4 ms·
If I understand correctly, I am writing a review of a review of a book about the Iliad. But we can only read so many books. If we had to choose, would we just
by acyou 3y ago
If I understand correctly, I am writing a review of a review of a book about the Iliad.
But we can only read so many books. If we had to choose, would we just read a translation of the original Iliad instead of a book about it? This is why we should be thankful for a physical bookshelf, it allows us to skip these steps and just pick up the book.
I don't think we need to be too concerned with the particular translation of the Iliad, I think the older the better as long as one can still properly read it. I think a certain amount of reading into the poem is required regardless.
To be more precise, this book would do all of the reading into the poem that I want to do. I want to read into it myself and draw my own conclusions! (To the extent that it's possible).
- nerdponx 3y agoI don't think there's anything wrong with people writing down their own thoughts about great works of literature like the Iliad. What I really do appreciate are the people who review such writings-down so that I can make an informed decision about whether their thoughts are worth my time to read. In this case, I imagine that any book analyzing the Iliad is intended for readers who have already themselves read the Iliad at least once.