago> It baffles me why this would be successful SEO -- and assuming that it actually isn't, it baffles me why CNET thinks it would be. If the content deleted is garbage, why wouldn't it help? No clue on CNET's overall quality, but I don't have a favorable image of it. Just had a look at their main page and that did not do it any favors.
- not_kurt_godel 3y agoBecause the remaining content is also garbage (probably even worse garbage gauging by the trends I observed before I started ignoring CNET altogether)
- ReflectedImage 3y agoSeveral reasons why it works. First is the page rank algorithm will give the other pages on the site a higher score. Per the spec. Second is there could be spam links pointing to old CNET articles that need to be wiped from CNETs site spam score.
- snowwrestler 3y agoIn a major site redesign a couple years ago, we dropped 3/4 of our old URLs, and saw a big improvement in SEO metrics. I know it doesn’t make sense and that Google says it is not necessary. But it clearly worked for us. I think a fundamental truth about Google Search is that no one understands how it actually works anymore, including Google. They announce search algorithm updates with specific goals… and then silently roll out tweaks, more updates, etc. when the predicted effect doesn’t show up. I think the idea that Google is in control and all the SEOs are just guessing, is wrong. I think it’s become a complex enough ML system that now all anyone can do is observe and adjust, including Google.
- seydor 3y agoWhich SEO metrics?
- snowwrestler 3y agoWe ranked higher for more keywords and traffic from organic search went up.