3 ms·
No, that still doesn't make sense. The loss discount was on a per-trip basis, not per hand, so basically if at the end of the week you were down $100k, you only
by TylerE 15y ago
No, that still doesn't make sense. The loss discount was on a per-trip basis, not per hand, so basically if at the end of the week you were down $100k, you only owed $80k.
The rules were generous but NOT totally even. The house still had around 0.25%, which is low, but not unheard of. Even on the Vegas strip you can find Blackjack games open to the general public under 0.50% house edge. Of course, that's
with optimum general strategy, not "playing your hunches", which could easily open the house edge to 10% or more depending on how dumb you're playing.
My guess is that he was card counting, but not with a traditional system, and he wasn't using it to size his bets, just to make strategy decisions, which would be harder to detect.
The odds of beating 3 separate casinos, over a reasonable number of hands, even against a very low house edge, are quite small.
- bootload 15y ago"... The odds of beating 3 separate casinos, over a reasonable number of hands, even against a very low house edge, are quite small. ..." what about the MIT Blackjack team? (I assume you're refering to Blackjack) ~ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXR5sKR3f-E&feature=related https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXR5sKR3f-E&feature=rela...
- TylerE 15y agoThey were counters. I meant the odds of beating 3 casinos without counting, which is that the article was claiming.
- bootload 15y ago"... They were counters. I meant the odds of beating 3 casinos without counting ..." from the article it looks like pre-counting (odds) using software isn't factored or detected.
- ImprovedSilence 15y agoI agree, but it appears that while he doesn't "count", He plays a more general "averages" game. Per the article: "More useful, for his purposes, is running a smaller number of hands and paying attention to variation. The way averages work, the larger the sample, the narrower the range of variation. " Edit: I would guess he's developed some algorithm for keeping track of swings and general variation, so he plays not hand by hand the way counting goes, but rather "batch" or "streak" While will also have wild swings of him making and losing lots of money, but if he keeps tabs on these variations, he can swing them in his favor over time.
- gamble 15y agoProbably the best evidence for your argument is the fact that he apparently negotiated a hand-shuffled shoe. I'm amazed anyone would agree to it, since it's pretty much a giant warning sign that the guy is planning to exploit poor shuffles.
- dsrguru 15y agoThe shuffles needn't be poor. The existence of the hand-shuffled shoe just means he has the opportunity to count or shuffle track. The former is impossible if they use a continuous shuffle machine and I imagine the latter is either impossible or too difficult to use effectively. I agree it makes no sense for the casino to agree to that if that's outside their normal rules. I guess they want high rollers to think they've got an edge, but the casinos realize that most high rollers don't actually know how to count fast enough to realize that edge. And until this guy, they've always been able to identify the successful advantage players (not counting group players a la the MIT blackjack team) before losing millions of dollars...
- danbmil99 15y agoanother factor: as an inside guy, he probably knew their precise algorithm for catching counters. I suspect he does count, but knows exactly how to vary his play to keep just south of the model targeting him as a counter.
- thesis 15y agoWhat are you talking about? A CEO got fired because of this. Anyone and everyone was watching this guy.
- danbmil99 15y agoWhat I'm saying is, they have mathematical models that they follow to decide whether someone is counting. I suspect this guy was in fact using information about cards played to vary his future bets -- in effect counting, but he was doing it in a way that did not fit the house's models for what card counters normally do. He clearly knew more than the people who were watching him, so the fact that all the 'experts' were paying attention doesn't mean he wasn't following a winning strategy.
- jyu 15y agoIt depends on the number of hands he played. As it mentions in the article, the house edge is based on billions of simulated hands. If he played nonstop for 1 week, that is at most 14,000 hands (100 hands/hr x 20 hrs/day x 7 days). Card counting or not, this is a statistically insignificant number of hands. This article describes someone with a lot of money playing blackjack with bad bankroll management who quit while he was ahead.
- TylerE 15y agoThe std. deviation of blackjack is quite low. 14,000 hands would be a fairly large sample for blackjack, for live hands. Now if we were talking about something like video poker, then yea, 14k hands would be nothing.
- zone411 15y agoNo, you are hugely underestimating variance in blackjack and the amount of hands needed to approach statistical significance. If you do the math, you should see that after 14,000 hands with 0.25% house edge, the chance of a gain is around 40%.
- TylerE 15y agoGiven a chance of being up of 40%, the chance of being up (and this is ignoring the magnitude of the win) over 3 separate trials is 6.4%.
- vannevar 15y agoThe odds of beating 3 separate casinos, over a reasonable number of hands, even against a very low house edge, are quite small. No one is writing stories about the millions of other high rollers who lost. It's entirely possible his outcome was driven entirely by chance alone. No card counting, no special expertise other than knowing the odds of the game. Just sheer luck. Unfortunately, that doesn't make for a very interesting read.